Code 10-67: Echoes of Evidence

On the evening of March 31, 2010, 31-year-old Jacob Cabinaw played a casual round of disc golf with a friend in Traverse City, dropped him off, and promised he was heading home to study. A National Guard member, mechanic, and father of two, Jacob had every reason to stay—he was actively saving to buy a home, loved his family, and was deeply rooted in his Northern Michigan community. He never made...

With school starting we didnt have time to put anything together. So heres a throwback from For The B-oo's podcast trye crime episode of Gerard John Shaefer. It was recorded in late 2024. In 1972, a badge meant safety, authority, and protection. But along the desolate, sun-bleached stretches of Florida’s Hutchinson Island, Deputy Gerard John Schaefer was using his uniform for something far more si...

On a cold February evening in 2005, two devoted parents—34-year-old Danielle Imbo and 35-year-old Richard Petrone Jr.—walked out of a bustling bar on Philadelphia’s South Street, climbed into a black Dodge pickup truck, and vanished without a trace. They didn't leave behind a single strand of physical evidence, a pinged cell phone, or a trace of the vehicle. For two decades, investigators and fede...

To those who loved her, Alicia Campitelli was a vibrant, deeply caring person whose energy could light up any room. But on a peaceful evening in Merritt Island, Florida, that light was violently cut short, shocking a close-knit coastal community and leaving investigators with a devastating crime scene. At first glance, the tragedy bore the terrifying hallmarks of a home invasion gone horribly wron...

When retired New Jersey corrections officer and beloved former Boy Scout leader Dennis Pegg was found brutally murdered in his Stillwater home in June 2012, investigators were met with a bloodbath. The ferocity of the attack suggested something deeply personal—but Pegg, a respected pillar of his tight-knit lakeside community, seemed to have no enemies. What the police uncovered next would shatter...

​How does a teenager vanish on a familiar street in broad daylight? The abduction of Mary Lou Arruda transformed Raynham from a peaceful suburb into a landscape of fear. A two-month search eventually led deep into the woods, but the discovery of her body was only the beginning of a larger nightmare. This week, we dive into a haunting case involving a local doughnut maker, controversial investigati...

In 1983, a man was paroled back onto the streets of St. Petersburg, Florida. Within five months, a shadow fell over the Tampa Bay area. ​For years, a series of brutal, seemingly disconnected crimes left local detectives completely baffled. Eldery widows, sudden vanishings, and domestic tragedies went cold, leaving a trail of unanswered questions in the Florida humidity. The cases sat in filing cab...

On May 2, 1995, 15-year-old sophomore Kiplyn Davis vanished during a lunch break at Spanish Fork High School in Utah, leaving behind her purse, makeup, and schoolbooks. What began as a missing persons case quickly turned into one of Utah’s most baffling mysteries, met with a frustrating wall of small-town rumors and shifting stories. ​Decades later, a federal grand jury exposed a shocking conspira...