The Reel Rejects

THE ELEVATOR MYSTERY IS SOLVED AND SHELDON FINALLY MEETS HIS MATCH! John Humphrey & Aaron Alexander finish their first-time The Big Bang Theory Season 3 reaction with Episodes 21–23! John & Aaron react to Dr. Elizabeth Plimpton’s visit, the flashback revealing how Leonard met Sheldon, the origin of the Roommate Agreement, the elevator explosion, and Steven Yeun’s memorable cameo. The Season 3 fina...

MICHAEL MYERS IS BACK AND HALLOWEEN 5 MADE JACKIE & JON FURIOUS! Jackie Bonsignore & Jon Maturan watch Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers (1989) for the first time in this full movie reaction and review! Picking up one year after Halloween 4, a traumatized Jamie Lloyd has lost the ability to speak while sharing a mysterious psychic connection with her uncle Michael Myers, who returns to ter...

THE BLACK PROM IS HERE AND CARRIE’S STORY EXPLODES! Roxy Striar & John Humphrey finish Carrie Season 1 with Episodes 7–8, “Romantic Literature” and “AP Physics,” in this Prime Video finale reaction and review! Mike Flanagan’s reimagining of Stephen King’s horror classic reaches its devastating conclusion as Carrie White attends prom and the town of Chamberlain faces the full force of her telekinet...

ONE HOBBIT. THIRTEEN DWARVES. ONE UNEXPECTED JOURNEY BACK THROUGH MIDDLE-EARTH! Jackie Bonsignore & Paige Kimsey watch The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey Extended Edition for the first time! After completing The Lord of the Rings trilogy, they return to Middle-earth for Bilbo Baggins’ first adventure with Gandalf, Thorin Oakenshield, and a company of dwarves determined to reclaim Erebor. Jackie & P...

JASON IS BACK FROM THE DEAD AND THIS TIME HE LIVES! Limited Time Offer – Make healthy eating simple. Get Huel today with my exclusive offer of 15% OFF online with my code https://www.huel.com/REJECTS. New Customers Only. Thank you to Huel for partnering and supporting our show! Jackie Bonsignore & Paige Kimsey watch Friday the 13th Part VI: Jason Lives (1986) for the first time! Tommy Jarvis accid...

CARRIE’S POWERS ARE GROWING AND THE BLACK PROM IS GETTING CLOSER! Roxy Striar & John Humphrey continue their first-time Carrie reaction with Season 1 Episodes 4–6 on Prime Video! In “Dramatic Arts,” “Physical Education,” and “Home Economics,” Carrie gains confidence, trains her telekinetic powers, and begins standing up to Margaret White. Roxy & John react to Tommy Ross asking Carrie to prom, the...

CARRIE HAS US REVISITING MORE STEPHEN KING HORROR! Jackie Bonsignore & Jon Maturan watch Misery (1990) for the first time as we revisit another iconic Stephen King adaptation in celebration of the new Carrie series! In this Misery full movie reaction and review, James Caan stars as novelist Paul Sheldon, whose rescue by obsessive “number one fan” Annie Wilkes becomes a terrifying fight for surviva...

Marvel and DC have given us plenty to talk about this week, and naturally, the internet is handling everything with its usual level of maturity. We're breaking down the big Marvel Television announcements from New York Comic Con 2026, including the new live-action Zodiac series, three upcoming Marvel Zombies spin-off specials, and Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man Season 2, featuring the retur...

THE FIRST PERIOD CHANGES EVERYTHING CARRIE WHITE’S NIGHTMARE BEGINS! Limited Time Offer – Make healthy eating simple. Get Huel today with my exclusive offer of 15% OFF online with my code https://www.huel.com/REJECTS. New Customers Only. Thank you to Huel for partnering and supporting our show! Roxy Striar, Tara Erickson & John Humphrey watch Carrie Episodes 1–3 for the first time in this Prime Vi...

TAKE AWAY HIS SUITS, HIS HOME, AND HIS CONFIDENCE. IS TONY STARK STILL IRON MAN?! Limited Time Offer – Make healthy eating simple. Get Huel today with my exclusive offer of 15% OFF online with my code https://www.huel.com/REJECTS. New Customers Only. Thank you to Huel for partnering and supporting our show! Jackie Bonsignore & Paige Kimsey watch Iron Man 3 (2013) for the first time as Jackie & Pai...

JEAN GREY, PUNISHER, & HULK In A Spider-Man Movie Better Than No Way Home?! Limited Time Offer – Make healthy eating simple. Get Huel today with my exclusive offer of 15% OFF online with my code https://www.huel.com/REJECTS. New Customers Only. Thank you to Huel for partnering and supporting our show! John Humphrey & Andrew Gordon watch Spider-Man: Brand New Day (2026) for the first time in this f...

EXCELSIOR! STAN LEE ARRIVES, THE ONE RING CORRUPTS THE GUYS & SHELDON LOSES HIS PANTS! Get a free 8-count Sample Pack of LMNT’s most popular drink mix flavors with any purchase at https://www. DrinkLMNT.com/rejects John Humphrey & Aaron Alexander continue their first-time The Big Bang Theory Season 3 reaction with Episodes 16–20! In this Big Bang Theory 3x16–3x20 reaction and review, John & Aaron...

