PlanetWorka

Agency & Development - Do Individuals Matter?

Business EN ↓ 28 episodes

Contemporary international development practice is shaped by politics and extends historical assumptions, concepts and narratives that specify ways of working for professional and practitioners in international and 'local' NGOs. This series explores the theoretical and ethical issues in contemporary development organisations and their discourse, and how development NGO workers are 'captured' by this discourse. planetworka.substack.com

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: planetworka.substack.com

Author

PlanetWorka

Category

Business

Podcast website

planetworka.substack.com

Latest episode

Sep 20, 2023

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

Concluding Thoughts - Can Practitioners Have Agency? 20.09.2023

Is there space for individual agency within the confines of developmentalism? Only if we actively dismantle the two pillars of this ideology - neliberalism and institutionalisation - and confront the power of technocratic elites and INGOs... This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit planetworka.substack.com

Do practitioners have individual agency? 20.09.2023

Considering what we have covered in this podcast series, do Plan CDFs exert agency as individual actors? As this episode argues, they cannot, as this is a misreading of 'agency' as an expression of individual action or attributes that is central to developmentalist discourse. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit p...

Performatist Tropes - Project Media 18.09.2023

Publicising development in the form of projects fulfils important needs of developmentalism. On the one hand it serves northern donors with expressions of the success of development subjects, while simultaneously re-legitimising the INGO as an enabling actor in this success. To do so, project media visits have to set up highly performative scenarios where the primary emergent interests are not nec...

Performatist Tropes - The Project Visit 18.09.2023

NGO, donor and local government project visits are ceremonious and ritualised, imbuing the event with important political symbolism essential to the legitimacy of actors and their relative status. For the development actors, these events maintain developmental continuity in their areas of operation. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to...

Performatist Tropes - The Sponsor Visit 18.09.2023

Child sponsorship is essentially a virtual experience, played out through communication and marketing intermediaries. These programs do, however, offer the opportunity for a sponsor to visit 'their' sponsored child. The sponsor visit becomes a microcosm of neo-colonial arrangements and interactions. The compliance of the sponsored child's family is essential to this enterpise, regardless of benefi...

Performatist Tropes - Partnership 18.09.2023

Partnership is an essential part of contemporary INGO practice and a central trope of developmentalist discourse. Yet, the interaction between INGOs and local actors is replete with contradiction, embedded power imbalance, and reproduction of traditional roles. In fact, the process and instruments in establishing partnership are the main driver of neutralising contention. This is a public episode....

Performatist Tropes - 'Planning Development' 17.09.2023

Developmentalist practice involves the performance of well-worn tropes. One of these is 'planning development', with highly stylised processes to design and conduct participatory design workshops. This episode examines this iconic development trope. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit planetworka.substack.com

Developmentalism in Operational Practice 17.09.2023

The field setting is where developmentalism finds expression in the everyday operations of organisations and the daily lives of practitioners. This episode sets the scene for the reality of operational practice of NGO community practice teams in Tanzania. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit planetworka.substack.c...

From Individual Sponsorship to Community Development 11.04.2023

Towards and into the 2000s, the shift from individualist charity - in the form of child sponsorship - to collective modes of community development accelerated in INGOs like Plan International. PlanetWorka explores how this was influenced by development trends, as well as insitutional pressures to preserve the power and confidence of Northern donors. This is a public episode. If you would like to d...

The Girl Effect, Neoliberal Feminism & Developmentalism 09.04.2023

The Girl Effect, and a focus of development effort on the 'girl of the South', has become a dominant theme in international NGOs and development institutions. Driven by neoliberal feminism in the North, this narrative seeks to redefine the identity of women in the South, and legitimise neoliberal tropes of empowerment and entrepreneurship. PlanetWorka explores the rationale and implications throug...

Child Sponsorship 07.04.2023

Child sponsorship pre-dates the development decades, and the era of community development. As such, it appears as an anachronism to the dominant collective discourse of contemporary development, yet remains remarkably resilient as a development and fundraising modality. PlanetWorka traces the evolution of child sponsorship in a well-known International NGO to demonstrate how it has effectively tra...

