Buckhorn Podcast

Martelle, Mike, and Randy record their very first Zoom-based show. Randy kicks things off with a tale about canned foods and how they sparked a revolution in childhood culinary delights. But the real shocker of the episode? Martelle announces he’s stepping away from the show…Recorded on 09/28/25.

Martelle, Mike, and Randy embark on the journey of Dry January. In this episode, the guys explore the world of near beer, sampling offerings from Brew Dogs Alcohol Free line and Guinness 0%. Join them as they share their impressions of these non-alcoholic options and navigate the challenges and surprises of going alcohol-free for the month. Amidst the dry adventures, the hosts take a moment to cat...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy kick things off with Penelope Toasted Barrel — an excellent bottle you can find in most markets. Somewhere along the way, Martelle threatens to leave the show (don’t worry, he doesn’t) as the guys catch up on life, swap stories, and share plenty of laughs. Recorded on 09/15/25. YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@buckhornpodcastApple Podcast: https://podfollow.com/BuckhornP...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy kick off the show with a pour of Old Raleigh Distilling Batch 12 before diving into all the updates and happenings from the past week. From whiskey talk to life updates, it’s a laid-back episode full of laughs and catching up. Recorded on 09/07/25.YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@buckhornpodcastApple Podcasthttps://podfollow.com/BuckhornPodcastSpotify: https://open.spoti...

Martelle and Mike kick things off with high hopes and a bourbon barrel-aged stout—but when that pour goes south fast, they pivot to Rhinegeist Ink before ultimately landing in safer (and tastier) territory with Penelope Toasted Bourbon. Along the way, the guys keep the banter rolling, sharing stories, laughs, and maybe a little too much honesty. Meanwhile, we’re about 72.3% sure Randy is gone. Rec...

Martelle and Randy crack open the latest Bourbon Hunters barrel picks—this round featuring a Maker’s Mark and an Elijah Craig. Mike joins the fun via FaceTime, doing his best to match pours from afar with bottles close to what the guys are sipping on.📅 Recorded on 08/17/25 YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@buckhornpodcast Apple Podcast: https://podfollow.com/BuckhornPodcast Spotify: https://open....

Martelle and Mike kick back and shoot the shit while catching up on Mike’s first few weeks living out in Utah. From settling in to new surroundings to the little day-to-day adjustments, the guys share laughs, stories, and plenty of off-topic tangents along the way. Recorded on 08/03/25 YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@buckhornpodcastApple Podcast: https://podfollow.com/BuckhornPodcastSpotify: htt...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy open the show with the chaos of the August 3rd floods that tore through Central Ohio. Mike relives a harrowing moment as raging waters nearly claimed his dog’s life, a split second from drowning before he pulled him to safety. From there, the guys shift into the saga of Mike’s drive to Utah, while Martelle keeps the mood Recorded 08/03/25 YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/...

Martelle and Randy kick back with pours of Virgil Kaine—starting with their classic Ginger Old Fashioned and moving on to the Ribbon Rail Rye. As the whiskey flows, the conversation drifts through Ohio weather shifts, updates on Martelle’s basement setup, and a nostalgic dive into one of Martelle’s childhood bedrooms. It’s a laid-back episode full of stories, sips, and a little sentimental chaos....

Martelle, Mike, and Randy take on the Bourbon Hunters' private barrel pick of Jack Daniel’s Barrel Proof—a bold pour weighing in at 129.6 proof. The guys break down the flavor, heat, and whether it lives up to the hype. Then, it’s back to the legendary Sam Adams Utopias, coming in at 28%. Is it beer, a collector’s flex, or something in between? With laughs, hot takes, and a few sips too many, this...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy crack into a few of Liz’s personal bottle picks—including Woodford Wheat, Bardstown Bourbon, and Town Branch Rye. Just when things start getting good… Liz walks in and catches them red-handed sipping her stash. Recorded on 07/13/25 — tune in for laughs, whiskey, and the moment they got busted. YouTube:  https://www.youtube.com/@buckhornpodcast Podbean / Apple Podcast / Go...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy are joined by special guest Bobby DeMars, founder of Blind Barrels—a quarterly blind whiskey tasting experience and membership that’s all about discovering hidden gems without the label bias. They dive into how the company started, what makes blind tasting so powerful, and sample a few surprises along the way. Recorded on 07/06/25 — pour something blind and join the conve...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy settle into a new recording location—Martelle’s basement—as Mike’s house is under contract and the Mac Shack is officially no more. To break in the new space, the guys dive into a Booker’s flight featuring: 2022-04 “Pinkie’s Batch” 2023-01 “Charlie’s Batch” 2023-02 “Apprentice Batch” Little Book® Chapter 7: “In Retrospect” Recorded on 07/06/25, this episode is all about b...

