The Wise Guys Podcast

Who are you trusting to tell you what the Catholic Church teaches? In a world of Catholic influencers, political commentators, and endless online controversy, it's easy to confuse someone's opinion with the teaching of the Church. The Wise Guys discuss why Catholics need to go to the sources, think critically about the voices they follow, and take responsibility for their own formation. From polit...

Are you following Jesus out of love and trust, or trying to prove that you're a good Catholic?  In this episode, we discuss the difference between "righteousness through faith" and "righteousness from works", why our spiritual practices can become more about performance rather than surrender, and how genuine faith changes the way we face fear, temptation, and everyday struggles. If you've ever fel...

Are we living as missionary disciples? Or just consuming the Catholic faith? In this episode of The Wise Guys, we discuss why Catholics can get stuck going through the motions, how parishes can foster real discipleship, and why encountering Jesus should lead us to share Him with others. Are you a Catholic consumer or a missionary disciple?

What does it actually mean to be a good Catholic man? In this episode, the Wise Guys unpack Ephesians 5, headship, masculinity, and the temptation to confuse Catholic aesthetics and cultural stereotypes with holiness. What happens when things like toughness, authority, traditional roles, or even devotion become performances rather than expressions of a transformed heart?

Why does the Catholic Church seem to struggle to engage men? In this episode, The Wise Guys talk about masculinity, men's ministry, vulnerability, and why Catholic men's groups don't need more machismo. They need a better way to help men encounter Jesus, build brotherhood, and become fully integrated men.

Can you be a deeply religious Catholic and still miss the point of your faith? Scott and Michel talk about the tension between religious practices and a personal relationship with Jesus—and why Catholics need both. From the Rosary and daily prayer to confession and spiritual disciplines, the goal isn't simply to check the boxes. It's intimacy with God.

Why does it seem like some people are just more blessed than others? Some find success, financial security, a spouse, or an easier life, while others seem to struggle year after year. Does that mean God favors some people more than others? In this episode, the Wise Guys wrestle with the mystery of God’s providence, suffering, human freedom, and what it actually means to be “blessed.” We talk about...

In this episode of The Wise Guys Podcast, Scott and Michel tackle one of the most common questions facing young adults today. We discuss the financial realities driving cohabitation, the cultural messages that have reshaped dating and marriage, and the deeper wisdom behind the Church's teaching on waiting until marriage. Is living together really the best preparation for marriage? Or does it unint...

How do you know when God is actually speaking to you, and when it’s just your emotions, your own thoughts, or something else? In this episode of The Wise Guys, we talk about the difference between charisma and charisms, why authentic spiritual gifts aren't something we simply “turn on,” and what the lives of the saints can teach us about humility, suffering, holiness, and extraordinary gifts.

What if the problem isn’t that marriage, family life, or faith are harder than you expected, but that you expected them to be easier? In this episode, the Wise Guys talk about moving beyond idealism and learning to love through the ordinary, difficult, day-to-day reality of life. From the honeymoon phase of marriage to the “mountaintop” moments of faith, real maturity comes when we learn to stay c...

Is wealth a blessing, a danger, or both? What happens when financial security becomes our goal? In this episode, we explore Jesus' challenging teachings on money, the difference between God's economy and the world's economy, and what it really means to be a faithful steward of what we've been given. Whether you have a little or a lot, what does God want you to do with it?

We unpack one of Christianity's most quoted but least explained phrases: "Be in the world, but not of the world." Rather than encouraging Christians to withdraw from culture—or to simply blend into it—we argue for a third path: becoming spiritually mature enough to engage the world without losing your identity.  Christian maturity isn't about fearfully avoiding the world, but about becoming rooted...

Our culture tells us to create our own identity. Christianity offers something different. Join us as we explore what it means to belong to Christ, embrace who God made you to be, and find lasting freedom.

In this episode, we explore why some intentional Christian communities flourish while others slowly become controlling, unhealthy, or simply fall apart. Drawing from real experiences with homeschooling groups, Catholic communities, monasteries, and everyday friendships, we discuss the difference between genuine fellowship and communities that unintentionally become driven by fear, idealism, or unh...

Why are so many young adults delaying marriage, careers, families, and big life decisions? In this episode of The Wise Guys, we explore why an entire generation has become afraid to take risks—and why waiting for the "perfect" moment may actually be keeping us from the life God is calling us to. Life has never come with guarantees. The Christian life has always been an adventure. If you've ever fe...

What happens when faithful Catholics become convinced the Church has made a serious mistake?   In this episode, we unpack the history behind the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX), Vatican II, and one of the biggest questions Catholics still wrestle with today: What do you do when you think the Church is wrong?    This conversation isn't just about one movement in the Church—it's about learning how Cath...

As America approaches its 250th anniversary, what does authentic patriotism actually look like for a Christian? We begin with John Adams' famous statement: "Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people." Was he right? And what does that mean for us today? In this episode, we explore why patriotism is a genuine Christian virtue. It's not blind nationalism or partisan politics, bu...

In this episode, Scott and Michel discuss recent "alien" sightings and reports and how we as Catholics should respond. They chat about the laws of physics, the probability of alien life existing, and whether or not it's reasonable to believe that the alien sightings could actually be demons or angels manifesting themselves. If you've been unsettled by any of these reports, you don't want to miss t...

In Part 4 of our series on Pope Leo XIV’s Magnifica Humanitas, we unpack Chapters 4 and 5 of the encyclical. We discuss truth in the age of AI, the meaning of human work, and why technology should serve people—not the other way around. Pope Leo reminds us that our future is not determined by machines, but by the choices we make. Join us as we explore his vision for building a culture rooted in hum...

In this episode, Scott and Michel continue breaking down the Pope's latest encyclical, Magnifica Humanitas, and explore what it means to be human in the age of AI. We discuss why technology can imitate human abilities but can never replace the spiritual dignity, freedom, and soul of the human person. We unpack the dangers of a technocratic mindset and transhumanism, while reflecting on Pope Leo’s...

In this epsiode, Scott and Dr. Therrien continue breaking down Pope Leo XIV's Encyclical Letter, Magnifica Humanitas, in depth so that you can grow in understanding of the purpose and breadth of the Church's social teaching, and how to approach the use of AI and technology without compromising your Catholic faith. We discuss the true meaning of social justice and break down the underlying principl...

In this epsiode, we take the time to break down Pope Leo XIV's Encyclical Letter, Magnifica Humanitas, in depth so that you can grow in understanding of the purpose and breadth of the Church's social teaching, and how to approach the use of AI and technology without compromising your Catholic faith. We cover why the Church releases documents like this, how teachings develop, and why the Church has...

In this episode, we talk about what reverence actually means, whether Catholics sometimes unintentionally treat God like He’s distant or untouchable, and how Jesus constantly reveals Himself as deeply holy *and* deeply approachable. We discuss fear, intimacy with God, the Eucharist, and how receiving Jesus should draw us closer to Him — not keep us at arm’s length. We also get into why affection a...

In this episode, we dive into confession, conscience, and the fine line between conviction and scrupulosity. We talk about what actually makes a sin mortal, how to discern grave matter, and how to examine your conscience without spiraling into shame or anxiety.    We also explore what confession can look like when you’re not bringing major sins, but instead trying to understand the deeper roots be...

Miracles are one of the most fascinating parts of Christianity, but what are they for?   In this episode, we explore what miracles actually are, why Jesus performed them, and whether or not miracles have decreased since the time of the Apostles. We also chat about healing Masses, miraculous healings, and the tension between healthy skepticism and genuine openness to God’s power.   This conversatio...