Cara and Levi Garrett
Caffeine Controversy
Welcome to Caffeine & Controversy — where an 80s baby/millennial married couple gathers in “the basement” (yes, wood paneling included) to overshare, overthink, and over-caffeinate their way through trauma from our mamas, life choices we’re still unpacking, and pop culture chaos. Raised on dial-up, reality TV, and emotional damage, this is just the continuation of the tradition. Messy, caffeinated, unfiltered. New episodes every Monday.
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
Flava of the Month 06.07.2026 26:57
This week, Cara and Levi attempt to survive a brutal heat wave, leading to conversations about perimenopause, swamp-level humidity, and the questionable ways people cope when it's too hot to function. That spirals into a nostalgic deep dive into the golden age of VH1 reality television, where Flavor of Love , The Surreal Life , and the wonderfully chaotic world of early-2000s dating shows ruled po...
Pull You for a Chat? 30.06.2026 30:58
Levi's caffeine withdrawal takes center stage as the episode kicks off with complaints about giving up energy drinks, ADHD self-medication, and the struggle of finding healthier coping mechanisms. That conversation unexpectedly leads into deeper discussions about mental health, healthcare disparities, growing up as millennials, and how constant access to news and social media has changed the way g...
We Gotta Cut This 22.06.2026 32:59
This week on Caffeine Controversy, Levi and Cara are joined by Levi's longtime friend and coach Nigel for what starts as a casual conversation and quickly turns into an unexpected therapy session. As Men’s Mental Health Awareness Month takes center stage, the three dive into self-worth, grief, burnout, bodybuilding, and the difficult process of learning to value yourself. Levi opens up about chasi...
Millennial Tv Premiere 15.06.2026 53:43
This week on Caffeine Controversy , Levi and Cara take a nostalgic trip through the golden age of television, debating everything from soda vs. pop, Coke vs. Pepsi, and whether fountain drinks actually taste different, before diving into a bigger question: did streaming kill the shared experiences that made growing up in the 80s, 90s, and early 2000s so memorable? The conversation explores the ris...
Podcast About Nothing 01.06.2026 51:52
Levi and Cara spiral from perimenopause brain fog, GLP-1 side effects, and birthday expectations into a wildly unhinged conversation about ho phases, bar fights, getting kicked out of churches, online dating as a bigger girl, generational trauma, bad exes, relationship roles, and why being the “responsible one” is exhausting. Along the way they debate modern music, body confidence, growing up too...
Can't Fix Stupid 25.05.2026 40:13
This week on Caffeine Controversy , Levi and Cara go from black cat chaos to a surprisingly deep conversation about mental health, burnout, and why adulthood feels like one long decompression session. After watching the documentary Sky King , they unpack the story of the airport employee who stole a plane during a mental health crisis, leading into a candid discussion about workplace pressure, eco...
The O Word 18.05.2026 27:36
This week on Caffeine Controversy , Levi and Cara dive headfirst into body positivity, fat liberation, perimenopause burnout, and the internet’s latest obsession: Jillian Michaels vs. the “O word.” The episode kicks off in classic chaotic fashion with Cara describing her brain as “mush” from perimenopause while Levi questions whether he’s been emotionally numb since birth. Between jokes about hati...
Trauma, Neglect, Taters 11.05.2026 43:50
We started talking about social media burnout… and somehow ended up unpacking generational trauma, food psychosis, internet frenemies, and why Cara’s cat “lost his scrotes.” In this episode of Caffeine Controversy , Levi and Cara get painfully honest about what it’s like building an identity online while trying not to lose yourself in the process. Cara opens up about eight years of sharing her lip...
The "Whoa" Factor 04.05.2026 21:19
We started with 90s TV nostalgia… and somehow ended up unpacking crushes, ego, and why some icons did not age well. In this episode of Caffeine Controversy, Levi and Cara go back to the TGIF era—when missing an episode actually meant something—and break down the shows that raised us, the characters we saw ourselves in, and the ones we were maybe a little too obsessed with. Full House, Family Matte...
Boy Bands and BS 27.04.2026 28:03
We thought we were just talking about boy bands… yeah, it didn’t stay there. In this episode of Caffeine Controversy , Levi and Cara break down the rise of boy bands and the powerful machine behind them—from the *NSYNC vs. Backstreet Boys era to the industry blueprint built by Lou Pearlman. But underneath the nostalgia is a much darker pattern: how fame, money, and control shaped what we saw as en...
Trapped in a Yeti 24.04.2026 34:19
Dating is already messy… now add interracial experiences, awkward hookups, moral dilemmas, and grief. Yeah—this episode goes there. Levi and Cara unpack real relationship stories—from “what was I thinking?” moments to deep conversations about intimacy, communication, and moving on after loss. It’s funny, uncomfortable, honest—and probably a little too relatable. They also get into the question nob...
Dating, Trash Tv & Vagisil 17.04.2026 1:20:03
This episode dives into the chaos of online dating, the messiest moments in reality TV, and why Vagisil somehow made it into the chat. It’s unfiltered, slightly unhinged, and definitely not your average relationship talk.
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.