Joe McReynolds and Dan Kewley

File 187 True Crime Podcast

True Crime EN ↓ 7 episodes

Buried in God’s CountryWhen two women vanish on their way to pick up children from a rural Oklahoma home, the search uncovers something far more chilling than a custody dispute. Beneath the quiet plains lies a radical belief system one where religion, control, and anti-government paranoia collide. This episode digs into a brutal double murder carried out by people who believed they were doing God’s will and a community forced to reckon with the extremism growing right next door.

Author

Joe McReynolds and Dan Kewley

Category

True Crime

Podcast website

www.file187.com

Latest episode

Jun 18, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Blood and Soil - Episode 3 “The Money" 18.06.2026

Blood and Soil | Episode 3: "The Money" In 1984, Robert Mathews and The Order robbed a Brinks truck on a California highway and walked away with $3.6 million. The men went to prison. The money went to work. Episode 3 traces how white nationalist financing evolved from armed robbery to donor-advised funds at Fidelity and Vanguard, a Christian crowdfunding platform that raised over six million dolla...

Blood and Soil - Episode 2 “The Machine" 16.04.2026

Before The Order ever acted, someone else built the blueprint. In Episode Two, we trace how white nationalist ideology separated from organization and became infrastructure , from a physics professor's West Virginia farmhouse to the private servers recruiting teenagers tonight. The compound was a prototype. What replaced it has no address.

Blood and Soil - Episode 1: "The Declaration" 24.03.2026

Blood and Soil — Episode One: "The Declaration" In 1983, nine men stood in a field in Idaho and swore an oath. Eighteen months later, one of them was dead in a burning house. The rest were in federal custody. The FBI called it a victory. They were wrong. This is the story of what happens when ideology becomes identity. When grievance becomes theology. When ordinary people become capable of extraor...

Case 4: The Slavemaster 03.02.2026

Before dating apps, before social media, there was a man who hunted through a modem. John Edward Robinson known online as Slavemaster. He used contracts, kindness, and the illusion of consent to trap women seeking connection. What police found on his farm wasn’t just murder… it was an archive. This is the chilling, fully-solved true story of how trust became a weapon and how the internet learned i...

Case 3: The Widow-maker. Merry Xmas 25.12.2025

A few days after Christmas, a quiet Midwestern town wakes up to a nightmare. A wife is found dead. A husband calls 911 in panic. And a friend steps forward… smiling. What follows is a true crime story so twisted it feels scripted  but every word is real. The Widowmaker is the chilling case of Pam Hupp, a woman who didn’t look like a monster, didn’t act like a killer, and didn’t run when the blood...

Case 2: Satan’s Carnival - A Halloween True Crime Event 30.10.2025

File 187: Satan’s Carnival peels back the panic, the headlines, and the faith-fueled fear that gripped a Midwestern town convinced the Devil came to visit on Halloween week. A traveling carnival rolls into the quiet farm town of Auburn, Indiana lights, music, and strangers promising a weekend of fun. By the time the Ferris wheel stops turning, a young waitress has vanished, and what’s left behind...

Case 1: Buried in God’s Country 20.09.2025

In God’s Country Two women vanish on the backroads of rural Oklahoma — a place where church steeples pierce the sky and secrets fester in the soil. What begins as a simple trip to pick up children spirals into a nightmare of cult ties, family betrayals, and a community bound by silence. In God’s Country unravels the haunting story of faith turned weapon, where loyalty is tested, lives are shattere...

Listen to the File 187 True Crime Podcast podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.