And a Rewatch Podcast

The romance part of the tragically cancelled ABC rom-com series, Selfie , begins to spark a little bit. It's time to talk about "Even Hell Has Two Bars"! Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Chels ( @chels725 ) unpack the workplace part of this workplace comedy first, talking about the differences between Eliza and Henry. They then discuss how Eliza spent the entire episode trying to help Henry,...

We're finally back at Apartment 4D... just in time for the roommates to squabble over a parking spot. That's right: We're talking about the hilarious, aptly titled episode, "Parking Spot" today! Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Jaime ( @jaimepoland ) discuss why this episode is funny, even 10+ years later. (They praise Max Greenfield and Lamorne Morris, specifically, for some hilar...

It's a new year but we're back talking about our favorite residents of Apartment 4D. Let's dive back into New Girl with "Table 34," shall we? Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Jaime ( @jaimepoland ) have a lot of thoughts about the episode that picks up right where "Cooler" left off. They talk about the way the episode struggles to find something for Winston to do, why the...

It's the end of 2025 and we've finally made it to our last episode about New Girl 's "Cooler" — and this time we're talking solely about that iconic Nick/Jess first kiss. Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Jaime ( @jaimepoland ) obviously have a lot of thoughts about what makes this kiss so unanimously hot and beloved. So they dive into the specifics of the way the kiss is shot...

Who's ready to talk more about ABC's tragically cancelled series, Selfie ? Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Chels ( @chels725 ) have returned to talk about an episode that focuses a lot on Charmonique and her son, Kevin: "Nugget of Wisdom"! They discuss Academy Award winner Da'Vine Joy Randolph's performance in this episode — and why we should all aspire to have the kind of se...

Who's ready to talk all about the second half (and by that, we mean basically just 8 minutes) of New Girl 's iconic "Cooler" episode? Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Jaime ( @jaimepoland ) are back again and they have so many feelings to talk through! They discuss the kind of odd Schmidt/Cece interaction and what it means for their story the rest of the season. Plus they discuss how fu...

Join Chels ( @Chels725 ), Jesse ( @speakupjesse ), Paige ( @thoughtsbypaige ), and Eoin ( @EoinDaily ) as they recap their favorite unscripted and scripted dramas. It's time for "The Wicked Wiz of Oz: The Musical" on Drag Race and our hosts have theories about the quality of Rusicals impacting the quality of Snatch Game. Untucked proves to be the best show on TV as our safe queens o...

Welcome back to our Selfie summer/fall series where we're rewatching the tragically cancelled ABC series! Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Chels ( @chels725 ) have returned to unpack two episodes of the show: "Un-tag My Heart" and "A Little Yelp From My Friends."  First, they discuss the hold that Facebook had over us all in 2014, as well as Henry realizing that life happened and h...

Chels ( @chels725 ), Sharai ( @sharai ), and Jesse ( @speakupjesse ) are back to recap season 3 of the show featuring their favorite little cannibals: Yellowjackets !  This week they discuss the episodes three and four of the season, "Them's the Brakes" and "12 Angry Girls and 1 Drunk Travis." The teens send a search party to find the missing Mari but find themselves tripp...

Chels ( @Chels725 ) and Jesse ( @speakupjesse ) are the only ones on the pod this week as they recap their favorite unscripted and scripted dramas. On The Traitors , the co-hosts are celebrating their perfection elimination predictions and toast good riddance to Boston Rob and Derrick. Jesse breaks down how are traitorous girlies are faring in the game, while Chels is overconfident that she'd...

It's time for a blast into the past: specifically back to 2014 when ABC debuted a tragically cancelled TV series called Selfie . Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Chels ( @chels725 ) were huge fans of the short-lived show and decided to revisit it this summer. So stay tuned as they cover all 13 episodes. To kick things off though, they talk about the series' pilot.  The cohosts spend the first par...

We've finally reached the iconic and game-changing episode of New Girl , "Cooler"! And since this episode is jam-packed with things to discuss, Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Jaime ( @jaimepoland ) are going to be breaking up their discussion of "Cooler" into three parts. In this part, they talk about the first half of the episode, including Nick and Jess' friendship and why...

Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Chels ( @chels725 ) are back one last time to talk about their beloved (and now tragically cancelled) series, Mythic Quest . On their "Heaven and Hell" recap , they talked about that game-changing final scene featuring Ian and Poppy kissing. But now that the ending has changed, Jenn and Chels process how they feel about the original ending's erasure. They als...