Recorded 7-14-23 Hey there, listeners! Buckle up and join us for a brand new episode of "Martelle & Mo Unplugged" as we hit the road for an exciting adventure to Kentucky. In this episode, we're taking you along on our journey to the Top of the Box Functional Fitness Competition, but that's not all - we're exploring some unexpected detours along the way. From malls and record stores to Woodsto...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy are joined by a packed house for Mike and #Mel2028’s moving/going away party. It’s a full send-off with everyone getting a shot (literally) at the infamous Snake Bite—a beer clocking in at 67.5%—followed by the always regrettable yet iconic Malört, one of Chicago’s finest (or most feared) spirits. With a room full of people, side conversations run wild and the chaos is re...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy sit down to shoot the shit with fan-favorite Oregon Derek after a massive blind whiskey tasting that, thanks to some brutal technical difficulties, never made it to air. While the lost episode lives on in memory (and maybe liver damage), this one is all about catching up, laughing it off, and sipping something strong while doing it. Recorded on 06/07/25. _________________...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy crack open the show with a premixed Hercules Rum & Rye Old Fashioned. Martelle drops a surprise by playing the legendary Ballad of Leeroy Jenkins ( watch here ), setting the tone for another classic Buckhorn episode. The crew revisits Quest's End Whiskey: Paladin and shares their thoughts now that the bottle's had some time to breathe. Mike recaps his chaotic journey...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy sit down to compare Mike’s bottle of Two Bitch Bourbon Pack Leader Reserve with Martelle’s and see just how different two bottles of the same release can be. The conversation drifts into boating adventures at Buckeye Lake, a little golf talk, and plenty of random tangents along the way. Recorded on 04/25/25 – grab a pour and come hang out. ________________________________...

Martelle and Randy BS about some BS while sipping on a couple of dog-themed whiskeys. First up is Two Bitch Spirits' Small Bark with Bite , followed by a surprisingly fantastic rye from Dog Distilling out of Powell, Ohio. What started as a fun theme turned into a solid tasting session with a few unexpected hits. Recorded on 04/18/25 — sit, stay, sip. _______________________________________________...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy kick off the show talking about their recent knife purchases and crack open another high-proof beer to keep things rolling. The guys touch on the ever-changing weather, swap some movie recommendations, and, of course, drink more beer. Recorded on 05/ 07/25, this episode is all about sharp edges, cold brews, and good conversation. Cheers! __________________________________...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy start the show talking about cars and the wild world of Cletus McFarland, including his track purchase back in the “before times” of 2019. Mike shares the story of kicking (or more accurately, moving) his son out of the house as part of the prep for his move to Utah. As the guys dig into Mike’s beer stash to lighten the load for the move, Mike quietly slips out—leaving Ma...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy kick off the show with a rare pour of 1978 Old Stitzel-Weller from Old Commonwealth and share their thoughts on this vintage gem. Martelle recounts the saga of his daughter taking out a mailbox with his truck, which sparks a trip down memory lane as he and Randy trade stories from their old street racing days. Recorded on 04/21/25, this episode brings vintage whiskey and...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy kick off the show with a unique twist—a bacon fat washed Old Fashioned that brings big flavor to the glass. Afterward, the guys dive into two different Four Roses offerings, breaking down what makes each one stand out. Recorded on 04/07/25, this episode is full of bold flavors and good times. Cheers! ________________________________________________________________________...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy continue their Buffalo Trace lineup exploration with a Weller flight featuring Special Reserve, Antique 107, and 12 Year. The crew breaks down each pour, comparing notes and debating favorites in the wheated bourbon world. To mix things up, the guys break out a horrible cinnamon-infused Watershed Whiskey before finishing the episode with a pour of Two Bitch Bourbon Pack L...

Martelle, Mike, and Randy start the episode with a quick chat about the recent flooding in Frankfort, KY, before diving into a full flight of Buffalo Trace products. The lineup includes the classic Buffalo Trace, Eagle Rare, E.H. Taylor, and Blanton’s. The guys sip, compare, and rank each pour—breaking down the flavors, the hype, and which bottle actually deserves the spotlight. Recorded on 04/13/...