Chillworthy

On December 23, 1974, Rachel Trlica, Renee Wilson, and Julie Moseley set out for a simple Christmas shopping trip at Fort Worth’s Seminary South Shopping Center. They never returned. Their car was found in the parking lot, filled with wrapped presents, but there was no sign of the three girls. A cryptic letter sent to Rachel’s husband only deepened the mystery, raising more questions than answers....

When 53-year-old Kristine Fitzhugh, a beloved music teacher and devoted mother, was found at the bottom of her basement stairs in her Palo Alto home, it seemed like a tragic accident. But as investigators took a closer look, inconsistencies in the crime scene and autopsy report painted a far more sinister picture. What they uncovered was a decades-old secret, a hidden affair, and a desperate attem...

In May 2014, the quiet town of Waukesha, Wisconsin, became the site of a shocking and nearly fatal attack. Two 12-year-old girls, Morgan Geyser and Anissa Weier, lured their friend, Payton Leutner, into the woods under the guise of a game—only to stab her 19 times and leave her for dead. Their chilling motive? A belief that by killing in Slender Man’s name, they could prove their loyalty to the in...

Warren Barnes was a familiar figure in downtown Grand Junction, Colorado—a gentle, quiet man who spent his days reading near Monique's Bridal. Known as "The Reading Man," he was embraced by local shopkeepers, who offered him books, food, and kindness. But on the night of February 27, 2021, Warren became the victim of a horrifying crime. His killer, 19-year-old Brian Cohee, had been plagued by viol...

On December 1, 1948, a man was found dead on Somerton Beach in Adelaide, Australia. Dressed sharply in a suit, he carried no identification, no labels on his clothing, and no clear cause of death. Authorities were baffled. But then—hidden inside a secret pocket of his pants—they discovered a tiny, torn piece of paper with two eerie words: Tamam Shud, meaning "it is finished." The discovery led inv...

On March 13, 1964, 28-year-old Kitty Genovese was brutally attacked outside her apartment in Queens, New York. The shocking headlines that followed claimed that 38 witnesses watched in silence and did nothing to help—a chilling tale that cemented the Bystander Effect in the public consciousness. But was the story we’ve been told for decades actually true? In this episode, we dive deep into the rea...

The holidays aren’t just about jolly cheer and presents—there’s a darker side to the season, embodied by Krampus, the terrifying folklore figure who punishes the naughty. In this chilling bonus episode, we explore the origins of Krampus, his connection to European traditions, and how his legend has endured through centuries. Is Krampus just a myth meant to scare children—or could there be a grain...

The mystery of D.B. Cooper just got a fresh twist! 🛩️💼 New evidence has emerged implicating Roy McCoy, a man with a shadowy past and surprising ties to the infamous skyjacking. In this update episode, Brent and Talia dive into the recently uncovered details and explore what they could mean for the case. If you’ve been with us for a while, you’ll recall our two earlier episodes—one delving into th...

What a ride! In this special recap episode, we revisit the most chilling moments, listener-favorite cases, unexpected laughs, and yes—hilarious bloopers—from Season 1 of Chillworthy. 🕵️‍♀️💀 Join us as we reflect on an incredible debut season and thank you, our amazing listeners, for making it unforgettable. After this, we’re taking a well-deserved holiday break 🎄❄️ to recharge. But don’t worry—w...

 A late-night phone call, a mysterious figure seen near his home, and eerie clues left behind have kept true crime enthusiasts and UFO researchers alike captivated for decades. Gary Sudbrink received several calls that night that can't be explained.  👽With the recent groundbreaking revelations about the existence of extraterrestrial life, we revisit Gary’s case with fresh eyes. Could this be conn...

In this thrilling continuation of our D.B. Cooper deep dive, we shift our focus to the suspects. 🕵️‍♂️ Who were the people investigators believed could have been behind the infamous 1971 skyjacking and daring disappearance? From seasoned skydivers and military men to rogue con artists and mysterious loners, the list of potential Coopers is as bizarre as the crime itself. 🌲✈️ Could any of them tru...

In this episode of Chillworthy, we unravel the eerie and perplexing case of Cindy James, a nurse from British Columbia whose life took a horrifying turn in 1982. For nearly seven years, Cindy reported being the target of relentless harassment, threats, and violent attacks. Despite over 100 incidents and police investigations, no definitive culprit was ever identified. Was Cindy tormented by a sadi...

