Common Mystics

On this episode of Common Mystics Jen and Jill unravel the events surrounding a 1981 car bombing in an affluent Chicago suburb. The crime stumped investigators. The victim was a family man and a good neighbor. Who would want him killed? Years later, a landmark investigation into one Mafia-connected family would blow the lid off decades of murderous secrets and bring the Chicago Outfit to its knees...

Common Mystics has teamed up with Access Paranormal Podcast to bring you The Boo Review, a monthly segment featured on L35 Online Radio based in the UK. In this new segment, Jennifer and Jill share vintage American ghosts stories from the newspaper archives. Told in a faux-newsy style, these short, richly atmospheric clips will transport you back in time and delight you with "true" spooky tales. ...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jennifer and Jill tell about the second Great Chicago Fire. Many know about the epic blaze that decimated the Windy City in 1871. But much less is known about the conflagration that brought the city's Union Stockyards to a halt in 1910. The conditions at this meat processing operation, while making Chicago the "hog butcher for the world," set the stage for another...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jennifer and Jill discuss the horrendous murder of the Cosden family on a quiet Maryland farm in 1851.* Thirty-year-old William Cosden was modestly successful, making just enough to raise his small family by working the rented land. But when some local ne're-do-wells stormed the farmhouse on a cold February evening, they sought mounds of cash. The scene they left...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jen and Jill sit down with the incredible Nichole Bigley, creator and host of A Psychic Story, A Psychic Story: Kids' Edition, and Supernatural Matters podcasts. Nichole discusses her early memories of being born, describes doing past life regressions with her little sister and shares some spine-tingling stories from her youth. These days Nichole is channeling ang...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jennifer and Jill give voice to the spirit of a Methodist minister with a surprising connection to the murder of Mormon leader Joseph Smith. Reverend Solomon Sharp revitalized the Methodist Episcopal church in Smyrna, Delaware with his riveting sermons and miraculous acts. In fact, decades after his death in 1830, the Smyrna Times continued to publish astounding s...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jennifer and Jill discuss their late Aunt Genie, who supported them through some of the most difficult times of their childhood. Laugh along as they describe the time the furnace went out, the time they got pinworms, and the time Jill went to jail. Genie shared her mystical gifts and, during her life, was a constant source and support and love. Her love still shin...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jen and Jill examine the crimes of Patty Cannon and the circumstances that allowed her to perpetrate evil deeds for nearly two decades.* Patty's ring of criminals specialized in kidnapping and human trafficking. During the era of legal human bondage in America, they nabbed free people of color and sold them South for profit. Her downfall, when it finally came, cam...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jen and Jill share a popular episode from their Patreon page for Tiers 3 and 4. This overview of dreams discusses both scientific and mystical viewpoints. The sisters cover ancient and modern practices for using dreams as avenues for self discovery and spiritual communication. Further, they talk about the most common dreams and their meanings and how to tell when...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jennifer and Jill discuss one of the first witch trials to occur on the American continent. The stage was set for conflict when the colonists of New Sweden became subjects to the English crown. For some, the old Swedish ways lived on through the folk magic of "healers". Margaret Mattson of Ridley Creek was one such healer, tried for witchcraft in 1683. The results...

