Annie Shibley & Caitlin Munsie
Adoption Diaries
Welcome to "Adoption Diaries," a heartfelt podcast hosted by Annie and Caitlin, where the intricacies of adoption are explored through personal stories, expert insights, and candid conversations. In this 10-episode series, join us on a transformative journey through the diverse experiences of adoption, from the initial steps of self-discovery to the joyous moment of welcoming a new family member.
Author
Annie Shibley & Caitlin Munsie
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Jul 6, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
Episode 48: Season 6 - This vs. That - Open vs. Closed Adoption - And Finding Your Path 06.07.2026 11:29
In this final episode of this season This or That series , Annie and Caitlin are exploring open vs. closed adoption - and how to find your path. They clarify definitions, address common misconceptions, and talk about why openness is becoming more common in adoption today. They will discuss the benefits to openness, healthy boundaries, and how openness can evolve over time as relationships, child...
Episode 47 - Season 6: This vs. That - One Agency vs. Multiple Agencies 29.06.2026 12:40
In this episode of Adoption Diaries, Annie & Caitlin are breaking down one agency vs. multiple agencies and what it really means to be multi-listed. They will explain how each approach works and why families might choose one path over the other. They will walk through the pros and cons of each option, including ethical considerations, contract details, and how costs and stress levels can differ...
Episode 46 - Season 6: This vs. That - Professional Profiles vs. Self-Made Profiles 22.06.2026 14:22
In this episode of Adoption Diaries, we're comparing two ways families share their stories with expectant parents: professional vs. self made adoption books. We'll talk about what expectant parents are actually seeing today and how the landscape has shifted in the digital age. Annie & Caitlin break down accessibility and shareability, along with the emotional storytelling differences between onl...
Episode 45 - Season 6: Pep Talk - Action Over Fear: Moving Forward in your Adoption Journey 15.06.2026 9:57
If you've been waiting for the perfect moment , the right sign , or for everything to finally feel "figured out" before starting your adoption journey-this episode is for you. The truth is, adoption isn't a path you can fully map out ahead of time. It's a journey built step by step, decision by decision, with clarity that comes after you move forward - not before. In this pep talk-style episod...
Episode 44 - Season 6: This vs. That: Domestic vs. International Adoption 08.06.2026 17:53
In this episode of "Adoption Diaries", Annie & Caitlin are diving into another big decision point: domestic adoption vs. international adoption. They walk through the legal processes and timelines for each path, and what families can realistically expect along the way. They will discuss travel requirements, cultural considerations, and typical costs, along with the age of children most commonly...
Episode 43 - Season 6: This vs. That: Domestic Infant Adoption vs. Foster Care 01.06.2026 19:17
In this episode of Adoption Diaries, Annie & Caitlin are comparing two common paths to building a family: domestic infant adoption & foster care. They will break down the primary goals of each system - permanency versus reunification - and what that means for hopeful adoptive parents. They explore the key differences, timelines, emotional expectations, and costs along with trauma informed paren...
Episode 42 - Season 6: This vs. That: Why Adoption Decisions Feel So Overwhelming 01.06.2026 9:38
In this kickoff episode of "This vs. Tha: Navigating Your Adoption Journey" mini-series, Caitlin & Annie dive into why adoption decisions can feel so overwhelming. With dozens of paths, agencies, timelines, and opinions, it's easy to fall into the Google rabbit hole and feel paralyzed by choice. We're breaking down why there is no "right" adoption journey - only what is right for your family -...
Episode 41 - Season 5: Reflections from the Heart 16.03.2026 6:07
In this special season finale of Adoption Diaries: Adoption from the Heart, Annie & Caitlin come together and reflect on the stories that have shaped this season and offer personal takeaways. Join them as they celebrate the wisdom of the season, the beauty of shared experiences, and the ways in which listening to these voices can guide, support, and transform families on their own adoption jour...
Episode 40 - Season 5: Quick Tip - Their Story, Not Ours: Navigating Adoption Questions from Day One 09.03.2026 14:23
This quick tip episode of Adoption Diaries explores how to talk about adoption from the very beginning - and how those conversations should evolve once your child has their own voice and story. From instrusive questions to well-meaning but misinformed ones, we share how we respond matters just as much as what we say. Annie and Caitlin offer a practical guide for protecting your child's dignity,...
Episode 39 - Season 5: The Dad Perspective - Love, Fear, and Fatherhood in Adoption 02.03.2026 37:23
In this heartfelt episode of Adoption Diaries, Annie & Caitlin sit down with a very special guest - Caitlin's husband, Tim Munsie - to explore a perspective we don't hear nearly enough in the adoption community: the father's experience. As a dad to two biological children and one adopted son, Tim offers a thoughtful and honest look at how adoption reshaped his understanding of fatherhood, family,...
Episode 38 - Season 5: Guided with Love: A Client's Story of Adoption & Support 23.02.2026 33:36
In this heart-forward episode of Adoption Diaries, Annie & Caitlin sit down with Tiny Hearts client, Amanda, to share a story rooted in courage, vulnerability, and deep love. As part of our new series, Adoptions from the Heart, this conversation invites listeners into the real, lived experience of one family's adoption journey - told with honesty, tenderness, and the wisdom that only comes from...
Episode 37 - Season 5: Quick Tips - Communication Matters 16.02.2026 12:30
Good communication can change everything - and this episode is packed with practical, bite-sized advice to help families strengthen how they connect throughout their journey. Annie & Caitlin share quick, actionable tips for communicating with agencies, and adoption professionals, all through the lens of respect and compassion. This conversation reminds listeners that communication isn't about sa...