I Love You, Junior... Visit https://prizepicks.onelink.me/LME0/RE... and use code REJECTS and get $150 if you win your first $5 lineup! Greg Alba, Coy Jandreau & John Humphrey react to Lanterns Season 1 Episode 8, “Dirt and Stars,” in this full season finale reaction and review! The Lanterns finale brings the mystery surrounding Hal Jordan to its breaking point as John Stewart confronts Sinestro a...

YOU DON’T GET TO 500 MILLION FRIENDS WITHOUT MAKING A FEW ENEMIES! John Humphrey and Jackie Bonsignore watch The Social Network (2010) in this full movie reaction and review ahead of Aaron Sorkin’s The Social Reckoning. Directed by David Fincher and written by Sorkin, the acclaimed Facebook drama follows Mark Zuckerberg, Eduardo Saverin, Sean Parker, and the Winklevoss twins through the creation o...

DIGGER Review, AVENGERS: SECRET WARS production delays, a new SPIDER-MAN Clone Saga TV series, David Fincher leaving Netflix, GODZILLA MINUS ZERO first reactions & RAY GUNN trailer talk! We kick things off with our Digger review and a bigger conversation about the state of the movie star — as Tom Cruise and Brad Pitt face recent box office disappointments while Robert Pattinson continues to thrive...

“YOU BOW TO NO ONE” JACKIE & PAIGE COMPLETE THEIR FIRST-EVER LORD OF THE RINGS JOURNEY! Go to https://hfly.co/ulew7 and use code REELREJECTS to get 5% off on eSIMs and 10% off on Holafly Plans (for up to 12 months)! #HolaflyTraveller Unlimited data for 200+ destinations! Jackie Bonsignore & Paige Kimsey watch The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King Extended Edition for the first time! In thi...

JASON IS DEAD—SO WHO’S BEHIND THE MASK?! Get a free 8-count Sample Pack of LMNT’s most popular drink mix flavors with any purchase at https://www. DrinkLMNT.com/rejects Paige Kimsey & Jackie Bonsignore watch Friday the 13th Part V: A New Beginning (1985) for the first time! In this Friday the 13th Part 5 full movie reaction and review, a traumatized Tommy Jarvis enters the Pinehurst halfway house...

DIGGER MOVIE REVIEW! Johnald Humphrey shares his spoiler-free Digger movie review and out-of-the-theater reaction to director Alejandro G. Iñárritu’s wildly ambitious new tragi-comedy! Tom Cruise undergoes one of the biggest transformations of his career as Digger Rockwell, a powerful oil tycoon racing to prove he can save humanity from a global catastrophe he helped unleash. John discusses Cruise...

50 YEARS LATER, CARRIE’S PROM NIGHT STILL BURNS! Get a free 8-count Sample Pack of LMNT’s most popular drink mix flavors with any purchase at https://www. DrinkLMNT.com/rejects Jackie Bonsignore & Tara Erickson watch Carrie (1976) for the first time in this full movie reaction and review celebrating the Stephen King horror classic’s 50th anniversary! Directed by Brian De Palma and led by Sissy Spa...

Roxy Striar, John Humphrey & Jon Maturan begin Castlevania Season 1 for the very first time! In this Netflix Castlevania full season 1 reaction and review, Roxy, John & Jon experience Dracula’s declaration of war, the attack on Gresit, Trevor Belmont’s brutal tavern fight, Sypha Belnades’ magic, and the unforgettable Trevor Belmont vs. Alucard confrontation! #Castlevania #CastlevaniaReaction #Cast...

AVENGERS ASSEMBLE! JACKIE & PAIGE REACH THE MCU’S FIRST EPIC TEAM-UP! Rula patients typically pay $15 per session when using insurance. Connect with quality therapists and mental health experts who specialize in you at https://www.rula.com/rejects #rulapod Jackie Bonsignore & Paige Kimsey watch The Avengers (2012) for the first time as they continue their MCU journey toward Tom Holland’s Spider-Ma...

EVIL HAS RETURNED TO HADDONFIELD AND THIS TIME, MICHAEL MYERS IS HUNTING A CHILD! Rula patients typically pay $15 per session when using insurance. Connect with quality therapists and mental health experts who specialize in you at https://www.rula.com/rejects #rulapod Jackie Bonsignore & Jon Maturan watch Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers (1988) for the first time! In this Halloween 4 react...

THE MOVIE THEY TRIED TO SHELVE FINALLY ESCAPED THE VAULT! Rula patients typically pay $15 per session when using insurance. Connect with quality therapists and mental health experts who specialize in you at https://www.rula.com/rejects #rulapod Tara Erickson & John Humphrey watch Coyote vs. Acme (2026) for the first time in this full movie reaction and review! The live-action/animated Looney Tunes...

SHELDON GETS ROBBED, RUNS AWAY AND TURNS A BALL PIT INTO COMEDY GOLD! Check out Freecash today using my link: https://bit.ly/4ijrrDU and get a $10 bonus after completing your first offer! Aaron Alexander & John Humphrey continue their first-time The Big Bang Theory Season 3 reaction with Episodes 11–15! In this full episode reaction and review, Aaron & John experience the legendary “Bazinga” ball-...

HAL JORDAN’S LAST SECRET COULD SOLVE EVERYTHING! Taking care of your health just got easier – start here with Zocdoc: https://zocdoc.com/REJECTS #sponsored Greg Alba, John Humphrey & Coy Jandreau react to Lanterns Episode 7, “The Jordan Boys Legacy,” in this full 1x07 reaction and review! The Reel Rejects break down the HBO and DC Studios series’ penultimate episode as John Stewart follows Hal Jor...