Magical Mystery Hour

Hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla discuss true crime cases. In this episode, Amanda breaks down the details of teenagers Emanuela Orlandi's mysterious disappearance from Vatican City in 1983, and discusses the series of investigations and conspiracies that have developed over the decades since. Inspired by the story, Paul performs a cover of Dan Franklin's "You Can't Ge...

Hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla discuss more real ghost stories submitted by Magical Mystery Hour podcast listeners. Guests Selnalyn Sajo, Dary Mills, Alika Spencer, and Jamie Carganilla share stories from their own experiences. Inspired by the final story, Amanda performs a cover of Vera Lynn's "We'll Meet Again", accompanied by her husband David Benjamin on the pian...

In this episode, hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla discuss real ghost stories. Amanda shares several stories from her family's history over the generations. Magical Mystery Hour podcast listeners Constance Chamberlain, Katie Gramajo, and Megan Fletcher share stories from their own experiences, as well. Inspired by the theme, Paul performs an acoustic guitar cover of "Ghost",...

In this episode of The Magical Mystery Hour, hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla discuss the sinking of the Titanic. From insurance scams to murder plots, Paul explores conspiracy theories surrounding what really happened to the iconic ill-fated ship and its passengers. Inspired by Paul's story presentation, Amanda performs an acoustic guitar cover of "Walk Like an Egyptian",...

In this premiere episode of The Magical Mystery Hour, hosts Amanda Benjamin and Paul Carganilla discuss the Dyatlov Pass Incident. Inspired by Amanda's story presentation, Paul performs an acoustic guitar cover of "Wake Me Up", by Avicii. Be sure to subscribe so you don't miss the second episode, which will feature Paul's conspiracy presentation, Amanda's performance...