Sam and Michelle Eisert

Couple of Critics Podcast

Comedy EN ↓ 378 episodes

Sam and Michelle Eisert have similar, yet radically different tastes. In this podcast they submit their favorite media from the past and present to each other to discuss and review.

Author

Sam and Michelle Eisert

Category

Comedy

Podcast website

soundcloud.com

Latest episode

Jul 8, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

252. Loneliness and Temptation by Clarence Carter 14.06.2023

Clarence Carter, Clarence Carter, Clarence Carter, Clarence Carter, ooooooh shit Clarence Carter. This episode has a brand new feature we like to call Guess That Song In One Second!

251. Zeit by Rammstein w/ Tom Jefferys 07.06.2023

Tom and Annemarie Jefferys are back! This week, Tom decided that Zeit by Rammstein needed a Couple Of Critics reviews, or he won't be able to sleep without hearing the children scream. We tried to stop the screams, but we're not sure if it worked. You'll have to ask him. This episode features yet another fun and fancy free game of Guess That Melody!

250. Pulp Fiction 31.05.2023

This episode breaks the seal on a new movie for Sam! Michelle has chosen possibly one of Quentin Tarantino's most popular films ever to rate and review. This week the critics watch Pulp Fiction! This episode features ChatGPT Theatre.

249. Cobain and Cornbread by The Black Tones w/ Annemarie 24.05.2023

Two podcasts all-stars, The Jefferys, are in town from Buffalo to discuss music! This episode belongs to Annemarie though and she brought along Cobain and Cornbread by The Black Tones. Note : She did not bring any Nirvana albums or actual cornbread. This episode features yet another ROUSING round of Guess That Melody.

PAXTOWEEN 2023 - Twister 17.05.2023

Everybody put on your best pair of butt shaping blue jeans, grab a fried chicken leg and get to celebrating the man, the myth, the legend - Bill Paxton! It's Paxtoween 2023 and Cousin Chris sits down with Michelle and Sam to try out fried foods and discuss the wacky, wild, wonderful weather-based blockbuster Twister!

247. Boston w/ Dale Masten 10.05.2023

Remember when you were younger and you saved up your money to buy that one album that you couldn't wait to have in your hands and call your own? This week, we reminisce and jam with first-time guest Dale Masten as we review the self-titled debut album by Boston. This episode features the little ditty, "Don't Be A Dick."

246. The Runaways 03.05.2023

It's a historic Couple of Critics episode as Sam has finally chosen something with women! This week the critics discuss the debut and self-titled album by rock n' roll female frontiers The Runaways.

245. Someone Like You by Matchbox 20 26.04.2023

What has 8 arms that play 90s soft rock for all ages? If you guessed a band with an album that could be reviewed on a podcast, then give yourself an award for stellar brain power. The critics review Yourself Or Someone Like You by Matchbox 20, and high-five into the sunset like farting lovebirds. This episode features a rousing round of Guess That Melody!

244. Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope 19.04.2023

It's a monumental moment in history as it's finally time for Michelle to watch and discuss Star Wars! Will this be the start of her journey through The Force or will she still think it's all just stupid? This episode features a 1 Minute Abe Review!

243. The Grand Pecking Order by Oysterhead w/ Zach Broering 12.04.2023

Classic All-Star guest Zach Broering is back in the "studio" and he's brought along an album that both Michelle and Sam are quite familiar with. This week's topic is the album The Grand Pecking Order by the Les Claypool and Stewart Copeland involved super-group Oysterhead! Oh yeah... that Phish guy is in there too. Wouldn't you know it!? This episode features a rousing round of Guess That Melody.

242. Aaliyah 05.04.2023

This week's discussion is the third and final album from Aaliyah! Was Sam as in as much misery listening to this album as Michelle was when she found out Aaliyah died? Better listen to find out. This episode features a mini episode of The Abraham Lincoln Crack Emporium Show.

