Christian True-Crime Junkies!

What happens when the worship songs that shaped your faith are tied to scandal, abuse, or spiritual corruption? In this unsettling but important conversation, we dig into the dark side of modern worship culture—asking whether Christians should keep singing songs written by fallen pastors, disgraced ministries, or churches accused of covering up sin. From church scandals and celebrity pastors to Ki...

Church scandals can leave lasting wounds—not just for victims, but for entire congregations, families, and even believers who were only indirectly affected. In this candid discussion, we explore why spiritual betrayal cuts so deeply, how high-profile church scandals impact faith, and what it looks like to heal when trusted Christian leaders fall. From celebrity pastors and denominational coverups...

One of the most feared rulers in history may have been shaped by an even more dangerous force—his own mother. This episode dives into the shocking story of Agrippina the Younger, the ambitious and manipulative mother of Emperor Nero, whose ruthless pursuit of power helped shape one of ancient Rome's most notorious tyrants. From political schemes and suspicious deaths to betrayal, exile, and murder...

A hacker known as "Ransom Man" exposed the private therapy records of more than 30,000 patients in what became the largest criminal investigation in Finnish history. As terrified victims received ransom emails threatening to release their deepest secrets, investigators raced to uncover the identity of the cybercriminal behind the devastating Vastaamo data breach. This episode explores online priva...

A mother watched her house burn to the ground in 1997—and insisted her baby daughter had been kidnapped, not killed in the fire. For years, everyone believed grief had driven her into denial… until one chance encounter at a family party changed everything. In this unbelievable true crime case, a mother's relentless intuition leads to a shocking discovery involving kidnapping, deception, and a chil...

A teenage girl tried to report her stepfather's abuse—twice. Instead of being protected, she was labeled a liar… until a single gunshot changed everything. When police arrived at a Maryland home in 2004, a husband was found dead in bed beside what appeared to be a staged suicide scene. But as investigators began uncovering years of domestic abuse, hidden evidence, and long-buried family secrets, t...

What if a self-help expert known for teaching influence and mindset was accused of getting away with murder? In this chilling case, a brutal killing leaves two men at the scene—and no clear answers. As their stories collide, the question lingers: was this simply reasonable doubt… or something more persuasive at work? Blending true crime with a faith-based lens, this episode explores the fine line...

In this episode of Christian True Crime Junkies , Alana is joined by her husband, Scott, for a thoughtful and nuanced discussion on a real-life custody case centered around homeschooling rights. When two parents with opposing views on education take their disagreement to court, the question becomes: who gets to decide what's truly in a child's best interest? Drawing from a 1996 California case, th...

In this powerful episode of Christian True Crime Junkies , we explore the incredible and lesser-known story of Eric Liddell —an Olympic champion whose greatest legacy wasn't on the track, but in his unwavering faith. Known for his conviction to honor God above all else, Eric shocked the world when he refused to compete on a Sunday… but that's only the beginning of his story. After his Olympic vict...

A dream home turns into a waking nightmare when Derek and Maria Broaddus begin receiving eerie letters from someone calling themselves "The Watcher." What starts as a strange welcome quickly becomes deeply unsettling, with the writer claiming to watch the house—and the family's children. As the letters escalate, fear takes over and just about everyone in this usually quiet town becomes a suspect....

This week on Christian True Crime Junkies! , we explore a shocking case inside a strict Orthodox Jewish community where women can become "chained" in marriages they cannot escape. When one desperate situation leads to the involvement of a controversial rabbi known for extreme—and illegal—methods, the line between justice and vigilantism begins to blur. Was he a champion for the voiceless, or a man...

What would you do if your home no longer felt safe, not just because of what was taken, but because of how extensively it was vandalized? In this episode of  Christian True Crime Junkies! , Jaime and Alana explore a strange string of burglaries that left Lake Tahoe residents fearful, frustrated, and searching for answers as tensions in the community continued to rise. As the investigation unfolds,...

What can the story of Anna Delvey teach us about trust, deception, and discernment? In this episode of Christian True Crime Junkies , we revisit the infamous con artist case made popular by Inventing Anna —but through the overlooked perspective of victim Rachel DeLoache Williams . Behind the headlines and fascination lies a sobering story of manipulation, financial loss, and a friendship that slow...

