Arguing Ever After

Did you ever play with a Ouija board growing up, or would you set foot in an abandoned tuberculosis hospital after dark? In this episode of Arguing Ever After , we share spooktacular ghost stories that will make you rethink turning off the lights! First up, we travel to Duluth, Minnesota, to explore the dark history and paranormal hauntings of Nopeming Sanatorium . Then, we head over to Minot, Sou...

Are werewolves pure movie magic, or is there a terrifying historical reality behind the beast? 🐺🌕In this episode of Arguing Ever After, we unpack the dark lore and real history of the werewolf! We share harrowing stories from historical records—including the 16th-century trial of Peter Stumpp and the mysterious Beast of Gévaudan—and break down how real medical conditions like rabies and porphyri...

Is the Mummy’s Curse a real ancient warning or history’s greatest media hoax? 🧟‍♂️🏺✨In this episode, we unpack the terrifying legend behind King Tutankhamun’s tomb and the series of mysterious deaths that shocked the world in the 1920s. Did Lord Carnarvon and the excavation team succumb to a dark pharaoh's curse, or was it toxic mold (Aspergillus flavus), ancient bacteria, and a sensational...

Who was Bloody Mary, and why are we still terrified of saying her name three times in the dark? 🪞🩸It’s Spooky Season on Arguing Ever After, and we’re dissecting the lore behind the ultimate sleepover urban legend! In this episode, we debate the real-world inspirations behind Bloody Mary—from Queen Mary I of England and Elizabeth Báthory to pure folklore and mirror-induced brain tricks. Who makes...

SPOOKY SEASON 2 STARTING EARLY!!Are zombies real, or just movie fiction? 🧟‍♂️🧪In this episode, we dive into the terrifying history of real-world zombies—starting with the famous case of Clairvius Narcisse, a Haitian man who was pronounced dead in 1962 and returned to his village 18 years later as a documented zombie. We debate the thin line between pop culture horrors (walking dead, viral outbre...

Stranded on a deserted island with only ONE item for entertainment: Do you pick a book or an MP3 player? 🏝️In this episode, we debated the ultimate hypothetical survival dilemma. We weighed music's ability to regulate mood and comfort against a book's capacity to keep your mind sharp and engaged over long periods. We also explored what each choice reveals about how we cope with isolation....

Are classic fairy tales magical, or are the original stories pure nightmare fuel? In this episode of Arguing Ever After , we dissect the original Brothers Grimm fairy tales to uncover just how dark, disturbing, and deeply unhappy these original "happily ever afters" actually are. From brutal endings to bizarre moral lessons, we debate which classic tale has the most miserable outcome and...

Is cereal secretly soup? 🥣 In this episode of Arguing Ever After , we dive headfirst into the ultimate breakfast debate! Join us as we rank the undisputed best cereals of all time, battle over sweet vs. crunchy, and settle the legendary "cereal is a soup" controversy once and for all. Whether you’re a devout Cinnamon Toast Crunch lover or team "milk is a broth," this episode i...

Would you rather live in a comfortable, blissful illusion or wake up to a harsh, cold reality? In Season 2, Episode 6 of Arguing Ever After , we’re diving headfirst into The Matrix to settle one of the biggest pop-culture debates of all time: The Red Pill vs. The Blue Pill. After years of marriage, we usually agree on the big stuff... but this iconic choice divided us completely. Is ignorance trul...

In Season 2, Episode 5 of Arguing Ever After, we are breaking down everything about Monopoly —from winning board game strategies to one of the biggest fast-food fast-talks in history. We dive deep into the infamous McDonald's Monopoly debacle , uncovering how a criminal network rigged the promotion for millions in unclaimed prizes. Plus, we debate the ultimate question that ruins friendships:...

Is showing up to a potluck empty-handed a major social red flag, or are there exceptions? In Season 2, Episode 4, we dive into the unwritten rules of party etiquette, guest expectations, and whether bringing drinks, napkins, or helping clean up excuses you from bringing a main dish. In this episode, we cover: The basic unwritten rules of potluck etiquette What to do if you can’t cook or don’t have...

Does sparkling water actually taste good, or are we all just pretending? In this episode, we’re bringing the heat to the ultimate flavor showdown: refreshing beverage vs. bitter liquid static! We're putting seltzer, mineral water, and flavored carbonated water to the ultimate taste test: Is the fizzy burn a crisp, top-tier sensation or genuinely unappealing? Why do some people crave the bite o...

