Hold On, Let Me Tell It

It's that time of the year, folks! We hope you enjoy our annual offering of creepy, strange and weird tales, as well as a little surprise at the end, because what would a Hold On, Let Me Tell It Creepshow be without some Jeopardy?! We will be back next month with another show, but until then, stay safe and be the great human beings that I know our listeners are. Cheers!

Hey gang! We are back! Adam, Sarah & I decided to sit down and fire this thing back up and I'm so glad we did. We had a blast recording this one. Topics included a Tampa Bay legend, The Dark Web, animals in freezers and a ton more. We wrapped it up with a quick round of Filthy Trivia, because why not? We will be back before the end of the month with the annual Creepshow Spooktacular, so stay s...

The treacherous trio are back to spread some holiday cheer for you wonderful listeners! This week on the show we spent a good chunk of our time talking about the Max documentary “Class Action Park”. This place was like Shangri La if you were an 80’s kid who wanted to rage. If you haven’t seen it, you should definitely check it out. Other topics include bumper stickers, a strange trip back from Osh...

This week on the show we got together the week before Turkey Day to chat about all sorts of stuff including the Telemarketers documentary on HBO, bar trivia, the Grillbot and much more. We hope you all had a tremendous Thanksgiving, and we will check in with you all in December. Cheers!

Welcome to part II of the 2023 Creepshow! We spent a few minutes chatting about last week's topics including the papermill documentary that Adam referenced. From there we get into this weeks tales that include an industrial revolution steel mill that may be haunted by one of its most notorious foremen, the strange numbers stations that started popping up shortly after the cold war of which man...

We're back, witches! This week we we're more than happy to reconvene in the studio after a several month hiatus to bring you what has become the favorite shows of the year for both the listeners as well as Adam, Sarah & I: Creepshow! We took a few minutes in the beginning to just chop it up, but the meat of the show is focused on some chilling stories. A man winds up dead in a vat of p...

This week on the show we open things up with Adam telling us that he got hit by a tow truck. From there we briefly run down a trip to see some wrestling in Oshkosh. The Scat with Mat makes a triumphant return as we read a couple reviews off Amazon for a colon cleanse. After that, it's another modified round of the Hit List as Adam and Sarah face off to see who will be the new #1 contender for the...

On the show this week we had a couple guests! Both have been on the show a time or two, but it was great to welcome TJ and Roman back to the table. We didn't really have an agenda, which turned out to be a great idea as the laughs were plentiful. In the second half, Sarah hosted a lightning round of filthy trivia just for funzies. Enjoy!

This week on the show we check in with Sarah after a trip to see the Packers at Lambeau Field. She gives us a run down of what the tailgate looked like, as well as a stop on the way up at a bar where she walked away with a unique prize! From there, since we recorded on the biggest drinking day of the year, Sarah and Adam went head-to-head in a round of Drunk Ass Trivia. Enjoy!

This week on the show we have a special guest at the table. Mat & Sarah’s nephew, Chase! He’s been on before, so we get caught up with him before transitioning to the final chapter in the 2022 Creepshow series. Sort of. More on that in a bit. Adam & Sarah both bring stories to the table and the grand finale was to be another installment of Creepshow Jeopardy, but something went wrong. Afte...

This week on the show we sat down a bit later than normal after our weekly night of Bag League at DTS (thanks to them for sponsoring the show, as always) to just chat about the prior week. Adam and Sarah talk about shows and restaurants and Mat chats about free gas, biker whips and the first Music at the Marv of the season. In the second half, it’s a round of Filthy Trivia #Iwishididntknow. Enjoy!

This week on the show we are once again graced by the presence of Adam's uncle Jon! We spend the first half just chatting about whatever pops into our heads. Mat has a beef with the way the game ended last week (shocking, right?!). After that, we get some more stories from Jon about his days in the fire department before playing some trivia. Who will take home the Ramblin' Rabbi? Listen to find ou...

This week on the show we have a very special guest: Adam’s uncle, Jon Tollefson! Jon has been one of our biggest supporters since we started this thing over three years ago. He is a recent retiree of the JFD, so you know he has stories for days! After just shooting the bull for a few we play 1 true 3, followed by choosing what stories we wanted to hear Jon tell (seriously, he brought in a menu of...