Episode 36 - Season 5: Adoption Through Generations: A Conversation with a Grammie Impacted by Adoption 09.02.2026 18:33
In this episode, Annie & Caitlin sit down with Donna Shibley, Annie's mother, to reflect on the ripple effects of adoption within their family. Donna shares her heartfelt perspective on Annie's adoption journey, offering insight into how adoption has shaped their family dynamics across generations. This conversation dives into the challenges and joys of navigating adoption with loved ones, whi...
Episode 35 - Season 5: Stories from the Heart - An Introduction to Season 5 02.02.2026 7:40
Join Annie & Caitlin as they kick off Season 5 of Adoption Diaries with an overview of their new series, Stories from the Heart . In this opening episode, they set the stage for the heartfelt, real, and deeply personal conversations to come - stories from individuals whose lives have been forever shaped by adoption. This season is about uncovering narratives that resonate with vulnerability, lov...
Episode 34 - Season 4: Growing Together - Resources for the Older Adoptee (ft. Elena S. Hall) 22.12.2025 28:11
As children grow, their understanding of adoption evolves - and so does the role of adoptive parents. Tune into this insightful conversation that Annie & Caitlin have with Elena S. Hall, author and adoptee. Learn how parents can support older adoptees thorugh changing emotions, identity, and development, and new questions that arise over time. Together, we will talk through resources, books, an...
Episode 33 - Season 4: Transracial Adoption in Real Life 15.12.2025 11:00
Transracial adoption is a lifelong journey of learning, listening, and intentionality. In this episode, Annie & Caitlin share practical ways families can support their child's identity and belonging - from choosing barbershops and doctors offices to surrounding your child with diverse representation in books, toys, and media. They dive into why these seemingly small choices matter deeply for a c...
Episode 32- Season 4: Your Adoption Profile Book & Beyond (ft. Kendahl from Little Ampersand & Co.) 08.12.2025 22:51
Your adoption journey begins with the relationships you build - and your connection with professionals is one of the most important. In this conversation with Kendahl, Annie, & Caitlin they talk about all things adoption, including why your profile book matters, and how those early interactions can shape your experience in meaningful ways. Together, they break down what makes a strong profile bo...
Episode 31 - Season 4: The First Call with an Expectant Mom 01.12.2025 13:42
That first call with an expectant Mom can hold so much anticipation - and a lot of emotion. In this episode, Annie & Caitlin walk through how to prepare for the conversation, what questions to ask (and what to avoid), and how to create a safe, genuine space for connection. They offer language, mindset shifts, and real examples of how to lead with empathy and humility, rather than pressure or per...
Episode 30 - Season 4: Gratitude & Grace - Holding Hope on your Adoption Journey through the Holidays and Beyond 24.11.2025 14:48
The adoption wait can stir up so many emotions on the journey - joy, longing, gratitude, and sometimes grief. In this episode, Annie & Caitlin offer a heartfelt pep talk for anyone navigating the wait. Whether you're waiting to be matched, navigating openness, or findng your footing with a new connection, this conversation invites you to pause and breathe. Together, they share gentle reminder...
Episode 29 - Season 4: Openness in Adoption - Before & Beyond Placement 17.11.2025 17:52
Openness is more than a concept - it's a posture of the heart. In this episode, Annie & Caitlin explore what healthy openness looks like both before and after placement. They talk through what it means to discuss openness during the waiting stage, how to prepare emotionally, and how to approach the topic with honesty and grace. Beyond placement, openness often shifts and grows. Annie & Caitl...
Episode 28 - Season 4: Walking with You: A Guide to the Adoption Journey Intro 10.11.2025 10:14
In this opening episode, Annie & Caitlin share the heart behind Walking With You and why they believe no one should navigate the adoption process alone. They'll reflect on how this series was created to meet families right where they are - whether you're waiting, newly matched, or years into parenting - and to remind you that support, learning, and community matter at every stage. Listeners will...
Episode 27 - Season 3: Adoption Reflections, Lessons, & Light 23.12.2024 11:40
As we close our Season 3 of Adoption Diaries and the year 2024, we're taking a moment to reflect on the powerful stories, heartfelt conversations, and impactful lessons shared throughout this season. In this finale, Annie will revisit key moments from the season and shares personal takeaways. Join us for this reflection wrap-up as we celebrate the connections we've built, the growth we've experi...
Episode 26 - Season 3: Talking to Your Adoptee about Their Journey 16.12.2024 12:05
In this heartfelt and practical episode of "Adoption Diaries", Annie and Caitlin explore the importance of having open, honest, and age-appropriate conversations with your child about their adoption journey. From starting the dialogue in early childhood to deepening the conversation as your adoptee grows, this episode offers strategies and insights to help parents navigate these meaningful disc...
Episode 25 - Season 3: Insight 101 | Tips When You and Your Partner are Deciding on Adoption as Your Path 09.12.2024 16:24
In this episode of Adoption Diaries, we dive into one of the most pivotal moments on the adpotion journehy: deciding with your partner if adoption is the right path for your family. We know that reaching this decision is rarely straightforward. That is why we're sharing essential tips to help guide you both through the process with intention, openness, and a sense of partnership. From examin...
Episode 24 - Season 3: Blending Bonds | Navigating Adoption with Biological Children 02.12.2024 24:33
In Blending Bonds: Navigating Adoption with Biological Children, Annie sits down with Caitlin for an honest and heartfelt conversation about Caitlin's adoption journey. Through Annie's thoughtful questions, Caitlin shares her experiences of adopting while raising biological children, offering insight into how her family navigating the joys, challenges, and transitions that come with blending biol...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.