Scholarly Peers - Journal Peer Review in Academia

In this episode of the Scholarly Peers podcast, host Sin-Wang engages with Susan Samardjian, who shares her experiences and insights on academic travel. They discuss the essential items Susan brings on her trips, including a physical notebook, a book related to her research, an iPad for convenience, and snacks for stress relief. The conversation dives into the importance of reading for relaxation,...

In this episode , host Sin-Wang Chong introduces a new series titled 'Researchers in a Bag,' focusing on the personal aspects of researchers' lives beyond their academic work. Joined by guest Jenny Taylorson, they discuss the significance of personal items that researchers carry during academic trips, the balance between work and life, the importance of staying connected with friends, and the ongo...

In this episode, Sin-Wang discusses the support systems for early career researchers (ECRs) from the perspective of a journal editor. He reflects on the mentorship scheme implemented in his journal, Review of Education, which aims to provide ECRs with hands-on experience in the peer review process. The conversation explores the challenges faced by ECRs, the importance of empowerment in support sys...

In this episode of Scholarly Peers, host Sin-Wang engages with doctoral student Thomas Stringer from the University of St. Andrews. They discuss Thomas's multifaceted identity as a language lecturer and researcher, his doctoral journey, and the motivations behind his publications. The conversation delves into the peer review process, the challenges of academic writing, and Thomas's new role as a c...

In this episode, Sin-Wang and Virginia Parker (University of St Andrews) discuss Virginia's experience as a peer reviewer for an international journal. They explore the challenges and benefits of peer review, the importance of being dialogic and relational in feedback, and the role of artificial intelligence in academic writing. Virginia shares her insights on the need for transparency and ethical...

In this episode, host Sin-Wang interviews Professor David Carless from the University of Hong Kong about his experience in journal peer review. They discuss unforgettable peer review experiences, challenges in navigating the peer review process, and advice for early career researchers. Professor Carless emphasises the importance of starting with realistic journal selection, getting critical peer r...

Dr. Talia Isaacs shares her experiences in journal peer review as an author, reviewer, and editor. She discusses both positive and challenging experiences, including finding a home for mixed methods research and dealing with disciplinary silos. Talia also provides insights on responding to reviewer feedback on methods and defending decisions. She highlights the importance of transparency in acknow...

In this episode, Professor Hayo Reinders, editor of the journal Innovation in Language Learning and Teaching, shares his experiences as an author, peer reviewer, and journal editor. He discusses unforgettable peer review experiences, including receiving a scathing review and discovering that his own work had been plagiarised. He also talks about the process of founding a journal and the importance...

In this episode, Dr. Caroline Tagg, a senior lecturer and journal editor, shares her experiences as an author, peer reviewer, and editor. She discusses her unforgettable peer review experience as an author, the importance of feedback, and the challenges faced by journal editors. Caroline also provides advice for early career researchers and PhD students on navigating the peer review process.    

In this episode, Professor Masatoshi Sato shares his experiences as an author, peer reviewer, and journal editor. He discusses both negative and positive experiences in the peer review process, including long wait times and constructive feedback. He emphasises the importance of training PhD students in peer review and suggests incorporating peer review into PhD programs. He also provides advice fo...