Crime Corner With Jessie Wiseman

The three mustaches tackle a spicy and sensational case that has all of our favorite things, and more. In 2023, a bizarre home invasion gone wrong in Herndon, Virginia resulted in the deaths of both the victim, and the alleged perpetrator. But, as detectives started trying to make sense of the senseless crime, it began to look as though the victim may have inadvertently orchestrated their own murd...

The three mustaches head to rural Oregon to help track down a guy named Robert Haney. According to his enchantingly beautiful landlord / employer, Susan Monica, he went hog wild a few months ago and she hasn't seen him since. Robert's son, on the other hand, thinks Susan knows exactly where his father is and she's just being pig-headed about it. All we know for sure is wherever Robert went, he's d...

The three mustaches head to jolly old England to cover the controversial case of the Manacled Mormon. In 1977, an American missionary named Kirk Anderson vanished from a Latter-day Saints church in Surrey, England. Three days later, he returned with a chilling tale involving chloroform, bondage, and a blonde bombshell named Joyce McKinney. But, according to Joyce, it wasn't an abduction, it was a...

The three mustaches reconvene to finish the scandalous tale of Joyce McKinney and the Manacled Mormon. When we last left off, Joyce and her friend-zoned lackey, Keith May, had just been arrested for the abduction and assault of a Mormon missionary named Kirk Anderson. What started as a shocking headline soon exploded into a worldwide media hurricane with Joyce at the center. Now hang on tight as w...

The OG mustaches are joined by their new producer, Bluke, to discuss the mysterious disappearance of Timothy Molnar. In 1984, Tim left his home in Daytona Beach, Florida, to attend classes at Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University. But, before he could reach the school, he vanished into thin air. Was his disappearance the result of foul play, or did Tim just need to blow off some steam? And how the...

The three mustaches convene for one last episode in Texas before moving to their new studio. To mark the occasion, they have chosen an exceptionally "chilling" case. In 1986, a flight attendant named Helle Crafts failed to show up for her scheduled shift. According to her husband, Richard, she had made a last minute trip to Denmark to visit her mother. Or maybe she went to the Canary Islands with...

The mustache mafia is setting up shop in a new studio in North Carolina! To give them time to finish decorating the new studio -- and bury the bodies of the previous tenants -- we present to you an episode pulled from the darkest depths of the Evidence Locker. Between 1990 and 2010, the remains of at least 45 young men have been found in or near bodies of water in the Midwest. Near each alleged vi...

The three mustaches tackle a controversial case from Blue Springs, Missouri involving a highly suspicious accident. On a sunny afternoon in February of 1990, a single gunshot rang out from the home of Ken and Kathy Middleton. When first responders arrived, they found Kathy dead from a single gunshot wound to the head. According to Ken, her tragic death was the result of a freak accident, but inves...

The three mustaches return to Long Island to conclude their hunt for the Gilgo Beach Killer. After pulling over a dozen bodies from the sand, the Long Island Police Department were able connect at least 8 of the victims to the same culprit. Unfortunately, interdepartmental feuds and corrupt cops derailed the investigation before the killer could be tracked down. Now it's up to an expert criminolog...

The three mustaches grab their bathing suits and sunscreen for a relaxing trip to the beach. And there's no beach more suited for true crime enthusiasts than Gilgo Beach in Long Island. Between 2010 and 2011, nearly a dozen bodies were pulled from the sand, most of whom were young escorts from nearby towns. Early on it was clear to investigators that they were on the trail of a serial killer, and...

The three mustaches prepare for their upcoming move by taking a short trip to their soon-to-be home, North Carolina. In 1986, a man named Harold Gentry was brutally gunned down in what appeared to be a botched home invasion. The murder remained unsolved until 2006 when a forensic criminologist named Dr Laura Pettler discovered that Harold's wife, Betty, had a few skeletons in her closet. Specifica...

The three mustaches are joined by Ben and Sarah Lambert from the only Michelin starred barbecue restaurant in the world. Why are there professional chefs on the show? Because it's time to cook some killer food from a serial killer's cook book! Between 1982 and 1988, Dorothea ran a boarding house for the elderly and infirm in Sacramento, California. Unfortunately, her charitable endeavor soon came...