What if the most famous murder of the early 1900s wasn't really about the killer—or even the victim—but about a young woman caught in the middle of power, fame, and manipulation? In this episode of Christian True Crime Junkies , we dive into the shocking story of Evelyn Nesbit—the original "It Girl"—whose beauty captivated a nation but whose life was shaped by exploitation, control, and tragedy. W...

In this episode of Christian True Crime Junkies , we explore the true story of Stephen, the first Christian martyr, recorded in the book of Acts. Jaime Hampton and Alana Terry walk through the events that led to his arrest, his bold defense before the Sanhedrin, and the powerful faith he displayed even as he faced death. Stephen's final moments—seeing heaven opened and praying for those who were k...

Is listening to true crime a sin? n this special episode of Christian True Crime Junkies, we step back from a specific case to wrestle with a bigger question many believers are asking. From articles in Christianity Today and Relevant Magazine to conversations in churches, Christians are debating whether true crime sharpens our understanding of justice — or numbs us to suffering. We talk about how...

This episode is sponsored by Edge of Truth by Janice Cantore . Get your copy today, anywhere books are sold! The world knew her as America's sweetheart. Tonya Harding knew her as her biggest rival. When Nancy Kerrigan was attacked just weeks before the 1994 Winter Olympics, the figure skating world was thrown into chaos. What followed was one of the most infamous sports scandals in history — a met...

When crime stories dominate headlines, how do we talk about justice without losing sight of faith? In this episode of Christian True-Crime Junkies! , we sit down with former Long Beach police officer turned Christian romantic suspense author Janice Cantore to explore what it's really like to serve on the front lines of law enforcement, and how God shows up in the darkest moments. Drawing from her...

When spiritual authority crosses into control, how do you recognize it—and why is it so hard to name while you're inside it? In this episode of  Christian True-Crime Junkies (which coincides with Spiritual Abuse Prevention Month) , Jaime sits down with Alana for the final installment of a 3-part interview exploring Alana's experience in a Christian cult during her college years. What began as a fa...

When spiritual authority crosses into control, how do you recognize it—and why is it so hard to name while you're inside it? In this episode of  Christian True-Crime Junkies (which coincides with Spiritual Abuse Prevention Month) , Jaime sits down with Alana for Part 2 of a 3-part interview exploring Alana's experience in a Christian cult during her college years. What began as a faith community r...

When spiritual authority crosses into control, how do you recognize it—and why is it so hard to name while you're inside it? In this episode of Christian True-Crime Junkies (which coincides with Spiritual Abuse Prevention Month) , Jaime sits down with Alana for Part 1 of a 3-part interview exploring Alana's experience in a Christian cult during her college years. What began as a faith community ro...

When abuse happens in the church, why is it so often mislabeled, minimized, or silenced?   In this episode of Christian True-Crime Junkies , we partner with special guest Lori Morrison to examine adult clergy sexual abuse (ACSA): how it happens, why it's frequently dismissed as an "affair," and the devastating impact church responses can have on survivors.   By researching a well-documented case a...

In the spirit of New Year's, we're looking back at all our stories and crime cases from 2025 and giving out awards to the most deserving in the first ever Christian True-Crime Junkies award ceremony. Find out who wins the prize for creepiest criminal, most resilient survivor, biggest transformational reform, and more! (Just don't forget to dress up and bring your own dessert.) Join award-winning a...

The world knew her as a living saint. Mary Johnson knew her as "Mother," the woman who devoted her life to serving the poorest of the poor in Calcutta and creating an order of sisters that Mary lived with, worked with, and dedicated her life to for two decades. When Mary joined Mother Teresa's convent as a young woman, she had no idea that she was going to walk into a world of abuse, power plays,...

In this episode, Jaime and Alana examine a quiet kind of deception: spiritual manipulation that preys on compassion rather than money. Describing personal encounters, they uncover how time, emotional energy, and even prayer can be stolen under the guise of need. But when discernment finally breaks through the deception, the story doesn't end in shame. Instead, it raises a hard question: how do bel...