Presidencies of the United States

Year(s) Discussed: 1817-1818 Explore a critical juncture in American political history as President James Monroe navigates escalating border violence and foreign filibustering operations along the southern frontier. This episode examines executive leadership under pressure as the administration attempts to suppress the privateering operations at Amelia Island while reacting to fraught relations wi...

Year(s) Discussed: 1820-1889 Before and after entering the White House, Julia Gardiner Tyler learned how public opinion could shape a person’s reputation—and how to push back when the story was wrong. Historians Sharon and Christopher Leahy explore her influence on the evolving role of first lady and the contradictions that connect her life to the wider story of the United States in the 19th centu...

Year(s) Discussed: 1817 As James Monroe returned to a still-under-construction Executive Mansion in late 1817, he faced major tests of executive leadership across foreign and domestic fronts. From dispatching a diplomatic commission to South America to handling Andrew Jackson's challenge to civilian military authority, this deep dive into American political history reveals the volatile conflicts t...

Year(s) Discussed: 1898-1918 In the second half of the conversation, with my special guest, Joe Pascone of the Turning Tides Podcast, we move from Puerto Rico’s 19th-century struggle for autonomy into the island’s capture by the United States and the legal limbo that followed. We examine the fallout of the Spanish-American War, the rise of American corporate and political control, and the ways Pue...

Year(s) Discussed: 1815-1898 In the first part of this conversation, I am joined by Joe Pascone of the Turning Tides Podcast to trace Puerto Rico’s history from the post-Napoleonic era through the rise of nationalism, rebellion, and colonial resistance. We explore the island’s shifting political status, the legacy of piracy and slavery, and how Puerto Rico became a crucial but often overlooked par...

Year(s) Discussed: 1945-2026 This episode explores how leadership can be shaped by fear, strategy, and the deliberate projection of strength. It traces the ideas behind the Madman Theory, showing how Cold War thinking, presidential power, and public perception collided to influence some of the most consequential decisions in modern politics. Along the way, it asks what happens when a leader tries...

Year(s) Discussed: 1776-2026 In this episode, we explore how the US Declaration of Independence has been interpreted and reinterpreted by presidents, reformers, and political movements over time. My conversation with author Tony Williams traces how leadership shapes the meaning of founding principles, especially in debates over equality, justice, and America’s role in the world. It’s a compelling...

Year(s) Discussed: 1813-1817 Most of what you think you know about early 19th-century American expansion is incomplete. A renegade naval captain, a privateer turned rogue, and a series of clandestine operations reshaped the Western Hemisphere’s borders — and the U.S. presidency’s approach to sovereignty, power, and diplomacy. This episode explores the complex history of early American foreign poli...

Year(s) Discussed: 1773-1841 In this episode, Callie Perrone shares how a playful idea about William Henry Harrison grew into a full musical that blends comedy, research, and political insight. The conversation explores the research, creativity, and persistence behind Callie's creative efforts as well as how public figures are shaped by image as much as ideology and why civic engagement depends on...

Year(s) Discussed: 1817 At the start of his presidency, James Monroe embarked on a nearly 3,000-mile journey which transformed from a planned strategic military inspection of national defenses to a powerful mission of national conciliation. During the course of his travels, he used his Revolutionary War experience to bridge partisan divides in an aim to define a new era of American political histo...

Year(s) Discussed: 1924-2018 Uncover the profound leadership qualities of George H. W. Bush that still resonate today—trust, humility, and an unwavering respect for institutions. My discussion with historian Laurence Jurdem about his new biography of Bush dives deep into the life and legacy of a man often underrated in our modern political landscape, revealing how his personal diplomacy and commit...

Year(s) Discussed: 1817 - 2025 This episode examines the complex leadership dynamics of the Monroe family as Elizabeth Monroe and her daughter Eliza Monroe Hay navigated the high expectations of U.S. First Ladies in the wake of Dolley Madison's time as hostess of the President's Mansion. Joined by my special guest, Ann Foster of the Vulgar History podcast, we explore the contrasting roles and repu...

Year(s) Discussed: 1768-1817 Join me and my special guest, Ann Foster of the Vulgar History podcast, as we dive into the life of Elizabeth Kortright Monroe, a woman whose leadership was defined by elegance, resilience, and strategic diplomacy during a formative era of American political history. As we explore the evolution of U.S. First Ladies, you will see how Elizabeth and her daughters, Eliza a...

