A Reasonable Response

In this episode of  A Reasonable Response , Robert Bosley examines the recent controversy surrounding John Piper's comments on faith, works, and justification. While Piper's language sparked debate across Reformed circles, Bosley argues that his teaching is thoroughly consistent with Scripture and historic Protestant theology. Looking to James 2 and the broader witness of the New Testament, B...

In this episode of A Reasonable Response , Robert Bosley responds to Sam Storms' article,  "A Complementarian Case for Women as Pastors,"  and argues that the proposal ultimately blurs biblical categories rather than clarifying them.  Bosley contends that Scripture consistently links the work and title of pastor to the office of elder and that attempts to apply the title  pasto...

In this episode of  A Reasonable Response , Robert Bosley evaluates common anti-Calvinist arguments and explains why they ultimately fail to persuade when measured against the teaching of Scripture. Bosley argues that these objections often rest on an elevated view of human autonomy and a misunderstanding of God’s sovereignty and love. When Scripture is allowed to speak on its own terms...

In this episode of  A Reasonable Response , Robert Bosley responds to the teaching of Henry Cloud, author of  Boundaries , and examines how modern therapeutic approaches to personal autonomy can conflict with the authority of Scripture. Bosley argues that the central issue is ownership. Scripture teaches that we are not our own—we belong to God—and are therefore called to liv...

In this episode of  A Reasonable Response , Robert Bosley refutes the claims of self-identified Christian progressive James Talarico and argues that his theology and proposed policies cannot meaningfully be called Christian. Bosley contends that the central issue is not personal identification or academic affiliation, but authority. When the sufficiency of Scripture is rejected and replaced w...

In this episode of  A Reasonable Response , Robert Bosley responds to the common assumption that Baptists hold a merely symbolic or memorial view of the Lord’s Supper and explains why this claim misunderstands both Baptist theology and the broader Reformed tradition.   Bosley argues that the Lord’s Supper—like baptism—is an effectual means of grace. While it does...

In this episode of  A Reasoned Response , Robert Bosley evaluates the case for paedocommunion—the practice of admitting young children to the Lord’s Table on the basis of covenant membership—and explains why it ultimately fails under careful biblical scrutiny. Bosley argues that the central issue is not whether children may one day be capable of faith, self-examination, or d...

In this episode of  A Reasoned Response , Robert Bosley addresses the appeal of annihilationism—the belief that the wicked are eventually destroyed rather than eternally punished—and explains why it ultimately fails both logically and biblically. Bosley argues that annihilationism rests on a flawed assumption: that sinners somehow stop sinning once they die. Scripture, however, pr...

In this special episode of A Reasoned Response , Robert Bosley addresses a recurring point of tension among Christians: whether believers should celebrate Christmas at all. Rather than treating the issue as a litmus test of faithfulness, Bosley frames it as a matter of Christian liberty that must be handled with love, humility, and a Christ-centered focus. He warns those who celebrate Christmas ag...

In this blunt and straightforward episode of  A Reasoned Response , Robert Bosley exposes the core error of homosexual affirming theology and movements that claim Christians can keep sinful desires—such as same-sex attraction or other disordered inclinations—as part of their identity. Bosley argues from Scripture that this is not Christianity but a distortion of the gospel. He exp...

In this episode of  A Reasonable Response , Robert Bosley examines the origins and theology of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, more commonly known as Mormonism. Beginning with a historical overview of Joseph Smith and the rise of the movement in 19th-century America, Bosley moves from history to theology—contrasting Mormon teaching about God, Scripture, and salvation wi...

In this sobering episode of A Reasonable Response , Robert Bosley confronts a dangerous distortion of Jesus emerging from progressive theology—a version of Christ with no lordship, no law, and no demand for repentance. Bosley contrasts this false gospel with the true message of Scripture: that while our sins are great, Christ is greater, and only in Him is there forgiveness and eternal hope....

In this episode of  A Reasonable Response , Robert Bosley tackles the lightning-rod issue of  patriarchy —a word that sparks outrage in some circles and confusion in others. Responding to viral videos and modern critiques of passages like Proverbs 31, Bosley offers a calm, biblical, and thoughtful defense of male headship and gender roles as taught in Scripture. Rather than reactin...

In this episode of  A Reasonable Response , Robert Bosley takes on a controversial and often emotionally charged question:  Are Roman Catholics truly Christians? While many within evangelical circles are quick to affirm Roman Catholics as brothers and sisters in Christ, Bosley pushes back—explaining why, according to Scripture and a biblical understanding of the gospel, this claim...

In this episode of  A Reasonable Response , Robert Bosley tackles the often-polarizing topic of dispensationalism. After a few lighthearted reactions to some of the more extreme online voices, Bosley shifts into “The Breakdown” to address core dispensational claims—especially those concerning Israel, prophecy, and God’s promises. He challenges popular interpretations,...

In this episode of  A Reasonable Response , Robert Bosley reflects on the long-standing theological differences between Baptists and Presbyterians—particularly regarding the nature of the New Covenant and whether covenant signs should be applied to children.   Rather than stirring division, Bosley highlights the shared faith both traditions hold in Christ and encourages a spirit of...

In this episode of  A Reasonable Response , Robert Bosely, with clarity and care, walks through seven popular egalitarian arguments—touching on creation, the fall, spiritual gifts, and Galatians 3—and responds from a confessional Reformed Baptist position. Bosley shows how Scripture affirms both the dignity of women and the distinct roles God has designed within the church. Whethe...