Daniel J. Abbott

First, Petey

Religion EN ↓ 46 episodes

These episodes are drawn from a growing collection of essays I’ve written in Christian apologetics. taking up questions at the intersection of Scripture, Church history, and theology, with the aim of bringing clarity where there is confusion, depth where there is surface-level understanding, and posing thought provoking questions to challenge pre-concieved notions in pursuit of the truth. The heart of this project is not simply argument for argument’s sake, but a genuine search for truth: truth about God, about the Church He founded, and about how faith speaks into the real world we live in. S...

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: firstpetey.podbean.com

Author

Daniel J. Abbott

Category

Religion

Podcast website

firstpetey.podbean.com

Latest episode

Oct 30, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

#21 Can Sola Scriptura survive "The Wilderness Test"? 06.02.2026

Misinterpretation of God's word has been the move since Genesis 3, If the devil can weaponize verses, what protects the faithful? Jesus answers each temptation with the word in its true sense. Can sola Scriptura deliver that same certainty? or does the New Testament point somewhere else? 

#20 Proof the Reformation was from God: error 404 30.01.2026

In the words of St. Francis De Sales “Show me your miracles, or show me your mission; otherwise, I cannot believe you are sent from God.” When God turns a page in salvation history, He leaves fingerprints. This episode asks whether the 16th-century protestant reformation has any.

#19 Sola Scriptura vs the Church 23.01.2026

Can “Scripture alone” erase the Church that received and canonized Scripture? Today we test sola Scriptura on logic: canon certainty, who decides disputes, and effect vs. cause. This episode covers Chesterton’s “procession,” plus constitution and music analogies. Not anti-Bible, but rather pro-Incarnation.

#18 Did the Catholic Church Ban Vernacular Bibles? 16.01.2026

This episode challenges the popular claim that the Catholic Church “kept the Bible from the people,” arguing instead for a consistent pattern of access with fidelity. What if the usual narrative is missing something essential? Today we explore how access and authority relate, and why it matters more than ever, from the Vulgate’s vernacular origins, to William Tyndale, to a modern case study on why...

#17 Women, Pastries, and the meaning of it all 09.01.2026

An exploration of how language can drift from reality, and what happens when words keep their sound but lose their substance. Even tiny redefinitions can alter our thinking, our life together, and even our sense of right and wrong. The question then becomes: what keeps language, and by proxy us, anchored to reality? What guards truth when words become negotiable?

#16 Define "Unbiblical" 02.01.2026

What makes a doctrine “unbiblical”? Silence? contradiction? lack of inference? or something else? This episode compares the leading approaches across Protestant schools of thought on the issue and then contrasts them with the older rule of faith that guided the Church’s reading from the start. What has to be in place for “biblical” to be more than a personal label? The answer, inevitably reshapes...

#15 The Strains of Double Predestination 26.12.2025

What happens when a theology built on divine sovereignty begins to strain under its own weight? Can a system meant to defend God’s glory and power end up distorting His goodness? This episode explores the tension that has divided Christians for centuries: can Calvinism (or Reformed theology more broadly) withstand the strain of the “Big Three” (Scripture, history, and the very character of God Him...

#14 The Calvinist Collapse into Double Predestination 19.12.2025

Is “passing over” just softer language, or a real theological difference? This episode examines whether Calvinism’s own commitments force the conclusion most modern adherents avoid naming.

#13 Judas, Calvinism, Mary and Catholicism 12.12.2025

Can rejection and surrender both serve God’s design without collapsing freedom into fate? Judas and Mary stand as living questions at the center of salvation history, today we look at how Calvinism and Catholicism handle the narrative of both

#12 Social Media and Sainthood 05.12.2025

What does it mean to pursue sainthood in the age of endless scrolling? This episode unpacks the harms and goods of social media, Augustine’s timeless insights, and how to re-order our loves toward God in the digital world.

#11 The slippery slope of Sola to Solo Scriptura 28.11.2025

Church-hopping is normal, disagreements are constant, and authority often feels optional. In this episode, we ask: does Protestant life today actually look like Sola Scriptura—or has it always been Solo in disguise?

#10 AI and the Age of Ultron 21.11.2025

From calculators to modern chatbots, lets explore what machines actually do versus what we project onto them.

#9 Can *YOU* Say I'm Wrong? 14.11.2025

Can you really say “I’m right and you’re wrong” without appealing to a higher authority? Through the “spot the ball” metaphor and concrete controversies, we probe Protestant and Catholic models of authority and the New Testament’s pattern for settling doctrinal disputes.

#8 Debating The Doctrine I can't pronounce (Perspicuity) 07.11.2025

This episode stress-tests the promise that “the gospel is clear and unanimously held” across Protestantism. We compare rival answers on baptism, perseverance, and the nature of saving faith, then explore the Catholic proposal of Scripture, Tradition, and Magisterium as a living authority. If the essentials are clear, why hasn’t clarity produced unity?

#7 Take me to Your Leader! 31.10.2025

Hebrews 13:17 says “obey your leaders,” but who are they? Who appoints them, and what proves they’re legit?

#6 Historic Protestantism VS Non-denom: The Pot Calling the Kettle Black 24.10.2025

Five centuries of Protestant structure vs. fifty years of non-denom agility. Does longevity equal legitimacy? 

#5 the Pointer Finger Problem 17.10.2025

This essay presses the “index” question beneath sola scriptura: If Scripture is the only infallible norm, which writings are scripture to begin with, and how do we know? This episode tests whether self-attestation and reception suffice, or whether a magisterium is necessary to fix the boundary of Scripture. 

#4 The Man-Made Asseveration 10.10.2025

For many Protestants, the word “tradition” feels like a warning label which precedes some unbiblical or man made teaching. But what if the New Testament treats some traditions as dangerous—and others as commanded? What if the real question isn’t “tradition or Bible,” but the question is rather which traditions are from Christ—and who says so?

#3 Motivated Reasoning and Confirmation Bias 03.10.2025

Before the speck comes the log. A short reflection on how identity, habit, and the feed shape what we “see”—and why certainty can feel easier than truth—plus a gentle case for making accuracy-motivated reasoning the aim. If we adjusted the lens first, what might change?

#2 Why Should We Care? (Theological relativism) 26.09.2025

"It's a relationship, not a religion!" is "Anything goes" a valid stance? Today I take a brief look into Theological Relativism, authority claims and how they stack up historically

#1 Why Should I Care? (Apatheism) 20.09.2025

“If it works for you, it must be true.” But is that really the case? Join me as we examine the claim that all paths are equal and ask what it means to seek the highest good.

Listen to the First, Petey podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.