Case of the Sunday Scaries

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Annie is covering a highly requested case, the history of the Salem Witch Trials! What do an 11-year-old, a fungus, and some town gossip have to do with witches? Everything! Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Elyse Dehlbom @elysemichelle_mua Annie Hochstein @anniehochstein Case Of The Sunday Scaries Podcast @acaseofthesundayscaries Lea...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Elyse is covering the mythological, historical, and religious history of redheads. Do they steal souls? Why were they believed to be witches? Join us today for a lighthearted look back in time to the history of redheads. Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Elyse Dehlbom @elysemichelle_mua Annie Hochstein @anniehochstein Case Of The Sund...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Ever wonder about the history behind Halloween traditions and folklore? Annie is diving in and we are sharing loads of giggles and Halloween memories as Annie breaks down the history of all things Halloween! Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Elyse Dehlbom @elysemichelle_mua Annie Hochstein @anniehochstein Case Of The Sunday Scaries Po...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! It is officially Spooky Season and Elyse is taking over the mic to tell you the haunting true story behind all those rumors we heard as children about poisoned trick-or-treat candy, this is the case of Ronald O'Bryan AKA The Candy Man. TW: This episode covers a case involving harm to a child If you would like to help donate to the Florida Disaster Relief fund...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Annie is back on the mic this week after Hurricane Ian tried to do its best to slow down the roll-out of our Spooky October Content, but she is covering Lake Mead and all the bizarre things being found just below the surface. If you would like to help donate to the Florida Disaster Relief fund click here A full list of references for this case can be found on...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Annie is covering (for once) a case that will actually give you some closure at the end of the episode! Today we are covering the tragic murder of John Stagner. A full list of references for this case can be found on our episode blog at: https://www.acaseofthesundayscaries.com/blog Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Elyse Dehlbom @elys...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! How can a corpse and an eyelash be used to trick one of the most brutal dictators of all time? Find out in today's case when Elyse covers Operation Mincemeat. A full list of references for this case can be found on our episode blog at: https://www.acaseofthesundayscaries.com/blog Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Elyse Dehlbom @elysem...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Annie is covering the haunting missing person's case of Melody Jones and the tragic murder of her husband Paul Jones. This case has us both stumped, so we would love to hear your theories! A full list of references for this case can be found on our episode blog at: https://www.acaseofthesundayscaries.com/blog Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! We are all recovering from the last case and felt like you all deserved an episode that celebrated two young actresses whose interaction with a group of orphaned children would shape the future of child abuse advocacy and care in the United States and the World! Enjoy this bonus episode! If you know or suspect there is a child in danger Call or Text the Child...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Elyse is discussing a case that has haunted her since she first heard about it, the case of Slyvia Likens a beautiful 16-year-old whose life was horrifically and tragically taken. If you know or suspect there is a child in danger Call or Text the Childhelp National Child Abuse Hotline 24/7 (1-800) 4-A-Child or (1-800) 422-4453 TW: This episode discusses SA an...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Annie is tackling her first serial killer episode with the story of Terry Rasmussen and the Allenstown four. A full list of references for this case can be found on our episode blog at: https://www.acaseofthesundayscaries.com/blog Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Elyse Dehlbom @elysemichelle_mua Annie Hochstein @anniehochstein Case O...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Elyse covers the heroic survival story of Mary Vincent and the determination she had to not only survive but would get her day in court with her attacker Lawrence Singleton. Check out the A&E Interview with Mary here A full list of references for this case can be found on our episode blog at: https://www.acaseofthesundayscaries.com/blog Join us for a new...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Annie covers THREE cases voted on by you, the Scary Squad, of real estate agents who have been murdered while showing homes. Please check out the National Association of Realtors Safety Page for tips and tricks for keeping yourself safe if you are a realtor, by clicking here or visiting https://www.nar.realtor/safety A full list of references for this case ca...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Elyse is covering the case of Joe Arridy, "The Happiest Man on Death Row." TW: Brief overview of a Sexual Assault: 11:20-12:43 A full list of references for this case can be found on our episode blog at: https://www.acaseofthesundayscaries.com/blog Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Elyse Dehlbom @elysemichelle_mua Annie Hochstein @ann...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Annie is back to cover the case of Gary Triano and his untimely passing. This case certainly has a lot of twists and turns, but who was responsible for his death? If you or someone you know is in an abusive relationship please visit: www.thehotline.org To donate to Arlo Schmidt's GoFundMe campaign click here or visit https://www.gofundme.com/f/arlo-schmidt A...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Elyse is covering the case of Giulia Tofana, a woman who has been credited as being the most prolific female serial killer in recorded history. Is she a hero or a cold-blooded killer? We will let you decide..... Bailey Sarian's Murder, Mystery, and Makeup Youtube Series A full list of references for this case can be found on our episode blog at: https://www.a...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Denver International Airport is full of secrets. Join Elyse and Annie as they discuss underground levels, the tunnel system, Blucifer the horse, and more in this wild conspiracy episode. A full list of references for this case can be found on our episode blog at: https://www.acaseofthesundayscaries.com/blog Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every S...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! We are picking up where we left off in Part One in the crazy story of Robert Hansen, Alaska's own "Butcher Baker." In this episode learn more about Robert's horrific MO and how it ties back to the "Most Dangerous Game." Also, we cover the unlikely trio that would finally bring Robert Hansen to justice. A full list of references for this case can be found on o...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Elyse is taking over the mic to discuss the horrible story of Robert Hansen aka The Butcher Baker, one of Alaska's most notorious serial killers and the most unlikely of heroes, Cindy Paulson. Our hearts go out to the victims and the victim's families of the Highland Park July 4th shooting. If you are in a position to donate to their GoFundMe pages a list of...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Annie is taking over the mic to uncover the story behind one of Colorado's most bizarre cold cases. The mystery behind Elizabeth "Beth" Miller's disappearance has remained a mystery for years, but with plenty of leads to uncover. If you have any information about the disappearance of Elizabeth "Beth" Miller, please contact the CBI at 303-239-4244 A full list...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! What do the Golden State Killer, BTK, and James Clanton have in common? Three letters: DNA. Join Annie and Elyse for their first mini-episode where they take a deep dive into the world of genetic DNA testing, the horrors of learning someone you love committed awful acts, and how one drop of DNA can reopen cases that have gone cold. A full list of references f...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! On our very FIRST episode, Host Elyse Dehlbom will be sharing the tragic murder of Tanner Pehl and Sarah Clark. This case began Elyse's fascination with true crime, but why? Join us for a very vulnerable interview with special guest Mandy B. and the reason for Elyse's interest, in this case, will be made clear. TW: Discussion of a crime scene and violence aga...