Saints Or Sinners - St Kilda FC Fans Podcast

A dominant performance from St Kilda with a 101-point win over West Coast. We cover the key takeaways: Hugo Garcia’s impact, Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera returning to his best form, the effectiveness (or ineffectiveness?) of the ruck combination, and why Callum Wilkie is the competition’s best defender! All the action plus trivia, fan calls, and more, on this weeks episode of SAINTS OR SINNERS!

A one-point loss to the Crows… but is there more to this story? A game that slipped away, yet showed genuine signs of progress. Ross Lyon believes the Saints are trending in the right direction at 2-4… but are we buying it? We dive into: The key moments that cost us the game The elite patches of footy that show what this team can be Who stood up when it mattered (and who didn’t) Whether this “impr...

A much-needed win over Port Adelaide — but are the Saints actually building something? 👀 We break down the performance, make the big call on Cal Wilkie as the best defender in the comp (and AA captain talk), and dive into JSOS’ impact down back! Plus, strong signs from the young core with Mattaes Phillipou & Hugo Garcia, and Nas showing his best again. Full game breakdown + a retro trivia tri...

After the loss to Brisbane, we break down what’s really going wrong — and why we think Choco Williams could be the missing piece at St Kilda. Coach Proc doesn’t hold back, calling on Nasiah to lift, and we dive into the key moments from the Lions clash. Plus trivia, fan questions, and plenty more. 🎙️ Saints or Sinners — the honest St Kilda podcast.

The Saints get the job done against GWS… but it wasn’t exactly comfortable in those dying moments 😅 A strong first half had us in control, playing some of our best footy — but things tightened up late and we were forced to hang on. Was it a sign of growth… or did we get away with one? We break down everything from the game — what worked, what didn’t, and what it actually means for us going forwar...

After a frustrating 0-2 start to the season, emotions are running high on this week’s episode of Saints or Sinners . Chef Joz lets loose with a passionate rant about the Saints’ skill errors and missed opportunities , while Coach Proc tries to keep things grounded, reminding us it’s still early in the season. We break down the loss to Melbourne, look at what’s going wrong on the field, and discuss...

The Saints are 0–1 and the Saints or Sinners therapy session is officially open. We break down the Round 0 loss to Collingwood, where things went wrong, and whether there were actually any positives to take from the game. We also look ahead to next week and discuss potential line-up changes Ross Lyon might make , plus we open the lines for fan call / SOS fan mail to hear what Saints supporters rea...

We break down the Saints’ preseason clash with the Bombers and the emerging Nas + Flying Ryan connection 👀 Chez Joz reviews Trac’s cooking methods... Gee from Red White Black Chat enters the hot seat, and fan mail is BACK. Plus - Round 0 vs Collingwood. We’re tipping a win.... oh my.

St Kilda beat Gold Coast in an unofficial pre-season hitout… and Saints fans are already planning the parade. Tonight we unpack the overreactions, put Z in the hot seat with some Would You Rather questions, fire up a Saints “Who Am I?” trivia segment, and Chef Joz breaks down Ross Lyon’s chat with Damian Barrett. Plus, we couldn’t resist a cheeky dig at Christian Petracca’s cookbook. Pre-season wi...

Season 2 of Saints or Sinners kicks off and the full panel is back - and we’re back with a MASSIVE call… could Nas be on track to become the greatest player in St Kilda history? This episode introduces new segments including Fan Call Mel in the Hot Seat, while bringing back fan favourites like trivia and the Chef's Knife ! We recap the Origin game early, break down what the Saints need to do t...

We’re back for a relaxed December episode as the Saints or Sinners crew checks in, catches up on life post-season, and breaks down everything that happened during St Kilda’s off-season. We chat through the trade period , the backstory behind the Leek Aleer situation , and how the conversation around it unfolded. We look at Liam Ryan’s marketing moves , the direction of our VFL team , and what all...

From new signings to captaincy changes, this trade week episode has it all! We discuss every Saints move, the Marshall-to-Geelong rumours, Steele stepping down as Captain, the arrival of Sam Flanders and what a 2026 premiership plan looks like. Oh, and of course there’s trivia — trade week style.