This week on the show Adam and Sarah break down their New Years Eve festivities, Mat gloats about a record setting 4thchampionship in the Tecmo Fantasy Bowl, and in the second half we have Sarah’s Scoops and play some Smartass. Have a great 2022 everyone, we definitely will!

This week on the show we have a very special guest on the show that we haven’t had on in almost a full year. Lisa Conry sits at the table with us! We spend the first half just getting caught up to speed on what we’ve been up to in the last week, and Mat lays out an update for the Tecmo Fantasy Bowl. Then in the second half, Lisa quizzes us on some Holiday trivia. Things get very funny when one ans...

This week on the show, Mat recaps the past weekend which included a terrible Packers game and an even worse food situation. Sarah reveals that we are recording on her 20th wedding anniversary, and we learn that Irene isn't the only crazy cat lady in Dongsville. Then in the second half of the show, Sarah hosts a round of "Who Wants To Be A Millionaire?" that pits the boys against one another. It's...

This weeks show gets kicked off with some pro wrestling talk, brought on by Sarah watching some episodes of the critically acclaimed "Dark Side of the Ring". If you have never seen the show, whether you are a fan of the sport or not, you should definitely check it out. From there, the chatter moves in all kinds of different directions, including the return of summer bag leagues and more. Thanks fo...

This week on the show we once again welcome in Adam's folks, Jody & Kristy Tollefson! We start things off talking about Adam's first visit to Miller Park... Errrr... AmFam Field in over a year, and Sarah has a story about how frustrating it was to purchase a patio set over the weekend. Then, what we are all here for, it's the rubber match for the grand championship of Who Wants To Be A Podcast...

This is it! The last show of what will no doubt go down as one of the strangest years of our lives. This episode too felt a bit strange. Sarah joins us via satellite from an undisclosed location in Vero Beach, Fl where she just managed to escape one of the worst snowfall's to hit Wisco in the past couple years to discuss the Holiday season so far. Everyone just kind of did their own thing across t...

Holy smokes, we did it! 100 episodes. How do you celebrate such a feat? You invite a special guest onto the show. Mat and Sarah's sister Lisa Conry joins the fun as we take part in a trifecta of trivia games. Each host brings a game to the table, including Desperado, Jeopardy, and one that covers the first 99 shows.           Week in and week out m...

This week on the show we start with a Robert report from Adam, and apparently this doll photo is wreaking havoc on Sarah as well... allegedly. Curse or coincidence? Either way it has become good fodder for the show! We then go old school and read a couple Hyperthetical questions, a large wall decal is reviewed during the "Scat With Mat" segment, and much more! Thank you to our sponsors for the epi...

This week we start a month long series of creepy, strange and out of this world tales! Hope you like it. The show kicks off with some audio that was recorded out in the field on a notoriously haunted road about 20 minutes from the studio. From there, we get caught up on what everyone has been up to since we last recorded before jumping into the meat of the show: Hold On, Let Me Tell It Presents: C...

On the show this week, we open with some talk about Adams recent birthday weekend (not much to do in a Covid-19 world). We then spend the bulk of the show discussing the Netflix reboot of Unsolved Mysteries. We decided to break it up into a two part series. This week we delve into episodes 1-3. After that, we have a listener submitted Scat w/Mat product review, and finish up with some news. Thanks...

On the show this week we start by discussing the elephant in the room, the Corona Virus. How it’s impacted our daily lives, as well as our upcoming vacation plans. Sarah talks about an absolute classic wrestling match between Randy Savage and The Ultimate Warrior, before getting into the news. Thank you all for your continued support. Please do us a favor and share with a friend! Also, our two spo...

Hey, Gang! On the show this week we talk about the Covid-19 Corona virus canceling everything in it’s path. (not WrestleMania so far) We also talk beer gimmicks, bar hopping, The Office trivia, a series of unfortunate events that lead to Hanoi Rocks drummer Razzles death, Aunt Kelly’s oven fireball and much more. Plus Sarah talks about a 1988 WWF scandal and gives us the news in Sarah’s Scoop. Enj...