Killer Heart To Hearts

A burglary at a grieving widow’s home seems straightforward — until one of the suspects tells police something they were never expecting to hear. What follows forces investigators to take a second look at a death everyone thought had already been explained. 🖤🥤🖤 SOURCE MATERIAL   https://www.cbsnews.com/news/harold-allen-marsha-buxton-ashley-jones-indiana-man-poisoned-root-beer-float-48-hours/ h...

A drug-fueled night in rural Georgia ends with two deaths, one survivor, and a murder case built around a hot tub, conflicting forensic evidence, and a story nobody can explain. 🖤🛁🖤 SOURCE MATERIAL: https://www.paramountplus.com/shows/video/Lw1FSN7zUv7jx_QPtdui1dDDXLK97HR8/ https://www.aecarterfuneralhome.com/obituary/Marianne-Shockley Blood Town https://obituaries.unionrecorder.com/obituary/cl...

In December 2000, Mike Williams disappeared during a duck-hunting trip on a remote Florida lake. His boat was found. His body wasn’t. What followed was a bizarre explanation, a mother unwilling to accept it, and a mystery that would remain buried for nearly two decades. 🖤🐊🖤 SOURCE MATERIAL:  https://www.cbsnews.com/video/cold-blooded-killer-august-2024/ https://nbcuniversalnewsgroup.com/nbcnews...

Grant Amato had a career, a family, and a future. Then he found a Bulgarian camgirl online. What began as paid attention became an obsession — one that cost more than $200,000, destroyed his relationship with his family, and ended with three people dead inside a Florida home. This is the story of loneliness, fantasy, and one man’s catastrophic refusal to understand the difference between being lov...

Chicago, Illinois. 1893. A grand hotel opens its doors on Michigan Avenue, just in time for the World’s Fair. For more than a century, millions of guests would pass through its halls. Some… apparently never left. 🖤🏨🖤 SOURCE MATERIAL: https://www.congressplazahotel.com/history https://www.architecture.org/online-resources/buildings-of-chicago/congress-hotel https://www.historians.org/perspective...

Circleville, Ohio. 1976. An anonymous letter arrives in the mail. Then another. Before long, an entire town is looking over its shoulder, wondering who knows their secrets… …and who might be next. Source Material: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/circleville-letters-author-unmask/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TEDYK5veqwg https://unsolved.com/gallery/poison-pen-murder/ https://www.victimsofthestate....

A birthday hike above Oahu left Arielle Konig badly injured and her husband, Dr. Gerhardt Konig, at the center of a case that would turn on what happened near the edge. Source Material: https://apnews.com/article/ced28e5b8885512579e6aa223e8ccc94 https://www.courttv.com/news/hi-v-gerhardt-konig-trouble-in-paradise-trial/ https://www.courttv.com/news/i-was-almost-pushed-over-the-edge-gerhardt-konig-...

In 2007, four people vanished from a remote town in Western Australia. A man. A woman. Her five-year-old daughter. And one friend who followed them. They left behind a note saying they had gone to Brazil. Nearly twenty years later, no one has found them. Source Material: https://www.coronerscourt.wa.gov.au/_files/McDougall%2C%20C%20J%20and%20L%3B%20Popic%2C%20A%20K%3B%20Felton%2C%20G%20finding.pdf...

They’d spent the evening drinking, laughing, and according to Sarah Boone, acting like children. A game of hide-and-seek. At least, that’s what she told detectives. But when 42-year-old Jorge Torres Jr. was found dead inside a suitcase in a Winter Park, Florida apartment, investigators would discover that the most important witness had already recorded what happened. And the videos she captured wo...

In 1933, Michael Malloy was a regular at a Bronx speakeasy when a group of men decided he was worth more dead than alive. But Malloy kept surviving. The newspapers would call him Iron Mike. The man who wouldn’t die. The truth was uglier. Source Material: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/1933/09/23/molloy-the-mighty https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/the-man-who-wouldnt-die-89417903/ https://...

Jesse James Hollywood wanted to be feared. In the San Fernando Valley drug scene, fear came cheap — a little money, a little swagger, a few friends willing to do what they were told. Then a debt got personal. And fifteen-year-old Nick Markowitz was pulled into a world where everyone wanted to act dangerous, but no one wanted to be responsible. Source Material: Los Angeles Times — “The Last Days of...

Portbou, Spain. 1990. A young woman is found hanging from a pine tree above the sea. No passport. No money. No name. Just a pair of black sandals placed neatly nearby — and a death investigators were quick to call suicide. For thirty-two years, she was known only as the girl in the tree. Then, finally, she got her name back. Source Material: https://www.theguardian.com/news/2025/apr/15/mystery-gir...

