Cast Aghast: A True Crime Podcast

Got 30ish minutes? Buckle up, because today we’re diving into the deeply disturbing and highly controversial case of Ellen Greenberg. Ellen was a 27-year-old teacher living in Philadelphia when she was found dead in her apartment in 2011 with multiple stab wounds. Her death was initially ruled a homicide, then later changed to suicide, a ruling her family has fiercely challenged. In 2025, the case...

Got 30ish minutes? Buckle up and brace yourself, because today we’re cracking open Hollywood’s most unsettling open secret: Cursed Films. Lightning strikes. On-set deaths. Fires, freak accidents, and coincidences so eerie they refuse to stay coincidences. From Poltergeist to The Exorcist, The Omen, The Crow, and beyond; were these productions just plagued by bad luck… or did something darker hitch...

🎙 Got 30ish minutes? Buckle up and brace yourself, because today we’re diving into a mystery wrapped in blue lights and small-town secrets: The Jessica Boynton Case. A locked closet. A service weapon. A deputy’s wife with a bullet in her skull… who lived to tell the tale. But was it a suicide attempt or something far more sinister? Disclaimer: We’re goofy humans who like to laugh and have fun whil...

🎙 Got 30ish minutes? Buckle up your snow boots and zip that parka because we’re heading deep into the frozen heart of Soviet Russia for one of the coldest, creepiest, and most confounding mysteries ever: the Dyatlov Pass Incident. ❄️🏕️Nine experienced hikers. One nightmarish trek. Zero satisfying answers. How did a group of seasoned hikers end up scattered, shoeless, and lifeless in the snow? And...

🎙 Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we tap into the sticky, sweet, and downright audacious Great Canadian Maple Syrup Heist! 🍁💰 This bizarre crime saw thieves making off with $18 million worth of liquid gold, leaving investigators in a very syrupy situation. How did they pull off one of the most Canadian crimes in history? And more importantly…why? 🥞🔍 💡 Disclaimer: We’re goofy people who love to...

🎙Got 30ish minutes? Join us us as we unravel the mysterious disappearance of Kris Kremers and Lisanne Froon, a perplexing case filled with eerie clues, unanswered questions, and chilling discoveries deep in the Panamanian jungle. What really happened on that fateful hike? 🏔️🔍 💡 Disclaimer: We’re goofy people who love to have fun and crack jokes, but we promise it’s never at the expense of the vi...

🎙Got 30ish minutes? Travel back to 1897 with us as we dive into the eerie tale of the Greenbrier Ghost, a chilling mix of true crime and paranormal mystery. How did a spirit solve a murder and make courtroom history? 👻⚖️ 💡 Disclaimer: We’re goofy people who love to have fun and crack jokes, but we promise it’s never at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy isn’t your cup of...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we discuss the darker side of Hollywood #amieharwick #dominiquedunne #hollywoodmurders Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, and hope you enjoy some of the amazing other podcasts out there! Connect with...

🎙Got 30ish minutes? Travel back to 1692 with us as we uncover the Salem Witch Trials, a haunting chapter of paranoia, power, and injustice that shaped history. 🧙‍♀️🔥 💡 Disclaimer: We’re goofy people who love to have fun and crack jokes, but we promise it’s never at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy isn’t your cup of tea, we totally get it, and we hope you find some oth...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we discuss Adam Strong and his disturbing house of horrors. Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, and hope you enjoy some of the amazing other podcasts out there! Connect with us! Youtube: Catam Concoct...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we dive into one of the most mysterious and baffling cases of the 20th century: the strange death of Mary Reeser and the phenomenon known as spontaneous human combustion. Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely under...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we discuss the terrible crimes committed by the hands of Arthur Shawcross. John's insults will be thick with this one! Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, and hope you enjoy some of the amazing other...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we discuss the kidnapping of Colleen Stan, and her 7 years of torture during captivity at the hands of Cameron Hooker. #colleenstan #thegirlinthebox #girlinthebox Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, a...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we discuss the Keddie Murders. Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, and hope you enjoy some of the amazing other podcasts out there! Connect with us! Youtube: Catam Concoction Instagram: Cast_Aghast Sp...

Got 10ish minutes? Check out our 'Cast Aghast Best of 2023'! A big thank you to our listeners for giving us another epic year! To ring in the 2024 the right way, follow along with the drinking game version for this episode posted below! Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we discuss the very disturbing and stomach-churning case of Ronald William Brown. Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, and hope you enjoy some of the amazing other podcasts out there! Connect with us!...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we discuss Roch Theriault and his cult The Ant Hill Kids. Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, and hope you enjoy some of the amazing other podcasts out there! Connect with us! Youtube: Catam Concoctio...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we discuss the horrific murders of Jennfier Hawke-Petit, 11 year old Michaela Petit and 17 year old Hayley Petit. Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, and hope you enjoy some of the amazing other podca...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we discuss the unsolved(ish) case of the Girl Scout Murders. Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, and hope you enjoy some of the amazing other podcasts out there! Connect with us! Youtube: Catam Concoc...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we discuss the sick and twisted Gary Heidnik and his basement of torture where he planned to hold women captive and force them to have his children. Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, and hope you en...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we the amazing story of Jennifer Schuett who survivor a horrific attack as a child, and brought her attacker to justice. Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, and hope you enjoy some of the amazing othe...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we the case of Arne Johnson. His case sparked a major media presence, and was inspiration for the 3rd installment in the highly popular horror franchise, The Conjuring. Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely underst...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we discuss Marvin HeeMeyer. The man who took out a town with his Killdozer Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, and hope you enjoy some of the amazing other podcasts out there! Connect with us! Youtube...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we discuss the Las Cruces Bowling Alley Massacre. Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, and hope you enjoy some of the amazing other podcasts out there! Connect with us! Youtube: Catam Concoction Instag...

Got 30ish minutes? Join us as we discuss the devastating story of Suzanne Capper and the horrific acts that were inflicted on her. Disclaimer: We are goofy people who like to have fun and crack jokes, though we would never do this at the expense of the victims. If mixing true crime and comedy is not your jam, we completely understand, and hope you enjoy some of the amazing other podcasts out there...