Tragedy - A True Crime Podcast

In this second installment of our ongoing investigation into the disappearance of Cody Haney, we sit down with his mother, Michele McRoy, for a deeply personal and emotional conversation. Michele shares her memories of Cody, the details she understands about the case, and the painful impact his absence has had over the past year. Her perspective brings new depth to Cody’s story and highlights the...

This special bonus installment begins with brief updates on the Ian Rogers and Michael John Olson cases, but its heart lies in a deeper dive into the disappearance of Jonathan Hagans. For the first time, we lay out our full assessment of what likely unfolded that night, what aligns, what contradicts, and what has been overlooked for more than 50 years. Through environmental analysis, witness recol...

Cody Haney’s story is striking not only for the unanswered questions, but for the overwhelming silence surrounding it. In this case summary, we dig into the scarce details we’ve uncovered, the near-total lack of media reporting, and the challenges of investigating a case with so little public record. We also focus on Cody himself, his personality, his life, and the human being behind the headline...

Today, we bring you critical new developments in two deeply troubling cases. We walk through the latest updates in the Ian Rogers case, including the discovery of his missing truck and the circumstances surrounding where and how it was found. We also break down newly obtained FOIA records from the Jacksonville Beach Police Department related to the case of Jonathan Hagans, documents that shed new...

In this special episode, we pull back the curtain on four cases that continue to shape our investigative work: Jody Kilgore, Ian Rogers, Michael John Olson, and Jonathan Hagans. We walk listeners through the newest updates, the leads we’ve followed, and the behind-the-scenes research that rarely makes it into the final episodes. This is a raw, transparent look at what’s moved forward, what’s stall...

When Jonathan Hagans vanished, the world kept moving, but for Susan Dempsey and Joe Hagans, time stood still. Now, five decades later, they open up about what they remember from that night, how it changed their family, and the quiet strength it takes to live without answers. A tender, human look at grief that never quite lets go.  As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in...

Author and teacher Randy Hubbard joins us to talk about his book The Laney Gwinner Effect, a deep look into a tragic case that continues to resonate decades later. But Hubbard didn’t stop at writing; he turned the lessons of the case into a hands-on classroom experience, guiding students through the complexities of investigative thinking. We unpack how his unique course bridges true crime, educati...

James Hicks’ story is one of deception, control, and calculated violence. Convicted of murdering two women and suspected in more disappearances, Hicks’ chilling crimes span decades, leaving a trail of unanswered questions. In this deep-dive podcast, we uncover the twisted life of a man who manipulated those closest to him, examine the investigations that brought him down, and hear from the people...

In this episode, Jack Fox from Never a Truer Word joins us to examine how perspective (the speaker’s viewpoint, context, and intent) can alter the way we interpret statements revealed in the most recent FOIA release related to the Michael John Olson case. Together, we break down how phrasing, timing, stress, and memory can subtly shift meaning, and why even small linguistic choices, like active ve...

In this episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast , Michael and Alyssa review the disappearance of Jonathan Hagans, a case that continues to haunt both family and the community. We sit down with Joel Hagans, Jonathan’s brother, for an emotional and candid conversation about the day his brother went missing, the unanswered questions that remain, and the lasting impact on those left behind. We also b...

Decades after Michael John Olson vanished, the truth was thought to be buried with time, until now. Newly released documents from a Freedom of Information Act request reveal details that were never meant to see daylight. In this episode of Tragedy - A True Crime Podcast , we unpack what those files contain, question what investigators may have overlooked, and explore how these revelations could al...

In this episode, we sit down with Meaghan Good , founder of The Charley Project , a vital online resource dedicated to cataloging missing persons cases across the United States. Meaghan shares the mission behind the project, how it has grown into one of the most comprehensive archives of its kind, and the impact it has had on both families and investigators. We explore several cases that have been...

Jeni Decker, host of the podcast Down and Away, discusses her journey into podcasting, focusing on unsolved homicide and missing persons cases. She shares insights into the disappearance of Michael John Olson, highlighting the complexities and inconsistencies surrounding the case. The discussion covers the dynamics of the night Michael went missing, the role of law enforcement, and the emotional t...

This episode of the Tragedy Podcast delves into the mysterious disappearance of Michael John Olson, featuring insights from his family members. They recount the events leading up to his disappearance, the challenges faced during the search efforts, and the inconsistencies surrounding the last night he was seen. The family expresses their ongoing quest for answers and closure, highlighting the emot...

In this episode of Tragedy: A True Crime Podcast, hosts Alyssa and Michael investigate the haunting disappearance of Michael John Olson, who vanished from West Palm Beach, Florida, in December 1979. They are joined by Paige Nienaber, a driving force in keeping Michael’s story alive. Together, they trace Michael’s life and the events leading up to that fateful night, recount the exhaustive search e...

In this episode of the Tragedy, Alyssa and Michael delve into the complexities surrounding the cases of Jody Kilgore and Ian Rogers. They discuss the importance of community support, the challenges of evidence collection, and the role of listener questions in driving the conversation. The episode highlights the need for consistent communication from law enforcement and explores various investigati...

Today, we begin an exciting collaboration with Sunshine State Sonar to dive into one of their most compelling cold cases: the disappearance of Michael John Olson. In 1979, Olson vanished from West Palm Beach, Florida, and more than 40 years later, his case remains unsolved leaving behind lingering questions and areas still waiting to be investigated. Support the show Thank you for listening. Pleas...

In this episode, we sit down with Mike Helms, a former deputy with the Leon County Sheriff’s Office who served during the investigation and trial of Ted Bundy for the Florida State and Lake City murders. Helms was part of the security team assigned to guard Bundy throughout his court proceedings while he was in custody in Tallahassee. Support the show Thank you for listening. Please visit us at ww...

Welcome to our first roundtable discussion. In this episode, we sit down with five of our listeners to hear their perspectives, answer their questions, and explore some of the theories they’ve developed after following the case. Support the show Thank you for listening. Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

Today, we provide a quick update on the Ian Rogers case as well as focus our efforts on getting as much participation as possible for Jody Kilgore's birthday celebration. Listen to Cyndi, Jody's sister, talk about where the event is being held and what to expect when you arrive. Support the show Thank you for listening. Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

On today's very special podcast, we meet with Kathy Decker and Douglas MacGregor. They belong to an organization named IRIS that offers specialty investigative services to law enforcement. We get their take on what they do and how they could provide a new look at the Jody Kilgore case. - https://irisinvestigativestrategies.com/ Support the show Thank you for listening. Please visit us at www....

This is our last episode in the Ian Rogers series. Here we discuss our theories and final thoughts as well as meet with Teresa, Ian's mom one last time. Support the show Thank you for listening. Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecrimepodcast.com

We speak with Britain Lockhart, the owner of Depths of History. He walks us through the mission of his organization, the type of work he engages in and his role in the search for Ian Rogers.  Depths of History YouTube Channel - https://www.youtube.com/@depthsofhistory  As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law Support the show Thank you for listening. Please...

Meet Justin Hembrock. He is the owner of North Florida Diving Services. Justin shares with us his efforts so far on the Ian Rogers case, an overview of what his company can offer, and the need for more information to help bring Ian home. As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law Support the show Thank you for listening. Please visit us at www.tragedyatruecri...

We had the privilege to speak with Joe Webster, the owner of Spartan Exteriors and Dan Ellis, one of his best friends that also worked for Joe. They provide some interesting details about their relationship with Ian and about the day Ian disappeared.  As with all cases, all parties are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law Support the show Thank you for listening. Please visit us at www.t...