New Orleans, 2005. Hurricane Katrina is moving toward the city, and two French Quarter bartenders decide to stay. Zack Bowen and Addie Hall ride out the storm together, falling in love inside an emptied-out Quarter where the lights are off, the rules are loose, and survival starts to feel like freedom. But when the power comes back on, reality returns.  One year later, Zack jumps from the roof of...

In March 2000, twenty-three-year-old Leah Roberts packed her white Jeep Cherokee and drove west. No warning. No clear destination. Nine days later, her Jeep was found wrecked in the woods near Mount Baker, Washington. Her belongings were still inside. Leah was gone. And the crash scene left behind more questions than answers. Source Material: https://www.whatcomcounty.us/292/Missing-Leah-Roberts h...

Virginia. 2015. A routine morning live shot by the lake. Reporter Alison Parker and photojournalist Adam Ward were covering a local tourism segment when a former colleague unexpectedly stepped into frame. And what happened next would turn an ordinary local news segment into one of the most horrifying moments ever captured on live television. Source Material: https://abcnews.go.com/US/shooting-alle...

Baltimore. 2006. Rey Rivera leaves home after a sudden phone call. He never comes back. What happened next would leave behind more questions than answers — and a case that still feels suspended between explanation and impossibility. Source Material: https://unsolved.com/gallery/mystery-on-the-rooftop/ https://vault.fbi.gov/rey-rivera https://therealnews.com/his-mysterious-death-made-national-headl...

He was the frontman of a band people loved. Famous. Charismatic. Familiar. But behind the image was something far more disturbing — a pattern of manipulation, abuse, and unchecked access that would eventually expose one of the most horrifying cases in modern music history. This is the story of Ian Watkins. A predator hidden in plain sight. And the warning signs too many people failed to stop. Sour...

Bergen, Norway. 1970. The burned body of an unidentified woman is found in a remote valley known as Isdalen — “Ice Valley.” She has no name. No clear past. And no shortage of questions. Suitcases packed with wigs, coded notes, and false identities only deepen the mystery, as investigators begin to realize this was no ordinary death. More than fifty years later, she is still known only as… the Isda...

Western Massachusetts. 1994. Twelve-year-old Becky Savarese gets away. And in doing so, exposes a quiet predator with a kidnapping kit, a secret plan, and ties to horrors that had already begun. Because once Lewis Lent started talking… the story only got worse. Source Material: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/serial-killer-lewis-lent-timeline/  https://www.cbsnews.com/news/becky-saverese-attempted-ab...

Auckland, New Zealand. 2006. Seventeen-year-old Liam Ashley is placed in the back of a prison transport van for what should have been a routine ride. He never makes it out alive. What happened inside that moving cage would horrify a country — and expose a system that failed to protect the very person in its custody. Source Material: https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/liam-revelled-in-the-pirates-life/O...

Lake Tahoe. 2021. A wealthy family is torn apart after a late-night shooting inside their home. At the center of it all: former MLB pitcher Dan Serafini. Source Material: https://people.com/daniel-serafini-ex-mlb-player-murder-lake-tahoe-exclusive-11784990 https://people.com/daniel-serafini-murder-mistress-samantha-scott-11787493 https://www.kcra.com/article/dan-serafini-murder-trial-tahoe-may-27/...

Bellefonte, Pennsylvania. April 2005. Ray Gricar has spent years building cases, following evidence, and knowing exactly where to look when something doesn’t add up. Then one day, he vanishes. And the deeper people look, the stranger it gets. Source Material: https://www.lockhaven.com/news/local-news/2020/04/the-hunt-for-ray-gricar-15-years-of-clues-theories-and-the-search-for-answers/  https://ww...

Anchorage, Alaska. Summer 2016. Over five days, three men are attacked in their homes by the same stranger — a man with a black leather jacket, a claw hammer, and a terrifying sense of purpose. What looks, at first, like a violent spree… is something far more complicated. 🖤🔨🖤 Source Material: https://apnews.com/general-news-4eb303a6227b4ce38707ab1d16d9529f  https://www.alaskasnewssource.com/con...

Salado, Texas. July 1997. Lela and Raymond Howard leave home for a local music festival just 15 miles away. They never arrive. Days pass. Then weeks. And the farther the search stretches, the harder it becomes to explain how two people can disappear so completely… without ever meaning to. This is THE WAY . https://nij.ojp.gov/taxonomy/term/decomposition    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC...

An heiress from Duluth. A trail of fires stretching from Minnesota to the Mexican border. And a quiet little mining town in Arizona… that never saw her coming. Marjorie Congdon Caldwell Hagen carried wealth, suspicion, and misery wherever she went. Her tale is part true crime… and part ghost story that still haunts this desert town. For this special episode, we’re going local, and recording live f...