Hi, Friends! We wanted to share this episode* of our Detours series, which is available on Patreon for members at Tiers 2 and above. On this episode, Jill takes a deep dive into the history of sodomy laws and how they morphed into anti-gay legislation and discrimination. Jill's bestie, the FABULOUS Ryan, joins us for that conversation... and sticks around to give us his take on Episode 72: Blackbe...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jennifer and Jill reveal the man behind the legend of Blackbeard. While little is known of his early life, the notorious pirate wreaked havoc on the Atlantic Coast from 1716 until his death in 1718. His reputation as a murderous barbarian inspired fear far and wide. Yet recently discovered evidence sheds light on Blackbeard's true character and motivations. Listen...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jen and Jill relate ghost stories from Atlantic City's past and present. Does the ghost of Steelman still terrorize treasure seekers on the beach? Do World War II soldiers still wander the halls and grounds of the Resorts Hotel and Casino? What happenings continue to rattle the modern day guests of the Claridge Hotel? Listen in now for some fun, spooky stories fro...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jennifer and Jill solve a murder case that's been cold for nearly ninety years. When 19 year old Anna Cardile left her Pleasantville, New Jersey home on the evening of October 3rd, 1934, she didn't tell her family where she was going. The next time any of them saw her, it was to identify her body in a shallow, sandy grave. Police would follow every lead, collectin...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jen and Jill tell a tale of love, betrayal and murder out of rural New Jersey in 1920. Mystery unfolds when a young woman vanishes from her family farm and her skeleton is found in a nearby forest. Not long after, her brother is shot to death. The suspect flees and justice fails in the shadow of the corruption and crime of Atlantic City.  Listen in now as Jen and...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jen and Jill conclude their discussion of the Doan Family Outlaws with another special guest. Annie Halliday, Director of Library and Archives at the Mercer Museum, offers historical insight into the motivations behind the infamous criminal band. The sisters learn more about the life and times of the Doans and finally give the family a voice.  Check out the Mercer...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jen and Jill welcome two special guests to discuss the story of the Doan Family Outlaws. Creator and producer of the TV series "America's Original Outlaws," Mark I. McNutt is joined by fellow Bucks County native, TV personality and paranormal investigator Katrina Weidman to talk about the legend of the Doans. In the Revolutionary War period, the Doan boys rose to...

It's Jen's turn in the hot seat! This special episode of Common Mystics is all about Jennifer James! Whereas Jill has been communicating with spirits for as long as she can remember, Jen's journey has been very different. As the oldest daughter of a single mother of four, Jen was practical and responsible at a young age. She chose to ignore the spiritual side of herself until well into adulthood....

This very special episode of Common Mystics is all about Jill Stanley! Interacting with the spirit world since infancy, Jill shares her journey of psychic development with candor... and lots of laughs. Most of all, she gives tips and takeaways that anyone can use. Come join us for this intimate chat between sisters and stick around for a few words of wisdom. Check out the extended version of this...

On this episode of Common Mystics* Jennifer and Jill are joined by the multi-talented Antoinette "Tiyi" Schippers. An accomplished storyteller, author, musician and poet, Tiyi's mystical abilities have led her to serve as a helper to spirits in need. While visiting her in her home town of Cadillac, Michigan, Jen and Jill picked up on a murder mystery that has haunted Tiyi for years. Perhaps by sha...

On this episode of Common Mystics, longtime friend Jenny Bee joins the sisters as they reflect on their highlights from 2022. Jen and Jill revisit some of their favorite voices from the road, psychic breadcrumbs, and standout podcasting moments. Looking back on what they manifested in the past year, they make new intentions for 2023... and share BIG NEWS about the upcoming Common Mystics book rele...

On this special holiday episode of Common Mystics Jennifer and Jill dive into the roots of Christmas. If nothing else, tune in to hear Jill's versions of the Nativity and the Immaculate Conception.  Then stick around for some interesting history and thoughtful contemplation on the meaning of the holiday season. Support Common Mystics on Patreon here: https://www.patreon.com/commonmystics and sign...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jennifer and Jill tell the story behind the largest manhunt in Ohio state history.* Robert Daniels and John West first met as cellmates in prison. Despite being paroled for good behavior, the two met up again outside the clink in July 1948 and embarked on a murderous crime spree. The media dubbed the motive "revenge". But the spirits have a different take... and i...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jen and Jill tell a true story of courage, perseverance and survival against all odds.* During the French and Indian War, Mary Draper Ingles and her two young sons were captured by Shawnee raiders. Soon after, her sons were taken from her and she was forced into servitude. It was at Big Bone Lick in present day Kentucky that she fled into the wilderness. Incredibl...

On this episode of Common Mystics Jennifer and Jill unwittingly stumble upon a well known "Horror House" in Kentucky.* Located in Boone County, the Gaines Tavern is famous for its hauntings. No wonder. The area is a geographical unicorn with a prehistoric history of movement of humans and beasts. The tavern itself rose up from those old routes. First established as an inn, it would become many thi...