You'd Be Surprised Podcast

In this candid and deeply personal episode, Tiarra Brummond shares her powerful story of growing up in a close-knit rural community, navigating family trauma after her parents’ divorce, and making life-altering decisions at a young age—including marrying at 17. Through heartbreak, resilience, and moments of self-reflection, Tiara opens up about the experiences that shaped her and the lessons she l...

In this chatty episode of You’d Be Surprise , Becca and Chelsie recap the dramatic finale of The Traitors , breaking down shocking betrayals, Rob’s winning gameplay, and the aftermath of the reunion. The conversation jumps into their latest TV obsessions—including the eerily realistic series Paradise —before spiraling into viral internet moments and celebrity rumors. From conspiracy theories surro...

In this chatty episode, Becca and Chelsie bounce between pop-culture hot takes and TV obsessions, recapping dramatic moments from The Traitors, debating seasons of Bridgerton, and sharing excitement about a new Yellowstone spinoff. While also unpacking controversies highlighted in America's Next Top Model and reacting to the ethics of teen pregnancy shows like Unexpected. We swap opinions on a cha...

In this lively episode of the You'd Be Surprise , the hosts recap Becca’s intense bout with influenza and ulcers, chat about Utah’s wild snowstorm canceling guests, and dive deep into reality-TV and pop-culture gossip—from excitement over a new season of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives and speculation about relationships tied to The Bachelorette , to reactions about finales like Tell Me Lies and...

In this candid and heartfelt episode, Maryn shares her journey from her childhood to her whirlwind post-mission romance and quick engagement. Listen to how she navigated early marriage challenges, grief, and personal growth. She opens up about becoming a young mom, her vastly different birth and postpartum experiences, and how anxiety shaped her early motherhood before she found support and confid...

This episode is a classic You’d Be Surprise spiral—in the best way. Becca and Chelsie dive deep into their obsession with The Traitors (good riddance, Lisa), debate shady gameplay, and chat about what they’re watching next, from Survivor to upcoming March TV like Secret Lives of Mormon Wives and Yellowstone spinoffs. They cover book releases, unfinished house projects, Super Bowl food > footbal...

This spicy episode is an unfiltered pop-culture rollercoaster as Becca and Chelsie dish on The Traitors power plays, reality TV strategy fails, and who they’re rooting for to survive the round table. From cringey Tell Me Lies takes and uncomfortable on-screen intimacy to book-to-screen drama, Taylor Swift wedding rumors, TikTok scandals, and MomTok chaos, nothing is off limits. Add in lawsuits ove...

In this episode of You’d Be Surprised , Chelsea and Becca sit down with Graycie Schiess , a western lifestyle content creator, mom, and homesteader, to talk about motherhood, social media, farming life, and staying grounded in your values online. Graycie shares her upbringing in Utah and Idaho, how she met her husband in high school, and what life looks like raising two young kids on a small farm....

In this lighthearted-but-real episode of You’d Be Surprise , Becca and Chelsie take a break from the constant negativity online and dive into what everyone’s talking about from The Traitors spoilers and shocking gameplay twists to reality TV chaos with Sister Wives and Tell Me Lies . They unpack celebrity news, upcoming binge-worthy shows, and why some series hit hard while others fall flat, inclu...

In this episode of You’d Be Surprised , Chelsea and Becca sit down with Anna Doyle , co-owner of Ruby Claire Boutique , to talk about entrepreneurship, motherhood, family business, and the winding road that led her to building a successful online boutique. Anna shares her upbringing in North Ogden, Utah, a childhood filled with family time, gardening, mountain views, and unforgettable summer memor...

In this episode of You’d Be Surprised , Becca and Chelsie kick things off by celebrating an early bingo card win before diving into everything they can’t stop talking about—from BookTok hype and current reads to upcoming TV shows, spinoffs, and long-awaited new seasons. We break down fantasy fatigue, debate whether certain books live up to the buzz, and share what they’re most excited to watch in...

In this New Year kickoff episode of You’d Be Surprised , Becca and Chelsea welcome listeners back after the holidays and reflect on the transition into 2026. They recap Christmas and New Year’s traditions, from family gatherings and ice skating to holiday trips and game nights, while acknowledging the emotional highs and lows that can come with the season. The conversation shifts into a candid dis...