Who gets to control the temperature in the car: the driver or the passenger? In this episode, we’re bringing the heat to this age-old road trip argument to settle the thermostat debate once and for all. Does driving give you total authority over the AC and heater dials, or is keeping the passenger comfortable the ultimate co-pilot rule? We break down road trip etiquette, dual-zone climate control...

"Is Odysseus a hero or a villain? Welcome back to the show, where today we’re tackling one of the biggest debates in ancient mythology and Greek literature. In this episode, we dive deep into Homer’s epic, The Odyssey , to examine the legendary King of Ithaca. Was Odysseus a brave, brilliant hero guided by wisdom and loyalty? Or was he a selfish, reckless leader who sacrificed his crew for pe...

Welcome to the Season 2 premiere! We are kicking off our second season with a massive doozy of an episode: the ultimate recap of the internet’s greatest debates. We are looking back at our wildest showdowns, reviewing the most controversial hot takes, and settling these legendary arguments once and for all. In this recap episode, we revisit and crown the winners of three massive debates:• The Stop...

Why are dolls so scary? In our 52nd episode, we ask the big question are dolls just a simple toy or nightmare fuel? From childhood nostalgia and vintage collections to the uncanny valley effect and famous haunted doll folklore, we explore exactly why these everyday objects can trigger such an intense fear response. Whether you love them or find them terrifying, this episode breaks down our complic...

Is counter-service tipping out of control? In this episode, we tackle the awkward "screen-flip" moment and ask the ultimate question: Are you truly compelled to tip when ordering at a counter? We break down the evolution of modern tipping culture, consumer guilt, and where to draw the line on everyday gratuity etiquette. We talk about all of the fun the World Cup is bringing. Plus, we di...

Welcome to the milestone 50th episode of Arguing Ever After ! To celebrate, we are diving deep into history's most epically absurd duels. From bizarre weapons to ridiculous insults, we’re looking at the strangest historical showdowns where people actually risked it all over the pettest drama. But the real debate happens at the finish line. We tackle the ultimate moral and legal question: If so...

In Episode 49 of Arguing Ever After , we are tackling one of the most passionate culinary debates of all time: What actually makes a burger? If you put a chicken breast on a burger bun, is it a chicken burger or just a sandwich? Does a veggie burger count if there’s no beef involved? What about a patty melt? We are breaking down the official rules of fast food, backyard barbecues, and menu termino...

Imagine a world where your children have superhuman abilities. On Episode 48 of Arguing Ever After , we break down a massive parenting dilemma: What superpower would you give your kid? In this episode, we explore: The funniest and most practical superpowers for everyday parenting. The accidental chaos of raising a child with superhuman abilities. Our personal picks for the ultimate kid superpower...

Welcome back to Arguing Ever After ! In our 47th episode, we are tackling a parenting question so absurd, we’re still not sure how we got here: Should you let your kid throw knives? While it sounds like a fast track to the emergency room, we dive into the hilarious (and surprisingly debatable) sides of letting children explore "extreme" hobbies. Is it a unique way to build hand-eye coordination an...

Welcome back to Arguing Ever After ! In Episode 46, we are discussing a highly debated relationship dilemma: Should you be allowed to tell your significant other to change their outfit to fit the occasion? We argue both sides of this classic couples argument, covering wardrobe control, fashion advice in relationships, and social etiquette before casting our final votes. Whether you believe in tota...

Welcome back to Arguing Ever After ! In Episode 45, we are tackling one of the biggest pop culture and fantasy debates of all time: Dragons vs. Unicorns . We argue the powers, mythology, and pop culture status of both iconic mythical creatures before casting our final votes. Whether you're Team Dragon or Team Unicorn, this episode is packed with the fun banter and disagreements you love. Suppo...

In the 44th episode of Arguing Ever After , we’re stepping into the shadows to settle one of the most cinematic debates of all time: Who is the greatest gangster? From the cold-blooded strategy of real-life mob bosses to the iconic anti-heroes of Hollywood, we’re breaking down the power, the loyalty, and the legacy of history's most notorious figures. Whether it's the Prohibition-era grit of Al Ca...

Did you remember to wash your hands? Did I just catch you double-dipping ? 🍟🚫 In this episode of Arguing Ever After , we’re getting down and dirty with the things that make our skin crawl. But we aren't just complaining—we’re diving into the evolutionary science of disgust. Why does the sight of a double-dip or the sound of a sneeze trigger an instant "ick"? According to the Behavioral Immune Sy...