Natalia Terfa, Emmy Kegler

Cafeteria Christian

Religion EN ↓ 389 episodes

Cafeteria Christian started as a place for people who love Jesus but are so over the version of Christianity that forgets love, justice, and curiosity. Hosted by Pastor Natalia Terfa and Pastor Emmy Kegler, the show is a mix of faith conversations, cultural commentary, and the beautiful, complicated mess of trying to follow Jesus in the real world. From biblical deep dives to big feelings about the world, Emmy and Natalia create a space where honesty and hope coexist. Together, we're reclaiming the term "Cafeteria Christian" — because when it comes to faith, you really can take what you like a...

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: www.cafeteriachristian.club

Author

Natalia Terfa, Emmy Kegler

Category

Religion

Podcast website

www.cafeteriachristian.club

Latest episode

Nov 16, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

#333 Micah: the OG Doom Scroll 06.10.2025

Emmy and Natalia set aside current events (and big feelings about current events) to talk about the biblical book of the prophet Micah and discover that actually, not a lot has changed since 700 BCE.  www.patreon.com/cafeteriachristian

#332 The Seven Heavenly Virtues (Finally!) 02.10.2025

Emmy and Natalia finally talk about the Seven Heavenly Virtues, and wonder if they even really matter at all?   www.patreon.com/cafeteriachristian  

#331 Why Is No One Ok? 24.09.2025

Emmy and Natalia continue the conversation from last week, about why everything feels like too much, and what we are trying to do about it.  Links:  https://substack.com/@dianabutlerbass/note/c-157891892?r=3g6zg&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=notes-share-action    

#330 Tragedy, Hot Takes, Stupid Joys, and What Is Ours To Do 15.09.2025

Emmy and Natalia talk about the death of Charlie Kirk, the outpouring of hot takes, and how it might not be good for us that everyone feels like they needs to care about all the things all the time.  Consider supporting our show. Not to get any free stuff of perks (though you can see video of this podcast if you're a patron), but support us because it matters to you that this podcast continues.  w...

#329 Seven Deadly Sins, pt. 2 09.09.2025

Emmy and Natalia finally come back to wrap up the seven deadly sins with wrath, envy, and pride. Also included, Natalia's rant about Psalm 46 and when cherry-picking goes wrong.     Links:  Substack article about not being able to maintain the moral high ground: https://open.substack.com/pub/elisedenbasco/p/on-white-covid-cautious-queers?r=3g6zg&utm_medium=ios   Natalia's uplift: https://nataliate...

#328 Thoughts. Prayers. Despair. Rage. 02.09.2025

Emmy and Natalia process their big feelings around the school shooting in Minneapolis this last week, and how we're trying to hold more than despair.  Links talked about it today's episode: Tolstoy and Trump Substack: https://substack.com/home/post/p-171917579   Glennon and Abby chat: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DNit0TKtDgY/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&igsh=MTNoajNtN2pudDVybA==   Moms Demand Ac...

#327 Should We Celebrate When Someone Dies? 26.08.2025

Emmy and Natalia take a little pause in their Seven Deadly Sins series to talk about the death of James Dobson and what to do when we have conflicting feelings about it.  www.patreon.com/cafeteriachristian  

#326 Seven Deadly Sins Pt 1 19.08.2025

This week, Emmy and Natalia begin a multipart series on the 7 deadly sins. What are they? How did they come about? Why do they matter, if at all? Dig into gluttony, greed, and lust with us (yey?) in part 1!  Link: www.patreon.com/cafeteriachristian  

#325 Rest Is Not a Deadly Sin 11.08.2025

Emmy and Natalia are back after their summer break and catching up on all things rest, sabbath, and holding peace while we navigate the dumpster fire that is the daily news cycle. http://patreon.com/cafeteriachristian  

#324 A Rebellion of Care w/ David Gate 07.07.2025

Natalia and Emmy welcome poet and artist David Gate, to talk about his new book of poems and essays called "A Rebellion of Care."    Links:  https://www.davidgatepoet.com/  

#323 Outside Safe Space with Mikah Meyer 30.06.2025

On our last episode of Pride Month, Emmy and Natalia welcome travel expert, speaker, and advocate Mikah Meyer to talk about his three year 419 National Park Service journey, as well as his current projects and why it matters to create safe spaces outdoors too.    http://patreon.com/cafeteriachristian   Links:  www.mikahmeyer.com Interactive Map: www.mikahmeyer.com/map Outdoor Safe Space Merch: htt...