Join us for our annual Grand Final preview as we dive into the Geelong vs Brisbane matchup and share our predictions. Of course, it wouldn’t be complete without a few Saints references along the way. Coach Proc breaks down the Liam Ryan trade, and we record our first-ever live show from Queen of Margherita in Bentleigh. It’s a little chaotic, but that’s exactly the vibe we love.

We break down St Kilda’s rollercoaster season with our highs, lows, and Sainter of the Year ! Plus, we dive into the big trade talk—Leek Aleer, Flying Liam Ryan, Sam Flanders, Cam Mackenzie and more potential signings on the radar. Don’t miss our unfiltered take on where the Saints must go next!

Crawf gives us glowing feedback after last weeks pod, Darcy Wilson lights up with five goals, and we break down the Saints’ season — the highs, the lows, and who needs to step up next year. Trenna wraps things up with his fantasy finish, plus we chat through the last game of the season (but not our last episode). Don’t miss this one!

Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera has signed with the Saints — and we cannot believe it! In this special episode of Saints or Sinners , we celebrate the huge news by calling our loyal supporters to hear exactly what this moment means to them. From passion to relief to pure excitement, this is one for the Saints faithful!

Is Nasiah staying or leaving the Saints? We break down every hint from his telling interview with Richo, what the Saints could realistically get if he goes, and whether he’s playing hardball or just holding his cards close. We also dive deep into the Saints’ clash with the Bombers, all the highs and lows, plus your latest fantasy footy updates and plenty more Saints banter you won’t want to miss.

We scrape past Richmond in a scrappy win, but there’s plenty to unpack — from Fact or Fiction trivia chaos to the latest on Nas’ contract, Windhager’s standout in Saint or Sinner of the Round, and Carl Dilena’s cryptic “75% confident” comment. Lets break it down!

Our good mate Crawf doesn’t hold back—he cheekily calls us out for not giving NAS enough love in the last episode - listen to his fun voicemail! So this week, we dive into Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera’s contract situation, what he means to the team, and why he’s one of the most exciting young Saints on the list. Plus, Coach Proc shares a wild moment bumping into his former player Max Hall, and we break...

We were there. We saw it. And we still can’t believe it. This week, we break down the Saints' record-breaking comeback — possibly the greatest game in Saints AFL history!?!? Proc tells us who we should be targeting from Box Hill, we recap today’s match against the Dees, hand out our best player of the round, and relive Nasiah’s unreal mark of the year and goal after the siren. One of the most unfo...

After a loss to Geelong, we break down what went wrong — and what went very right with Nasiah in the midfield. Is he really top 2 in the comp right now? We weigh in. We also talk about the potential arrival of Leek Aleer, who earns Saint or Sinner of the Round, and test our knowledge with some classic Saints captain trivia.

The future could be looking bright for the Saints! In this episode, we dive into the arrival of Max "The Moose" Heath and what his impact could mean for the club. The kids stepped up and played some brilliant footy, and we break down all the promising signs for the weeks ahead. Plus, a big discussion around Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera, his contract situation, and the rumours swirling about his future....

How do you win nearly every stat and still lose? Welcome to a classic Saints heartbreak. We break down the game against the Hawks—where the numbers looked golden, but the skills let us down big time. From missed goals to costly turnovers, nothing was falling our way… except for Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera, who keeps delivering. Coach Proc brings the heat with some behind-the-scenes knowledge on what t...

This week, we break down our game against the Dockers and praise two young guns: Alix Tauru, who looks destined for something special, and Max Hall, who delivers yet again. We also chat about the future of Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera — will he re-sign with the Saints? All that and plenty more in a milestone episode 20 of the pod.

On this week’s episode, we dissect our showdown with the Pies, hear Joz unleash a scathing rant on the Saints, and question Liam Henry’s whereabouts. We also react to another injury setback for Phillipou and share a cheeky jab at the player welfare coach. Stick around for our “Saint or Sinner of the Round” verdict—this one’s not to be missed!