In this episode of Chillworthy, we’re diving into one of America’s most enduring mysteries: the story of D.B. Cooper. On a rainy November night in 1971, a man known only by this pseudonym hijacked a Northwest Orient Airlines flight, demanded $200,000 in cash, and then, in an audacious twist, parachuted from the plane—never to be seen again. Join us as we trace the timeline of Cooper's legendary he...

In this chilling episode, we dive deep into one of the most bizarre and brutal cases of the early 20th century: the mysterious death of Elfrieda Knaak, better known as The Furnace Girl. In 1928, Elfrieda was found horribly burned but still alive, left near the boiler room of an Illinois government building. Her final hours were shrouded in agony and unanswered questions, sparking intense public cu...

This October, Chillworthy brings you another spine-tingling tale in our special spooky series: the legend of the Devil’s Chair. In graveyards across America, mysterious stone chairs have sparked a host of terrifying rumors. Sit in one at midnight, they say, and you might hear the whispers of the dead—or worse, invite the Devil himself. From eerie sightings to tragic tales, we’ll explore the origin...

In this bone-chilling episode of Chillworthy, we dive into the eerie tale of Mercy Brown, the last American vampire—or at least, that’s what her family and community believed. As part of our special spooky October series, we’ll unravel the disturbing events surrounding Mercy’s death in 1892, when a small Rhode Island town became consumed by fear and superstition. Was Mercy truly a vampire feeding...

On this gripping episode of Chillworthy, we unravel the baffling case of Brandon Swanson, a 19-year-old from Marshall, Minnesota, who vanished without a trace in the early hours of May 14, 2008. After accidentally driving his car into a ditch, Brandon called his parents for help, staying on the line as he walked toward what he believed was a nearby town. But then, in the dead of night, his phone c...

Welcome Chillers!!! In this spine-chilling episode of Chillworthy, we take a deep dive into the eerie origins and evolution of the Bloody Mary legend. From sleepover dares to genuine paranormal investigations, the story of the vengeful spirit who appears in the mirror has terrified generations. But where did this urban legend truly begin? Is there a historical basis for the haunting figure, or is...

In this chilling part 2 of episode 15 of Chillworthy, we explore the hauntingly beautiful yet deeply unsettling Aokigahara Forest, located at the base of Japan’s iconic Mount Fuji. Known to many as the "Suicide Forest," Aokigahara has become infamous as one of the world’s most prevalent sites for suicide, with hundreds of tragic deaths taking place beneath its dense canopy. Join us as we navigate...

In this chilling episode of Chillworthy, we explore the hauntingly beautiful yet deeply unsettling Aokigahara Forest, located at the base of Japan’s iconic Mount Fuji. Known to many as the "Suicide Forest," Aokigahara has become infamous as one of the world’s most prevalent sites for suicide, with hundreds of tragic deaths taking place beneath its dense canopy. Join us as we navigate the myths, my...

In this haunting episode, we explore the strange and tragic case of Elisa Lam, a 21-year-old Canadian student whose disappearance and death at the infamous Cecil Hotel in Los Angeles captivated the world in 2013. What began as a missing person case quickly took a bizarre turn when elevator footage of Elisa's last known moments surfaced, showing her behaving erratically, sparking countless theories...

Join us in this chilling bonus minisode 13.1, as we delve into the baffling case of 76-year-old Connie Johnson, a beloved woman with a passion for the outdoors who vanished while on a solo camping trip in the rugged wilderness of Idaho in 2018. Despite extensive search efforts, few clues were ever found. What happened to Connie in those remote woods? ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Click here⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠  to see all listenin...

In this episode of Chillworthy, we delve into the mysterious disappearance of Terrence Woods, Jr., a young and promising filmmaker whose life took an unexpected turn. On October 5, 2018, Terrence was on location in Idaho's rugged and remote Orogrande area, working as a production assistant for a British television documentary. What was supposed to be an ordinary day of filming ended in tragedy Joi...

In this chilling episode of Chillworthy, we delve into one of California's most perplexing mysteries: the disappearance of the Yuba County Five. In February 1978, five young men—Jack Madruga, Bill Sterling, Ted Weiher, Jack Huett, and Gary Mathias—vanished without a trace after attending a basketball game in Chico, California. Their abandoned car was found miles away from their intended route, dee...

In 2019, Marshal Iwaas seemed to vanish into thin air, leaving behind a mystery that has puzzled investigators and haunted his loved ones ever since. In this gripping episode of Chillworthy, we dive deep into the perplexing disappearance of Marshal Iwaas—a man with no known enemies and an ordinary life, who simply vanished one day. Was it a calculated escape, a tragic accident, or something far mo...