The Watsonian Weekly

What happens when Americans review a British podcast about two Brits and a Spaniard in a part of America we actually know nothing about? Our review of the second part of "A Study in Scarlet" as told by Sherlock & Co.

Sherlock & Co. returns to A Study in Scarlet after three years, and we're here for it! 

Our review of Sherlock & Co.'s final part of "Crooked Man" finds the bull pups left with questions. And also thoughts about the coming novel adaptation!

Our weekly review of Sherlock & Co. is a bit sleepy this week, not due to the first part of "The Crooked Man" being bad, mind you, but due to some low energy podcasters! Hopefully our other listener besides your lovely self won't give up on us this week.

Bruce Partington Plans on Sherlock & Co. comes to a close, and the Bull Pups are here to give one last review, as well as discuss the Patreon-only "Dead Man's Hand"

Watson takes a back seat this week as Sherlock & Co. went full Mycroft and we do love Sherlock's older brother -- especially their take on him!

Reviewing Sherlock & Co's second part of Bruce Partington Plans, we wander into wondering about how many adaptations of the original Sherlock Holmes sixty stories are left. And it's not Mycroft's fault!

Johanna Draper Carlson joins the bull pup regulars to get into Mycroft Holmes's latest appearance and we liked the episode so much that there was even less to talk about in all the enjoyment.

This week, we have special guests Greg Sullivan and Naching Kassa joining us to discuss the original story of "The Adventure of the Copper Beeches" before we get into the final chapter of the Sherlock & Co. adaptation of same. 

Content Warning: Someone is not having fun at the midpoint listening to Sherlock & Co's adaptation of "Copper Beeches." It might even be multiple someones. Positivity-requiring listeners are cautioned to listen to this one with care.

Our review of the first episode of Sherlock & Co.'s "Copper Beeches" adaptation brings questions: Do we love this story too much to be fair?

A final review of Sherlock & Co's three part adaptation of the Boscombe Valley Mystery sees Watson escaping murder charges without much concern or discussion on this podcast. I mean, he was in jail for murder, which is something you'd think we'd take seriously, but, no, he's Watson, and even his literary agent can't be implicated in a casino heist when he's naming his gang something that Ocean's E...

Two of the three regulars made it home from the Holmes in the Heartland weekend in St. Louis and are here to talk about that and part two of Sherlock & Co.'s "Boscombe Valley" adaptation. (But we're tired so don't expect too much!)

Boscombe Valley is not the place we remember from Conan Doyle in the episode Sherlock & Co had for us, so let's discuss!

We've got Enola Holmes 3 to talk about and she finally has an adventure with Watson in it! After that, back to Sherlock & Co.'s final part of "The Engineer's Thumb," a triumph for some, a tragedy for others!

It's our review of the second episode of Sherlock & Co's adaptation of "The Engineer's Thumb." Remember how Arthur Conan Doyle wrote about Watson taking Victor Hatherly out for dinner and saying how beautiful he was? No? Well, things are a little different in Sherlock & Co. world!

Just the review of Sherlock & Co.'s first part of Engineer's Thumb this week. 

This may be a Watson podcast, but oh, that Mycroft. It's our last dance with the Sherlock & Co. incarnation of the older brother for a while, so let's get into it!

Reviewing the latest Sherlock & Co., casting an adaptation of "Speckled Band," seeing what Watson's Literary Agent was doing in 1896, and trying to drum up engagement, it's the Watsonian Weekly for July 15, 2026. 

A little more bite-sized episode this time as we suffer from Mycroft Holmes deprivation after last week's Sherlock & Co. Also, why was Sherlock Holmes balling up those papers on the train to Boscombe Valley to protect Watson?  You don't have to listen long to find out! 

Since Sherlock & Co. introduced its Mycroft Holmes this week, we're all about that, and joined by Johanna Draper Carlson to discuss her favorite Sherlockian character. And if you hold on for all of that, get ready to turn off the podcast, as Watson's Literary Agent gets a bit naughty . . . or does he?

Where did Watson's own TV show fall in a new top ten list? What happens when a Sherlock Holmes series takes a break? Time to find out!

Our host gets a little help from a friend to discuss David Burke's legacy and a fully stocked bull pup squad gets into the return of not-Sherlock in the final part of Sherlock & Co's adaptation of "The Empty House."

CBS's Watson draws to a close and we have opinions on that. And why we're reviewing Sherlock & Co episodes that don't have Watson in them, I do not know!

This year Reichenbach day falls on Monday, just like it did in 1891 and boy is Watson just taking it hard. Either he's in a coma or needing a brain tumor removed, it's all pillow forts and pie to talk about for the bull pups. There will never be a more Watson week of Watsons! Unless it's next week!