After a long holiday break, Chelsea and Becca are back and catching up on everything from the haunting Housemaid movie twist and Sydney Sweeney’s performance to the latest binge-worthy shows like Landman , Stranger Things , and The Way Home . They dive into Hollywood drama with the alleged “Mean Girls” mom club, reality-TV updates from Sister Wives , MomTok, and Secret Lives of Mormon Wives , and...

In this episode of The Surprise Podcast , hosts Chelsea and Becka sit down with Kathy Schroeder, the creator behind Cache Valley Buzz , a popular local social media platform highlighting events, businesses, and community stories throughout Cache Valley. Kathy shares her deep roots in the valley, growing up in Hyrum as a self-described “national park kid,” and how leaving—and eventually returning—h...

In this holiday episode, Chelsea and Becca jump into all things Christmas — the magic, the chaos, the mom-pressure, and the funny (and painful) realities of gift-giving. From husbands who have zero clue what's under the tree, to advent calendar fails, to kids who don’t care about Christmas outings the way moms dream they will, this episode is equal parts hilarious and relatable. They unpack childh...

In this jam-packed episode of You’d Be Surprise , Becca and Chelsie speed through a week full of opinions, pop culture chaos, and jaw-dropping internet stories. They break down Sister Wives frustrations—from TLC’s dragging storylines and Meri’s endlessly repeated “Ron came down” to Kody’s cringey workout scene and a questionable apology tour—before pivoting to Secret Lives of Mormon Wives , where...

Brie Allred shares her journey through infertility, motherhood, and surviving breast cancer at age 28 while raising infant twins. After years of trying to conceive, she became pregnant with twins—only to later discover she had aggressive, triple-negative breast cancer. Brie walks through diagnosis, surgery, chemotherapy, hair loss, and the emotional toll of fighting cancer as a young mom. Through...

In this episode of You’d Be Surprise , Becca and Chelsie dive back into the wild world of reality TV now that Dancing with the Stars has wrapped. They break down the latest Sister Wives drama, including Kody’s sudden apology tour and whether any of it feels sincere—or just for show. Then they shift to the chaos of Secret Lives of Mormon Wives , from Dakota’s awkward reunion appearance to Demi’s un...

In this episode, we sit down with sisters Emme and Savannah, the owners of Studio Fit, to talk about their journey from high-fitness fanatics to leaders in the growing “muscle mommy” and low-impact strength movement. They open up about transitioning from instructors to business owners, managing a big team of mostly women, and navigating tough conversations with empathy and boundaries. We dive into...

In this long-overdue episode, Becca and Chelsie dive into the jam-packed Dancing With the Stars season finale — from five-contestant chaos to jaw-dropping freestyles and the surprising win that left everyone talking. Then they break down Whitney Leavitt’s Call Her Daddy appearance, the Broadway rumors, and whether DWTS voting is even real anymore. And of course… the Fruity Pebbles drama. The girls...

This episode of the You’d Be Surprised Podcast features special guest Margaret Gittins , affectionately known throughout Cache Valley as the Caramel Apple Queen . The hosts dive into her childhood, adoption story, family life, business journey, and how she built the iconic caramel-apple brand Smackerel .

Join us LIVE every Wednesday on TikTok for all things reality TV and in the world! This week’s episode is packed with drama — we’re diving into the shocking elimination on Dancing with the Stars , breaking down the wildest moments from Secret Lives of Mormon Wives , and giving a quick recap of Sister Wives (yes, Kody and Robyn are as cringy as ever). From Coyote Pass chaos to some real-life hairst...

This episode features Julie Baumgartner —a registered nurse, business owner, and mother of four—who shares her journey from nursing and entrepreneurship to becoming a co-owner of SALT Hydration & Wellness , a fast-growing IV therapy and women’s wellness company.

Becca and Chelsea kick off with a quick Sister Wives rundown—Kody and Robyn’s awkward dance lessons, Maddie’s baby countdown, Christine vs. David over movie-quote “heartfelt,” and Meri unearthing an old love letter—then roast Cody’s Special Forces antics. They dive into Dancing with the Stars’ 20th birthday episode: Tom Bergeron’s return, Elaine’s grit, perfect 40's for Robert, Dylan, Alix, and Wh...

In this heartwarming and hilarious episode, Chelsie and Becca sit down with the women of the Pickleville Playhouse—Kenzie, Whitley, and Sharli—to talk all things family, theater, and motherhood. From jump-roping kids backstage to the art of theatre, the Pickleville crew shares what it’s really like to run a beloved family business. They open up about balancing babies and business, working alongsid...