The werecolumbo’s Podcast

WereColumbo is back on track! This week, A.J. and Heather dig into Lady in Waiting, an episode about sibling rivalry, murder, rich white people, and the apparently complicated legal implications of shooting someone multiple times after they’re already dead. Before the recap, Heather starts some podcast beef with SmartLess, while A.J. discovers that his friends apparently think his actual pajamas a...

WereColumbo EP4: Suitable for Fur-Ming | Suitable for Framing Recap This week we’re hanging around the art world as Columbo investigates Suitable for Framing. Before we even get to the murder, though, we revisit one of our own biggest WereColumbo regrets: did we choose the wrong “WereColumbo Moment” back in Episode 2? After listening back, we make our case for why Columbo’s famous “old nose” speec...

WereColumbo EP3: Dead Bite | Dead Weight Recap This week, A.J. and Heather tackle Dead Weight, the third episode of Columbo—and the first episode they simply don’t like. Is it the worst episode of Columbo ever made? Quite possibly. But here’s the more important question: Could the worst episode of Columbo make the best episode of WereColumbo? Want to jump straight to the episode discussion? 🕵️ Col...

This week, A.J. and Heather return to the world of Lieutenant Columbo to discuss the Season 1 classic Death Lends a Hand. Before getting to the case, the hosts dive into a birthday road-rage incident, the strange psychology of yelling at people from inside cars, and whether we'd all be a little kinder if we had to walk everywhere. Want to jump straight to the episode discussion?   🕵️ Columbo recap...

In the premiere episode of WereColumbo, a Columbo recap podcast, we revisit the very first episode of Columbo , Murder by the Book . We break down the pilot mystery starring the wonderfully smug Jack Cassidy, talk through the crime step by step, and admire just how confident this murderer is despite making some… questionable decisions. Along the way we get into mystery-writing partnerships, suspic...