Cup of Mets

After weeks of frustration and mounting pressure, Steve Cohen has finally broken his silence on the state of the Mets. We break down everything the owner had to say, what it means for the remainder of the season, and whether fans should feel any more confident about the organization's direction. With Carlos Mendoza out, the managerial search is already taking shape. We discuss the early candidates...

The New York Mets have made sweeping changes, and we're breaking down everything from a chaotic week in Queens. Carlos Mendoza is out as manager, with Andy Green taking over on an interim basis. Was this the right move, or is Mendoza simply taking the fall for larger organizational issues? We also take a hard look at David Stearns' tenure as President of Baseball Operations. Has his vision for the...

The Mets open their series in Philadelphia with a big win, and we break down all the latest developments surrounding the club. Juan Soto continues his scorching stretch at the plate and now leads the National League with 169 wRC+. We also discuss the encouraging news surrounding Francisco Lindor's impending return, Sean Manaea's impressive form since rejoining the rotation, why the startin...

**RECORDED PRIOR TO NEWS ON ALVAREZ RETURN & SENGA INJURY** The Mets continue to steady the ship, winning seven of their last ten games and showing signs that this club may be turning a corner. In Episode 10 of Season 5, we break down what's fueling the recent stretch of success, the continued evolution of Carson Benge, and why veterans Bo Bichette and Marcus Semien finally appear to be fi...

The vibes in Queens have officially hit rock bottom. In Episode 9 of Season 5, we break down another brutal stretch of baseball as the Mets continue spiraling with no signs of urgency or accountability from the top down. Is it finally time for David Stearns to wave the white flag and begin selling before the deadline frenzy begins? We dive into the uncomfortable conversations surrounding the futur...

The New York Mets leave Washington with a split against the Washington Nationals and winners in 7 of their last 10, but was it a missed opportunity or a sign this team is beginning to find its identity? This week, we break down the series in DC, the continued emergence of the Mets’ youth movement, and why the young core is bringing much-needed energy to the roster. We also dive into Bo Bichette st...

The future may be arriving faster than expected in Queens. This week, we break down the growing impact of AJ Ewing and why his emergence is turning heads throughout the organization, while Carson Benge continues to heat up and make his case as one of the most exciting bats in the system. We also dive into the ongoing frustration with over-managing through analytics and discuss why it may be time f...

The New York Mets continue their West Coast swing going 4-2, but not without some lingering frustrations. In this episode, we break down the bizarre series finale in Denver as the Mets appeared to punt the getaway game against the Colorado Rockies, raising plenty of questions about urgency, lineup construction, and in-game management. We dive deep into Carlos Mendoza’s recent decision making, the...

The vibes in Queens are anything but steady right now. With injuries piling up across the roster and key contributors dropping left and right, the Mets are starting to look more like a MASH unit than a contender. Is this all setting the stage for Carlos Mendoza to take the fall? We dive into whether David Stearns could be lining up his manager as a scapegoat amid a spiraling situation that goes fa...

The vibes in Queens have officially hit rock bottom. In Episode 4 of Season 5, we break down a nightmare stretch for the New York Mets as the losing streak reaches a staggering 11 games and panic begins to take over the fanbase. Is this just a brutal skid—or something much deeper? We dive into the growing pressure on manager Carlos Mendoza as his seat gets hotter by the day, and take a hard look a...

The vibes have taken a sharp turn in Queens. After getting swept by the Oakland Athletics, the New York Mets find themselves spiraling with five straight losses, raising serious concerns early in the season. In this episode, we break down what went wrong in the series and why this skid feels more alarming than just a rough patch. We dive into the struggles on the mound, including what's going on w...

Episode 2 of Season 5 is here, and we’re joined by special guest Pat Ragazzo of Sports Illustrated! We get into his early impressions of the New York Mets and what’s stood out—both encouraging trends and potential red flags—as the season gets underway. The guys also tackle the Mets’ frustrating struggles with runners in scoring position. Is it just early-season variance, or a sign of something mor...

Happy Opening Day and welcome to Season 5 of The Cup of Mets Podcast! The 2026 season is officially here, and we’re kicking things off with a full-scale preview of what to expect from the New York Mets this year. From roster expectations to organizational direction, this episode sets the stage for everything ahead in what could be a defining season in Queens. We break down the biggest keys to a su...