The three mustaches convene once again to examine all of the potential culprits of the infamous Alphabet Murders. Many suspects have been investigated over the past few decades, but so far no arrests have been made. Today, the true crime trio will utilize their vast knowledge of the criminal mind to finally identify the monster responsible for the brutal attacks on three young girls in Rochester,...

The three mustaches hop in their time machine and travel back to 1971 to tackle a case out of Rochester, New York. When the bodies of young girls began turning up along rural roads in upstate New York, police soon noticed an eerie similarity in their murders. Each girl had a first and last name that started with the same letter. Even more strange, their bodies were found in towns that also started...

The three mustaches take a trip to Kentucky, and it's not for the fried chicken. In 1988, just outside of Louisville, 36-year-old Brenda Schaefer went missing after a dinner date with her soon-to-be ex-fiancé, Mel Ignatow. Following her disappearance, all eyes were on her abusive former lover, but Mel turned out to be a slippery fella to catch -- likely due to all lube he kept on hand. Their tragi...

The three mustaches stock up on hairspray for a trip into the sordid underbelly of professional hairstylists. After spending 30 years clawing his way to the top of his industry, Fabio Sementilli was living the dream. He had a beautiful wife, a beautiful home, and a loving family that adored him. But that all came crashing down when the beloved celebrity hairdresser was brutally murdered in what ap...

The three mustaches gas up their Geo Metro and strap on their explosive ordinance disposal suits to deliver some hot and fresh pizzas. Why would they need protective gear to deliver Italian food? We're glad you asked! Apparently there's a lunatic out there strapping explosives to innocent delivery drivers and forcing them to rob banks. But was Brian Wells really an innocent victim sent on a deadly...

The three mustaches convene once again to go over all the facts and give the final verdict on the case of Darlie Routier. In the 30 years since Darlie was convicted of murder, new evidence has come to light that, in some people's minds, casts doubt on whether or not she was responsible for the deaths of her two sons. In order to keep listeners abreast of all the new details, the true crime trio wi...

The three mustaches grab their gavels and prepare to cast judgement on the controversial case of Darlie Routier. After a brutal home invasion left her two sons dead, investigators put Darlie in their crosshairs. Although she had nearly bled to death from defensive wounds, the detectives in charge of the investigation were suspicious of Darlie and her ever-changing story. But was she a cold-blooded...

The three mustaches stock up on garlic and holy water to hunt down a Midwest vampire. When Sydney Loofe met a young woman named Audrey on Tinder, she thought she had hit the jackpot. Audrey was fun, attractive, and always had some really good weed. But, unbeknownst to Sidney, her new love interest was hiding a dark secret that involved black magic, ritualistic sacrifices, and the occult. Keep a wo...

The three mustaches grab their hair gel and touch up their spray tans to cover a controversial case from New Jersey. In the Spring of 2004, suitcases began washing up on the shores of the Chesapeake Bay. Inside were the dismembered remains of a Jersey native named Bill McGuire. As investigators began unraveling the mystery surrounding the case, they discovered a toxic relationship filled with gamb...

The three mustaches hop in their time machine and travel back to 1989 to tell the story of Patricia Stallings. When Patricia and her husband David rushed their three-month-old son Ryan to the emergency room, doctors were at a loss. The infant's symptoms seemed to caused by ethylene glycol poisoning. But, his loving parents wouldn't slip anti-freeze into his bottle... would they? For a mystery like...

The three mustaches brace themselves for the brutal conclusion of the life and crimes of Carl Panzram. After spending most of his teens locked up, Carl is unleashed upon the world to get revenge for the horrors he was forced to endure. Sadly, the targets of his wrath are primarily innocent young men who had the misfortune of crossing his path. This episode has it all: a little blah-blah, a whole l...

The three mustaches cave in to peer pressure and finally cover the life and crimes of bonafide psychopath, Carl Panzram. Born in the late 1800s, Carl's life started out rough and it only got worse from there. By the age of 8, Carl was already a sticky-fingered alcoholic with a predilection for violence and disdain for authority. But, was he born this way or did his experiences growing up shape him...

The three mustaches head to South Carolina to tackle one of the most shocking and convoluted cases ever featured on Crime Corner. As the old saying goes, everyone is a villain in someone else's story. Well, if all of the allegations presented in this case are true, this story has nothing but villains. What started off as a seemingly theatrical murder soon devolved into a Mexican standoff of finger...