#322 Saints, Icons, and a Beef with Bridget, w/Erik Nelson 24.06.2025

Emmy and Natalia are joined by friend of the pod friend of God Erik Nelson to nerd out on the saints and icons and why it matters to know their names and their stories. Not just as histories but for our own understanding of what it means that God is still speaking through saints today as well.    Support us on Patreon: www.patreon.com/cafeteriachristian Follow Erik on Instagram: @sverike  

#321 Find Your Pretzel 16.06.2025

It's Pride month, and it feels even more important than ever to speak up and support our LGBTQ+ siblings. Emmy and Natalia process a moment that Emmy recently had during a Q&R (question and response), and how to respond when someone comes at you hard using the Bible as their defense.    Links:  President Bartlett's takedown: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3CPjWd4MUXs   Support our show! www.patre...

#23 (Repost): The Drive-Thru Cheeseburger Principle 10.06.2025

To kick off our Pride month discussions we're bringing back an oldie but a goodie: episode 23, Emmy's first appearance on the podcast way back in January 2019. Natalia, Nora McInerny, and Emmy talk "welcoming" vs "affirming," reclaiming the word "queer," and what to do with "Bam Bam Christians" who are just a little too into the "clobber verses" of the Bible. Links:  www.patreon.com/cafeteriachist...

#320 No Mega-Church May (June) part 3: The Church Search 02.06.2025

Emmy and Natalia continue the conversation about finding a church fit, what your search might lead you into, and why you might not want to church search at all.    Links:  www.patreon.com/cafeteriachistian Venmo: @cafeteriachristian  

#319 No Mega-Church May 28.05.2025

We asked, and you all responded! This week Emmy and Natalia read and talk about the ways Cafeterians have church shopped and how it went.  www.patreon.com/cafeteriachristian  

#318 No Mega-Church May 19.05.2025

Emmy and Natalia answer our most commonly asked listener question about churches and how to find a "good" church that also is safe, but also has good music, and also good preaching, and and and and and.  Links:  www.patreon.com/cafeteriachristian

#317 Practicing Being Human w/ Beth Silvers 12.05.2025

Emmy and Natalia welcome Beth Silvers of Pantsuit Politics to spend a little time talking about the intersections of faith and politics and why we haven't given up on either just yet.  Links: Pantsuit Politics: https://www.pantsuitpoliticsshow.com/     Sarah Bessey Article: https://sarahbessey.substack.com/p/are-we-still-calling-ourselves-christians     www.patreon.com/cafeteriachristian  

#316 The Noise of Your Songs 07.05.2025

Emmy and Natalia talk about a few stories about Christianity that have been in the news this week, and why it matters to stay in this faith thing, even when it feels like it would be easier to just walk away. www.patreon.com/cafeteriachristian

#315 Get in Loser, We're Going Conclaving 30.04.2025

Natalia drags Emmy into her rabbit hole of interest in the papacy and tries to convince her that it matters and that we should care - even if we're super not Catholic. http://patreon.com/cafeteriachristian    

#314 Post-Easter Mini-sode with Emmy 25.04.2025

Emmy offers a short meditation on life after Easter Sunday.  Content warning for discussion of a suicide attempt. www.patreon.com/cafeteriachristian

#313 Hope is Sewer Rat with Feathers 15.04.2025

Emmy and Natalia talk about hope - and why it is so hard to hold onto right now, and what we are doing to hold onto hope when everything else is telling us to just let it go.  Poem: Hope is Not a Thing with Feathers Emily, It Is a Sewer Rat - by Caitlin Seida www.patreon.com/cafeteriachristian

#312 Why Does Holy Week Matter? 08.04.2025

Emmy and Natalia talk about how we show up during a week of complicated emotions and feelings, and one that often has a lot of church baggage attached to it. As we get closer to this particular week in the church, let's reflect on what really matters about each day, and why. http://patreon.com/cafeteriachristian  

#311 Theology of Reality 31.03.2025

Emmy and Natalia get into a deeply theological talk about God and faith and life right now and why scripture is still relevant and where God is right now.    Notes:  www.patreon.com/cafeteriachristian www.facebook.com/groups/cafeteriachristian   Book Club Form link: https://forms.gle/QobkVMPsvLQX44QP7

#310 Good Soil w/ Jeff Chu 24.03.2025

Emmy and Natalia welcome Jeff Chu to talk about his new book, Good Soil.    Get Jeff's Book: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/729761/good-soil-by-jeff-chu/   See Jeff on his book tour: https://byjeffchu.com/tour www.patreon.com/cafeteriachristian  

Listen to the Cafeteria Christian podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.