Dive into the second act of Samuel L. Southard’s career as he navigated the fractious politics of the Adams administration and a high-stakes personal vendetta with Andrew Jackson. This episode highlights his leadership in pushing for ambitious naval innovations and his pivotal role in American political history, eventually serving as President pro tempore and standing next in line for the presiden...

Tenure of Office: September 16, 1823 - March 4, 1829 Rising from his beginnings as a young New Jersey jurist to become Secretary of the Navy under James Monroe, Samuel L. Southard emerged as a "diligent and durable" figure in American political history. With my special guests, Rob and Jamie of Totalus Rankium, we explore how Southard utilized family connections to end up involved in high-stakes po...

Year(s) Discussed: 1960-1975 In a landscape where Confederate flags, Lincoln quotes, and Civil War symbols are woven into modern politics, how did history become a tool for political identity and culture wars? Historian Tim Galsworthy uncovers for us the surprising ways Civil War memory has shaped the Republican Party and American politics from 1960 through the first half of the 1970s - from Eisen...

Tenure of Office: December 28, 1832 - March 4, 1833 How did a man praised for his "patience, industry and excellent judgment" find himself at the center of a national power struggle? Known for being at his desk by dawn, Hugh Lawson White built a reputation in his career of public service and business leadership which positioned him to take up the role of President pro tem when the Senate rostrum w...

Year(s) Discussed: 1816-1817 Explore the dawn of the Monroe administration, a pivotal moment in American political history often branded as the "Era of Good Feelings" though the reality on the ground was far more fractious. This episode examines the leadership of the incoming president, James Monroe, as he attempted to act as a head of the nation rather than a faction in an era defined by underlyi...

Year(s) Discussed: 1838-1905 Uncover the hidden depths of Abraham Lincoln's speechwriter, John Hay, and how his poetic touch shaped American history in this captivating episode featuring Jan Cigliano Hartman, author of Lincoln's Speechwriter: John Hay and the Friendship That Inspired American Eloquence. This episode reveals why Hay’s ability to translate Lincoln’s vision into poetic, relatable lan...

Year(s) Discussed: 1789-current Most of us are unaware that the fight over healthcare in America is a century-long battle filled with surprising twists, political cycles, and personal stories that have shaped policy — and presidents — throughout history. In my discussion with David Blumenthal and Jim Morone about their new book, Whiplash: From the Battle for Obamacare to the War on Science, they r...

Year(s) Discussed: 1787-1819 This episode tracks James Monroe’s "fits and starts" through early American political history, from his courageous dissent at the Virginia Ratification Convention to his pivotal role as a leadership figure in the burgeoning Democratic-Republican faction. We delve into the immense personal and financial costs of his public service, including his challenging diplomatic m...

Year(s) Discussed: 1731-1821 Join me and my special guest, Richard Vague, as we delve into the life of Thomas Willing, a pivotal yet often overlooked leader in America's financial revolution. Discover how his strategic foresight and adaptability in leadership helped shape the nation's early economic landscape, navigating complex political tides and forging influential relationships. This episode d...

Tenure of Office: January 1, 1819 - August 31, 1823 Explore the life of Smith Thompson, a transitional figure in American political history who served as Secretary of the Navy under U.S. President James Monroe before ascending to the Supreme Court. This episode analyzes his leadership style, contrasting his role as a trusted lieutenant focused on political patronage with his independence as a juri...

Year(s) Discussed: 1866-2026 Delve into the art of crisis management with insights from an expert PR consultant and journalist, Edward Segal. This episode uncovers the leadership strategies of US presidents, including insights on the importance of communication and information gathering for successful crisis managers like Franklin D Roosevelt and John F Kennedy. Our conversation also reveals how h...

Year(s) Discussed: 1758-1787 What does it take to rise from being a 16-year-old orphan to a central figure in the American founding? This episode explores the early leadership journey of James Monroe, a man driven by a profound aversion to "insignificance". We trace Monroe’s evolution from a courageous young lieutenant who nearly bled to death at the Battle of Trenton to a strategic thinker under...