241. Smash by The Offspring w/ Kirk Gibbons! 29.03.2023

This week Kirk Gibbons sits down with the critics to try out a new beverage and talk about The Offspring's first major hit album Smash! This episode once again features a rousing round of Guess That Melody.

240. Ten by Pearl Jam 22.03.2023

This week Sam threw a curveball of a music choice for Michelle and the first half of the episode just possibly might have some audio issues. Alright! It definitely has audio issues but I promise it gets better. The critics sit down to listen to and discuss Pearl Jam's debut album Ten.

239. Music For The People by Marky Mark and the Funky Bunch 15.03.2023

We're really sorry. We listened to it and now you must suffer as well. This week's subject is Marky Mark and the Funky Bunch's debut album Music For The People. This episode features yet another rousing round of Guess That Melody!

238. Tenacious D w/ Jimmy Rowland! 08.03.2023

Long time friend of the podcast Jimmy Rowland has made his way back on to the show. This time his choice is the debut album self titled album from Tenacious D! This episode features the dumbest minute and thirty-four seconds of your entire life.

237. Houdini by Melvins 01.03.2023

It's Sam's choice this week and he went with a band some consider kings of the underground. It's time to listen to and talk about Houdini by Melvins! This episode features a rousing round of Guess That Melody featuring Travis!

236. Hurley by Weezer w/ Gus! 22.02.2023

This week the critics have a brand new guest! Sam's first cousin once removed Gus joins in to talk about the album Hurley by his favorite band Weezer.

235. Machine Gun by Commodores 15.02.2023

It's finally time for another Michelle episode and she is getting back to her funky roots! This week the critics are listening to and discussing Commodores first album Machine Gun! Featuring a rousing round of Guess That Melody!

234. Valentimes Day with Chris and Rachel 08.02.2023

It's time to celebrate love Couple of Critics style. Chris Gibson is back but this time he brought his better half, Rachel! In this episode everyone chose three songs they enjoy with "love" in the title to go head to head for a prize bag. Who will win the bag of Valentines Day crap? Listen to find out! This episode features a song premiere from a special pin-faced someone.

233. Over The Top by White Wizzard w/ Travis Harpster! 01.02.2023

Rolling through town is Travis Harpster to bring us MORE METAL for Michelle. It's time to sit down, listen to and discuss White Wizzard's debut album! This album features a rousing round of Guess That Melody!

232. The Sane Asylum by Blind Illusion 25.01.2023

This episode is a dive into the unknown for both Michelle and Sam! This week the choice is Blind Illusion's debut album The Sane Asylum featuring a young Les Claypool and Larry LaLonde before the success of Primus. Also featuring a brand new Quiz Show!

231. The Queen Is Dead by The Smiths w/ Rob Suding 18.01.2023

The Smiths say The Queen Is Dead, and the world agrees. First time guest Rob Suding has brought something new to the table to review with the critics, as well as two big guns for hugs.

230. Here's Little Richard 11.01.2023

Wop-bop-a-loo-bop-a-lop-bam-podcast! It's a new week and Michelle chose Little Richard's debut album Here's Little Richard as the topic of discussion. Is Sam a boogie woogie Queen? This episode features a round of the brand new segment Who Said That Shit?

229. Bad Brains by Bad Brains 04.01.2023

Sam chooses an album that unfamiliar territory and known as essential in the world of hardcore music. This week the critics listen to and discuss the album Bad Brains by the one and only Bad Brains. This episode features round 2 of Guess That Melody with Beth and the family!

228. Sticky Fingers by The Rolling Stones 28.12.2022

Brown sugar, how come you taste so good? The critics review Sticky Fingers by The Rolling Stones, whether Sam likes it or not. What does Sam think about The Rolling Stones after having listened to an album? Michelle is about to find out. This episode features another rootin' tootin' round of Guess That Melody.

Listen to the Couple of Critics Podcast podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.