Daniel J. Abbott

First, Petey

Religion EN ↓ 46 episodes

These episodes are drawn from a growing collection of essays I’ve written in Christian apologetics. taking up questions at the intersection of Scripture, Church history, and theology, with the aim of bringing clarity where there is confusion, depth where there is surface-level understanding, and posing thought provoking questions to challenge pre-concieved notions in pursuit of the truth. The heart of this project is not simply argument for argument’s sake, but a genuine search for truth: truth about God, about the Church He founded, and about how faith speaks into the real world we live in. S...

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: firstpetey.podbean.com

Author

Daniel J. Abbott

Category

Religion

Podcast website

firstpetey.podbean.com

Latest episode

Oct 30, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

#46 Subjective Faith: Private Judgment and the Collapse of Protestant Authority (Full Series) 30.10.2026

Is Protestantism Subjective? In this complete series, I examine the role of private judgment within the Protestant framework and ask a foundational question: When Christians disagree over the meaning of Scripture, where does the final authority actually lie? Across three parts, we examine Protestantism as it exists today, return to the roots of the Protestant Reformation itself, and finally ask wh...

#45 Subjective Faith, Part 3: Is Protestantism Inescapably Subjective? 23.10.2026

Concluding the series, we turn from the past and present toward the future: Is Protestantism inescapably subjective? If the Protestant Reformation was justified in rejecting the authority of the visible Church on the basis of Scripture, what prevents every future Christian from doing the same? In this episode, I argue that private judgment is not merely something Protestantism has historically str...

#44 Subjective Faith, Part 2: Is Protestantism Fundamentally Subjective 16.10.2026

Continuing the series, in Part 2 we return to the roots of the Protestant Reformation, circling back to the foundational question upon which everything else is built: Was the Protestant Reformation justified? Was Luther in the right? Can he be? In this episode, I argue that the subjectivity examined throughout this series is not merely a consequence of what Protestantism became, but something pres...

#43 Subjective Faith, Part 1: Is Protestantism Intrinsically Subjective? 09.10.2026

In Part 1 of Subjective Faith, we examine four broad expressions of Protestant authority, from Solo Scriptura and low-church evangelicalism to confessional Protestantism and high-church Prima Scriptura, and ask whether any ultimately escapes the problem of private judgment. The central question is simple: Is there any authority within Protestantism capable of issuing a doctrinal “No” that the indi...

#42 Intro to "Subjective Faith: Private Judgment and the Collapse of Protestant Authority" 02.10.2026

Every Protestant denomination claims to follow the Bible. Calvinists, Arminians, Baptists, Lutherans, Presbyterians, Pentecostals, Anglicans, and non-denominational Christians all appeal to Scripture... yet... they often arrive at mutually exclusive conclusions... So... who is right? And more importantly: by what authority does anyone decide? This episode introduces Subjective Faith: Private Judgm...

#41 Does Baptism Save You? 1 Peter 3:21 31.07.2026

Does baptism actually save? In 1 Peter 3:21, the apostle Peter says plainly: “Baptism… now saves you.” But across (modern) Christianity, that verse is interpreted in radically different ways. In this episode, we put the three major views of baptism to the test: the historic sacramental view, the covenantal means-of-grace view, and the symbolic ordinance view. Which one best fits the text? Which on...

#40 The True Church, According to Scripture, History, and Reason (Complete Series) 19.06.2026

The True Church, According to Scripture, History, and Reason (Complete Series) brings together the full argument from Episode 30 through Parts 1–9 into one six-hour deep dive on one of the most important questions in Christianity: What is the Church that Jesus Christ actually founded? The series begins with the question of why “I just follow Jesus” is not enough by itself. If Jesus founded a Churc...

#39 The True Church, Part 9: Overview and Closing remarks 12.06.2026

This episode serves as a full overview and closing summary of the entire True Church series, bringing together the central arguments from each part into one place. The series began by asking what the true Church must look like according to Scripture, identifying the biblical marks of the Church Christ founded: visible unity, apostolic authority, sacramental life, continuity, and the promises Chris...

#38 The True Church, Part 8: The Papacy, According to History 05.06.2026

If the Papacy is truly part of the Church Christ founded, it shouldn’t just appear centuries later, it should leave traces in the earliest Christian record. In this episode, we turn to the first 200–300 years of Christianity to examine whether the historical Church functioned with a recognizable center of unity. Rather than assuming later developments, we’re looking for the seed form, the earliest...

#37 The True Church, Part 7: The Papacy, According to Scripture (2/2) 29.05.2026

Is the Papacy actually found in Scripture, or is it something read back into the text later? In Part 7 of this series on the True Church, we move from objections to evidence, examining whether the New Testament itself presents Peter in a uniquely structured role among the apostles. Using four key biblical “litmus tests,” this episode explores: Whether Peter is singled out in a meaningful way Wheth...

#36 The True Church, Part 6: The Papacy, According to Scripture (1/2) 22.05.2026

This episode marks the scriptural turning point in The True Church series. In Part 6, we begin the biblical case for the Papacy by asking a foundational question: is there anything in the New Testament that actually contradicts it? Before building a positive case, we test the strongest objections, whether Peter is just one apostle among equals, whether Christ alone being head excludes any visible...