Wrap up the offseason and get ready for first pitch as we close the book on the winter and turn the page to spring. In this season finale episode, we break down the latest moves from the New York Mets, including the club’s decision to ink veteran outfielder Mike Tauchman and what his bat, defense, and versatility could mean for the roster battle heading into camp. From there, we dive into the bigg...

The New York Mets stay busy reshaping the roster, and we’re breaking it all down in this episode. We start with the arrivals of MJ Melendez and Bryan Hudson, what each brings to the table, and how they fit into the Mets’ evolving depth chart heading into 2026. Then we dive into the big storyline: Francisco Lindor’s surgery, the recovery timeline, and what it means for the infield and early-season...

Players have officially began reporting to camp! In Hot Stove #50, we break down the early storylines from Port St. Lucie, including standout performances, injury updates, and what we’re learning about the shape of the 2026 roster. Plus, we touch on key World Baseball Classic notes and which Mets could see their stock rise (or fall) on the international stage. We also dive into the Mets’ decision...

The Mets didn’t just dip their toes into the trade market — they cannonballed in. In a wild 48-hour stretch, David Stearns reshaped the roster by acquiring Freddy Peralta, Tobias Myers, and Luis Robert Jr., signaling an aggressive pivot toward contention. We break down each deal in detail: what the Mets gave up, how these additions fit the short- and long-term vision, and what this flurry of moves...

The Mets finally make a splash, signing Bo Bichette, and we break down what this move means for the lineup, the infield, and the organization’s long-term vision. With Bichette in the fold, what’s next for Mark Vientos and Brett Baty? Who fits, who’s expendable, and how does David Stearns sort out the infield puzzle? We also dive into an outfield picture that’s still very much in flux, exploring re...

The Mets are reportedly now swinging for the fences as they’re linked to star outfielders Kyle Tucker and Cody Bellinger, along with frontline starters Ranger Suárez and Framber Valdez. What’s realistic, what’s smoke, and how aggressive should David Stearns really be? We also react to the news of Jeff McNeil being dealt — what it means for the Mets’ now barren outfield, payroll flexibility, and ov...

The Hot Stove is heating up and there’s plenty to unpack on Episode 46. We break down the Mets’ latest moves, diving into the signings of Jorge Polanco and Luke Weaver—what they signal about roster construction, lineup balance, and David Stearns’ broader plan. Is a true power bat still missing, and where could the Mets realistically find it? We also zoom out to the league-wide chaos, reacting to a...

Recorded: December 10th, 2025 The baseball world is buzzing—and Mets fans are reeling. In this episode, we break down the stunning departures of Pete Alonso and Edwin Díaz, what led to these franchise-altering moves, and how Mets president David Stearns is shaping the club’s future with his bold (and controversial) decision-making. We dive deep into the timeline, the rumors, the front-office philo...

(Recorded 12/3/2025) In today’s episode, we break down the Mets’ signing of Devin Williams and ask the big question: Is Edwin Diaz next? We dive into the latest Kyle Schwarber rumblings, revisit the ever-present Luis Robert Jr. speculation, and sort out what’s real vs. noise as the Winter Meetings loom. Plus, we cap it all off with a bold prediction that could completely reshape the Mets’ offseaso...

In this jam-packed episode, we break down the blockbuster trade sending Brandon Nimmo to the Texas Rangers in exchange for All-Star second baseman Marcus Semien. What does this mean for the Mets' infield and lineup construction? Could Jeff McNeil be the next piece to move as the front office reshapes the roster? We also explore why Cody Bellinger might be the perfect fit in Queens and how his vers...

The Hot Stove presented by The Cup of Mets Podcast is Back! We're diving straight in by discussing the departure of Frankie Montas (Thank God), where the club stands with Edwin Diaz & Pete Alonso, the availability of Brandon Nimmo, Kodai Senga and Jeff McNeil on the trade block as well as dishing out our Mets To-Do lists for the upcoming winter! FOLLOW on INSTAGRAM, YOUTUBE & X: @cupofmets...

The 2025 New York Mets have officially collapsed and will not see October Baseball. The crew discusses the issues that arose throughout the season which led to the demise of such a talented group as well as touches upon David Stearns' end of year press conference and so much more! We're just as disappointed as all of you but we thank you for tuning in throughout the entire season! We'll be back in...