The Reflexive Practitioner 02.04.2023

In an attempt to resolve the contradictions inherent in the 'developer's' role, development ideology promotes reflexivity in practice. In a context of developmentalism, does it matter? As they become more aware of their role can development practitioners adapt in a manner that is meaningful? This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus e...

Development Practitioners in International NGOs 26.03.2023

International NGOs employ a range of development staff, stratified carefully between operations and 'program' in country offices. Within the 'program' staff, expertise is differentiated bewteen professional at the national head office and local development facilitators. Moreover, most international NGOs rely heavily on 'community volunteers' - unpaid local residents who play a crucial role in oper...

Professionalisation and Devaluing the 'Local' 24.03.2023

Professionalisation has brought a powerful dynamic into the world of the development practitioner, creating an epistemic divide between the transnational 'expert' and the 'local' development practitioner. The former elevated to a powerful role, the latter constrained by their positionality and characteristics of the 'other'. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other su...

Managerialism and Technologies of Control 18.03.2023

Contemporary development practice invovles the implementation of highly technical project planning and implementation approaches. Rather than enhancing development outcomes, these represent technologies of control. Implemented as part of a culture of managerialism, these approaches ensure that the 'expert' is able to assert control over both the local development facilitator and community particip...

Development Practice as Norms Transfer 18.03.2023

Is the development practitioners role to 'deliver' development, or impose development discourse? Development practitioners are important interlocutors for translating developmentalism into localised norms, calling into question the ethical virtue of their work. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit planetworka.subs...

The Development 'Practitioner' 18.03.2023

If development practice is where developmentalism is cemented, then the development practioner must be the labourer that applies this. Who are these 'practitioners'? In this episode PlanetWorka explores the positionality of the development worker in development, and identifies a growing divide between the global development professional, and the local commuity development worker. This is a public...

Judith Butler's Notion of Performativity 05.03.2023

A powerful gender and identity theorist, Judith Butler has conceptualised human agency as 'performativity'. PlanetWorka examines how this is different from the notion of performance, how performativity refers to the constitution of identity through repeated routines, and how re-signification offers potential for agency. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscri...

Giddens and Foucault - Reshaping Agency in Development 05.03.2023

Two eminent theorists have shaped our understanding of individual agency in development. Anthony Giddens' theory of Structuration a nd Michel Foucault's theory of Governmentality are heavy influences on developmentalism. PlanetWorka explores how key ideas in these theories have shaped how individual agency is located in developmentalist discourse. This is a public episode. If you would like to dis...

Individual Agency in Social Theory 05.03.2023

How does the concept of individual agency address the tension between the excessive individualism of liberal theory, and the focus of the collective 'community' in development? PlanetWorka explores how social theory has influenced the notion of individual agency in development, and located this centrally in normative expectations of collective social action and benefit. This is a public episode. I...

Managerialism and the Technology of Control 02.03.2023

Managerialist approaches have overt political objectives and impact on development processes. Highly technical project planning methodologies using rationalist, outcomes prediction techniques like logical framework analysis create external control of complex social situations. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit...

Institutions and Developmentalism 02.03.2023

It's tempting to see developmentalism as an ideology impsed by a select number of insitututions based in the North. However, development ideology is remarkable for the way in which it is transitted, reinforced and implemented in practice by thousands of development institutions around the globe. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bon...

The Post-Development Critique 02.03.2023

The celebratory narrative of development's successes in the 1990s was characterised by an undercurrent of disquiet. In the face of increasing inequality and disempowerment of the supposed 'beneficiaries' of development, the very architecture came under sustained attack by 'post-development' theorists. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access...

The Individual and Community Development 02.03.2023

"Community Development" is a central trope of developmentalism. How does this relate to the individual, and can the individual only realise 'development' through the collective of 'community'? PlanetWorka explores how the notion of community development relates to the governmentality interests of the state and NGOs. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers...

The Problem of the Nation State 11.02.2023

Whereas in previous development decades states were the focus of development effort, the emerging neoliberal ideology of the 1990s sought to 'depoliticise' development and constrain the power of the nation state in development. As an alternative, civil society in the form of NGOs and international organisations were conferred increasing status and power. Planteworka explores the impact of this shi...

Listen to the Agency & Development - Do Individuals Matter? podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.