Though Paige ( @thoughtsbypaige ) is gone this week, the rest of the reality TV and soaps rewatch crew has returned. Join Chels ( @Chels725 ), Jesse ( @speakupjesse ), and Eoin ( @EoinDaily ) as they recap their favorite unscripted and scripted dramas. The group talks about The Traitors first and laments how the remaining Traitors are playing a poor and messy game (and how the Faithfuls are being...

While Mythic Quest has unfortunately been cancelled, that won't stop us from talking about the show's universe! So we're back this summer to unpack the four episode anthology spin-off series, Side Quest . Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Chels ( @chels725 ) talk all about the first episode, "Song and Dance." They dissect the episode's depictions of anxiety, self-sabotage, and...

Welcome back to Apartment 4D where the Nick/Jess tension and flirtation is starting to build in this week's great New Girl episode, "Pepperwood." Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Jaime ( @jaimepoland ) have returned to talk all about a hilarious B-story involving roommate "pogos," Jess trying her best to get through to the adults in her creative writing class, Nick doing everything...

If Yellowjackets is back, that means that your recap crew has officially returned too! Chels ( @chels725 ), Sharai ( @sharai ), and Jesse ( @speakupjesse ) are back to recap season 3 of the show featuring their favorite little cannibals.  This week they discuss the first two episodes of the season, "It Girl" and "Dislocation." Teen Natalie is a single mom who works two jobs, wh...

Though Eoin ( @EoinDaily ) is gone this week, the rest of the reality TV and soaps rewatch crew has returned. Join Chels ( @Chels725 ), Jesse ( @speakupjesse ), and Paige ( @thoughtsbypaige ) as they recap their favorite unscripted and scripted dramas. The queens are tasked with recording and performing songs based on iconic Drag Race monologues a la "Now That's What I Call Music!"...

It's our 200th episode! 🎉🎉🎉 There's really no way that we'd rather celebrate than by talking about the Mythic Quest season finale, "Heaven and Hell." Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Chels ( @chels725 ) have a lot to say! (Jenn was an excellent secret-keeper. 🤭) They start by talking about the hilarious new role that Jo has been "demoted" to and what Brad's decis...

It's the penultimate episode of Mythic Quest this season, and that means a lot of characters are coming to terms with their next steps. There's a lot of FaceTime involved. It's time to discuss "Telephone"! Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Chels ( @chels725 ) are back to discuss David's frazzled energy in this episode, the entire episode being an actual game of "telephone,...

Every season, Mythic Quest delivers us an excellent standalone episode, and this year we get to know more about Brendan in "Rebrand"! Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Chels ( @chels725 ) are joined by their podcasting pal David ( Gimmicks ; Are You My Mother? ; Fear Coded ) to talk all about the theme of this episode, exploring what it means to grow up, parasocial relationships, talk about Ian&ap...

On this week's Mythic Quest episode, Ian and Poppy's relationship finally fractures as David and Rachel appear before Congress. We're talking about "The Room Where It Happens"! Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Chels ( @chels725 ) are joined by their lovely friends Sharai ( A Nightmare on Fierce Street ; Blerdy Massacre ) and Emmy-nominated writer Alrinthea ! They all discuss the Co...

This week on our Mythic Quest rewatch, it's time for a poker game that contains some pretty high stakes. Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Chels ( @chels725 ) are joined by friends and former guests, Matt from Communiess ( @communiess ) and Elyse ( @princessbilbo ) to discuss "The Fish and the Whale"! The group talks about Brad trying to outsmart David in poker, what they thought of the 5-mon...

This week, Poppy deals with some news: she's pregnant! We're back to talk all about "Second Skeleton." Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Chels ( @chels725 ) have so many thoughts about this hilarious, heartfelt episode. (We adore you, Ashly Burch!)  They talk all about Poppy's fears of being a bad mom, how Ian tries to help, and what they think of Shannon being the person who ultima...

It's time for an Agatha Christie-style murder mystery party this week on Mythic Quest . Who's ready for "The Villain's Feast"? Jenn ( @notajenny ) and Chels ( @chels725 ) have returned to talk about this absolute banger of an episode with the very funny and talented writers of it: Megan Ganz and Humphrey Ker ! (Their adorable pug Hilda also makes an appearance in this epis...