The Pretty Paranoid Podcast

This week, Andi and Cassie dive into some of Reddit's creepiest stories and try their best to spook each other along the way. From terrifying encounters with mimics and eerie skinwalker sightings to a story about a wife peeking around corners. Are these just internet horror stories, or could there be something darker lurking behind them? Turn down the lights, lock the doors, and join us as we...

In this week's episode of The Pretty Paranoid, Andi dives into the mysterious disappearance of the Sodder children, a case that began with a Christmas Eve house fire in 1945 and left a family searching for answers for decades. Then, Cassie explores the eerie legend of the Devil's Footprints, a trail of unexplained hoof-like prints that appeared overnight across the English countryside in 1...

This week, Andi covers the Fall River Cult Murders, a case filled with allegations of Satanic ritual abuse, manipulation, and murder. Cassie dives into the mystery of the Finders, a secretive group that became the center of one of the strangest and most controversial investigations of the 1980s. What was fact? What was fear? And what might still be hidden?

This episode, we kick things off by sharing a bit about who we are and why we’re diving into the strange. Andi dives into the eerie mystery of “The Hum,” that bizarre worldwide phenomenon. Meanwhile, Cassie unpacks the Hat Man, sleep paralysis, and all the conspiracies lurking in the shadows. Buckle up! This is just the start!