Radiotopia
Amityvilleville
If you’ve ever thought to yourself, “Wow, I’d really love to listen to Reply All/Hyperfixed's Alex Goldman and former VICE culture writer Caroline Thompson absolutely lose their minds watching every Amityville movie ever made,” then boy do we have a podcast for you! On a cold November night in 1974, 23-year-old Ron DeFeo Jr. picked up a .35 caliber rifle and crept room to room in his lakeside family home in Amityville, New York. By dawn, his mother, father, and four younger siblings all lay cold and dead in their beds. Over the last half century, this gruesome family annihilation and the alleg...
Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: play.prx.org
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
The Amityville Horror (2005) 15.05.2026 1:22:07
I thought we just did this movie like 10 movies ago. Oh this time though Ryan Reynolds is acting his butt off. And his shirt off. Like his shirt is off for this entire movie. As of this writing, The Amityville Horror (2005) is available on the following streaming services: TUBI The Roku Channel Pluto TV
My Amityville Horror 08.05.2026 57:28
This week we watch a documentary about Danny Lutz, son of Amityville haunting victim George Lutz, about his experiences growing up in a haunted house. Honestly this one might more harrowing than all the movies we've watched up until this point. As of this writing, My Amityville Horror is available on the following streaming services: Xumo Philo Roku
Amityville Dollhouse 01.05.2026 1:23:43
This one is set in the desert for some reason and has nothing to do with Amityville as far as we can tell, but there's spiders, wasps, rats zombie dads, and reused props from other movies Alex has seen. Oh and incest. There's more incest. As of this writing, Amityville Dollhouse is available on the following streaming platforms: Pluto TV The CW Tubi Roku Plex
Amityville: A New Generation 24.04.2026 1:23:23
TW: Suicide Amityville is a mirror now, I guess. And like in LA? It’s somewhere, but it ain’t amityville. But there's a guy named Keyes Terry. Oh and Locke from Lost is here. As of this writing, Amityville: A New Generation is streaming on the following services: Sling Roku Plex Tubi Amazon
Amityville 1992: It's About Time 17.04.2026 1:18:17
The horror is a sexy clock now, and it can turn you into a baby. Frankly, that's none of my business. As of this writing, you can watch Amityville 1992: It's About Time on the following streaming services: Pluto TV Sling Plex Roku Tubi
The Amityville Curse (1990) 10.04.2026 1:03:04
Look, Caroline wants to fuck the lamp. I'm no happier about this than you are. In this week's movie, a bunch of annoying Canadians go to a house that has nothing to do with the Amityville house, never utter the word Amityville and infuriate the shit out of Alex and Caroline for 90 minutes. To be clear, this episode of the podcast is a banger. But the movie is terrible. As of this writing, The Ami...
Amityville: The Evil Escapes 03.04.2026 1:07:07
This time the horror is a lamp. And maybe a cat? As of this writing, you can watch Amityville the evil escapes on the following platforms TUBI CW Xumo Sling Roku
Amityville 3-D 27.03.2026 1:16:06
Here's how my mom and dad fell back in love after my dad bought a haunted house that killed me and then exploded. As of this writing, Amityville 3-D is available (lamentably, in 2-D) on the following streaming services: TUBI Pluto TV If you are just discovering this podcast, please consider listening to Alex's other podcast, Hyperfixed
Amityville II: The Possession 20.03.2026 59:35
We're on the second movie and already deeply upset. The Montellis ( not the Lutzes) move into 112 Ocean Avenue, and things go down hill quickly (both for the Montellis and for the viewer). As of this writing, Amityville II: The Possession is available for streaming on: Tubi Pluto If you are just discovering this podcast, please consider listening to Alex's other podcast, Hyperfixed
The Amityville Horror 13.03.2026 53:38
The movie that started all. Josh Brolin and Margot Kidder run afoul of priests, pigs and the paranormal. As of this writing, The Amityville Horror is available to stream for free on: Tubi Sling TV Pluto TV If you are just discovering this podcast, please consider listening to Alex's other podcast, Hyperfixed
Episode 0 - The History of the Amityville Murders 22.01.2026 48:12
In this introduction to the Amityville series, Caroline schools Alex about the real life history of the DeFeo family killings, as well as the subsequent "haunting" of the Lutz family.
Amityvilleville Trailer 30.12.2025 1:16
A trailer for the new Amityvilleville podcast. Follow us on social media everywhere @ amityvilleville
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.