#35 The True Church, Part 5: The Papacy, According to Reason 15.05.2026

Is the Papacy a later invention… or a built-in necessity for Christian unity? In this episode, we lay down the logical foundation for the Papacy before turning to the text. If Christ willed one visible Church, how does that Church avoid deadlock, competing authorities, and endless schism? We walk through the “final court of appeal” problem, answer the common objections (“Peter wasn’t supreme,” “co...

#34 The True Church Part 4: The Great Apostasy 08.05.2026

If Jesus Christ founded one true Church, what happened to it? In this episode, we take the biblical, historical, and logical criteria established in Parts 1–3 and apply them to the major alternatives: Restorationist movements (Mormonism, Jehovah’s Witnesses, Seventh-day Adventists, and Stone-Campbell churches) and Protestantism as a whole. We examine key questions surrounding the Great Apostasy, a...

#33 The True Church, Part 3: According to History 01.05.2026

If Christ truly founded a Church, what happened to it after the apostles died? In Part 1, we defined the biblical blueprint: twelve scriptural marks of the True Church. In Part 2, we followed the logic wherever it led and saw that this Church must be visible, authoritative, unified, and sacramental. Now in Part 3, we test that conclusion against history. Turning to the earliest Christian witnesses...

#32 The True Church Part 2: According to reason 24.04.2026

In Episode 31, we laid out the biblical blueprint for the Church Christ founded. In this episode, we take the next step and ask what those biblical claims logically require. Can the true Church be invisible, fragmented, or loosely authoritative and still satisfy Christ’s commands and promises? In Part 2 we examine several common objections and show why the New Testament points not to a vague spiri...

#31 The True Church, Part 1: According to Scripture 17.04.2026

How do you identify the Church Christ actually founded? In a world of endless denominations, competing doctrines, and hundreds of church signs on every corner, which Church is the one described in Scripture? In Part 1 of this 9-part series, we begin where every serious Christian must begin: the New Testament itself. By examining both the direct and indirect ways Scripture speaks about the Church,...

#30 The True Church, Introduction: Why "I Just Follow Jesus" Isn’t Enough 10.04.2026

Many self professed Christians claim allegiance to Christ while rejecting any concrete church authority. But does that posture actually align with the New Testament? In this episode, we test the logical and biblical coherence of “churchless Christianity” and ask whether following Jesus can ever mean standing apart from the Church He established.

#29 Matthew 16 and the Papacy 03.04.2026

Many Christians reject the papacy because they don’t see a fully formed Vatican I Papacy in the New Testament. But what if that expectation misunderstands how divine institutions begin? This episode lays out the five major interpretations of Matthew 16 and subjects each one to the same textual tests to determine which reading of Matthew 16 allows the text to speak most naturally, and which require...

#28 Do Catholics Worship Idols? 27.03.2026

The charge that Catholics worship idols is one of the most common (and least examined) claims made against the Church. This essay argues that the accusation collapses once worship, honor, and symbolism are properly defined. What looks convincing at a glance fails under careful analysis.

#27 Proof that the Catholic Church is from God: 200 OK 20.03.2026

What kind of evidence should Christians expect if God truly founded a visible, sacramental Church? By examining Catholic-distinctive miracles across history, this episode explores how different theologies generate different evidential profiles. This essay does not argue that any single miracle proves Catholicism. Instead, it examines patterns, expectations, and explanatory coherence across centuri...

#26 John 20:23 and the Ministry of Reconciliation 13.03.2026

John 20:23 is one of the most direct and disputed lines in the New Testament: “Whose sins you forgive are forgiven.” Is Jesus talking about preaching? Church discipline? Mutual forgiveness? Or a real ministerial authority to absolve sins? In this episode, I compare five common interpretations, track how the earliest Christians received and practiced this text, and argue that the historic sacrament...

#25 The Incoherence of Love in Calvinism 06.03.2026

What if the biggest problem with Calvinism isn’t justice or sovereignty, but love itself? Can a theology be true if it requires Christians to love more universally than the God who is Love? This episode takes a hard look at that dilemma, and follows that question to its logical conclusion.

#24 Vain Repetitions, Repetitions, Repetitions... 27.02.2026

Repetition is the mother of learning, yet some point to Matthew 6:7 to say we ought not repeat prayers, this episode takes a look at the biblical and historical support for such a claim.

#23 Did Jesus actually claim to be God? 20.02.2026

What would a claim to be God have sounded like in the first century? Is it reasonable to demand “say it our way,” or is that the wrong test? Would it need a sentence, or could actions say it better? What’s a fair standard to use across time? 

#22 Do Christians, Jews, and Muslims worship the same God? 13.02.2026

Is it possible to be wrong about something while still talking about the same thing? Same word, same reality… or not? This episode maps the line between identity and interpretation. Short, sharp, and a little mind-bendy, but a Superman reference makes it all worth it.

Listen to the First, Petey podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.