Case of the Sunday Scaries

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Annie is weaving a tangled web in today's episode. Mary Louise Day went missing as a pre-teen. Her parents say she ran away, but her sisters and the police suspect foul play. When a woman shows up claiming to be Mary Day over two decades later, will we find out what really happened all those years ago? Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Today Elyse is breaking down the mystery of Easter Island, the most remote inhabited island on the planet! Easter Island is most famous for its 900 statues called Moai and the mysteries and theories created to explain them. Why did the Rapa Nui people create so many Moai statues? How were these multi-ton statues created and transported? Who is the Birdman?” J...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! April is sexual assault awareness month and we sat down with Steve, a seasoned sex crimes detective to learn more about how survivors can get help, how to be a friend to a survivor, resources to educate our listeners and so much more. TW: Today’s episode will discuss SA in brief graphic detail. While this conversation was not easy to have or easy to listen to...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Annie will be leaving us soon for maternity leave but insisted we record this special episode today. This case is truly harrowing. Tom was born in the early 1920s but would soon become one of the most well-known serial killers in history. Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Elyse Dehlbom @elysemichelle_mua Annie Hochstein @anniehochstei...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Today Annie is covering the case of Jaleayah Davis, a young 20-year-old in the prime of her life until her body was discovered in the early morning hours in a passing lane of the Ohio interstate. Was it murder or like the police would have us believe, a tragic accident after a night on the town? If you feel this investigation deserves a second look, please jo...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! You asked for it, we are covering the Murdaugh family! In Meet the Murdaughs Episode Two, we go through the timeline and evidence for the murders of Paul and Maggie Murdough as well as speculate about what in the world could have been the motive for their murders? Have a theory of your own? We would love to hear from you! If you want to follow along as we dis...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! You asked for it, we are covering the Murdaugh family! In Meet the Murdaughs Episode One, we are covering the family history of the Murdaughs as well as their legal issues and the mysterious deaths that seem to surround every member of this family. If you would like to sign the petition in memory of Stephen Smith click here Join us for a new Case of The Sunda...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! We are concluding our series about intimate partner abuse with our guest Alice who bravely shares with us her story and her road to recovery. If you resonate with anything discussed throughout this series, we encourage you to visit www.thehotline.org or call/text 1-800-800.799.SAFE (7233) Resources discussed in today's episode: DV Texting game tool -  https:/...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! February is Black History month and we want to honor that by dedicating our episodes to discussing some of the injustices and downright horrendous acts that have victimized the Black community in America. Annie is covering the case of Anthony Wright Jr and how the Innocence Project helped free him after over twenty years behind bars. You can find more informa...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! February is Black History month and we want to honor that by dedicating our episodes to discussing some of the injustices and downright horrendous acts that have victimized the Black community in America. Today Elyse is sharing the amazing story of Isaac Wright Jr. and his fight to free himself from a corrupt system, a prosecutor determined to keep him behind...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Isreal Keyes was a serial killer with kill kits buried all over the United States, a calculated criminal whose crimes would span almost a decade until he finally was caught when he murdered 18-year-old Samantha Koenig in Anchorage, Alaska. Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Elyse Dehlbom @elysemichelle_mua Annie Hochstein @anniehochste...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! February is Black History month and we want to honor that by dedicating our episodes to discussing some of the injustices and downright horrendous acts that have victimized the Black community in America. Today Annie is breaking down the Tuskegee Syphilis Study. Thank you to The Farmers Dog for sponsoring this podcast. If you would like to save 50% on your fi...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! We are joined this week by Dr. Kirk Honda, a therapist, professor, and host of the popular podcast and Youtube channel "Psychology in Seattle." We discuss possible red flags when entering into a new relationship and answering questions submitted by our listeners. You can check out Dr. Honda's Psychology in Seattle podcast wherever you stream your favorite pod...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Amy Lynn Bradley disappeared during a family vacation on a Caribbean cruise in 1998. Her whereabouts remain unknown, but in today's case, Annie is breaking down possible sightings and theories on what happened to this beautiful 23-year-old woman. Thank you to The Farmers Dog for sponsoring this podcast. If you would like to save 50% on your first box of fresh...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! We are continuing our series about intimate partner abuse with a focus on stalking and harassment. In this episode, we dive into the life and tragic death of Molly McLaren, a beautiful 23-year-old whose life would suddenly change to one lived in fear after swiping right on Joshua Stimpson. If you resonate with anything discussed throughout this series, we enc...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Two tragic deaths occurred at the Spreckels mansion but who, if anyone is to blame? TW: This case goes into forensic details of suicide and mental health Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Elyse Dehlbom @elysemichelle_mua Annie Hochstein @anniehochstein Case Of The Sunday Scaries Podcast @acaseofthesundayscaries Resources for this case...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Happy New Year!! A topic that unfortunately comes up repeatedly while we research episodes for our podcast is intimate partner abuse. With this in mind, we wanted to take time to break down different types of abuse within a relationship including stalking and harassment. Elyse is starting the series with her own personal story with a past partner. It is our h...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays! Annie is covering the brutal murder of a 15-year-old named Karen Stitt, a case that had gone cold for over 40 years, but recently had a new development in the case that just might finally give the answers her family and loved ones deserve. As always you can submit your case suggestions or personal stories on our website! Jo...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Elyse is covering the unbelievable and tragic murder of Bonnie Haim. Could her young son's memories help find her killer? Join us for a deep dive into not only this case but the psychology behind repressed memories. As always you can submit your case suggestions or personal stories on our website! Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Ely...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! The tragic murders of two young girls Abigail Williams and Liberty German have haunted the town of Delphi, Indiana since 2017. However, recently there was an arrest made in this case! Join us as Annie reads the arrest affidavit and we give our thoughts heading into the spring trial of their number one suspect. Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries ever...

A Case of The Sunday Scaries Update! Annie and I couldn't be more excited about what is to come for this podcast and we wanted to share a little announcement that we are taking a couple of weeks off to gear up for the changes we are making, which includes adding exclusive content, a Youtube channel, and other ways to interact with our podcast community! We hope you follow along with the process on...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! This case was highly recommended to us and Annie is diving into the tragic story of the DeFeo family murders and the paranormal activity inside an Amityville house that scared away the new homeowners in less than a month.... or did it? Thank you so much to everyone who joined us for Spooky Season, Happy Halloween! Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Today we uncover the Pharoah's Curse, is it true or just a wild coincidence and how did corpse medicine become an excuse for human cannibalism? **We apologize for the audio issue at the end of this podcast, we have worked to remedy it and appreciate your patience! Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Elyse Dehlbom @elysemichelle_mua Anni...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! What happens when Elyse goes down a historical true crime Google rabbit hole? You get an episode listing her top picks for the worst torture methods of all time. Which one do you think is the worst? TW: Discussion of torture and sadism throughout the episode Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Elyse Dehlbom @elysemichelle_mua Annie Hoch...

Welcome to Case of the Sunday Scaries! Annie is back on the mic to give you plenty of scary stories to tell at your next camp fire! Learn the mysterious history of the Appalachians! Join us for a new Case of The Sunday Scaries every Sunday! Elyse Dehlbom @elysemichelle_mua Annie Hochstein @anniehochstein Case Of The Sunday Scaries Podcast @acaseofthesundayscaries Learn more about your ad choices....