You Two Scare Me Podcast | A Paranormal Podcast

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we’re heading way out west to El Paso, Texas, a city where history haunts every corner and the desert wind carries more than just dust. We’ll start at El Paso High School, often called the most haunted school in America. From there, we step into the De Soto Hotel, where fire and tragedy have left more than just scars. Then it’s off to Monteleone’s Ristorante, wher...

Send us Fan Mail In this bone-chilling episode of the Home State Collection, Andi and Feliz head to the island city of Galveston, Texas, a place where the salt air is thick with history and hauntings. We explore the tragic legacy of the 1900 Great Galveston Hurricane, the deadliest natural disaster in U.S. history, and how it left a permanent mark on the island’s spiritual landscape. Our tour begi...

Send us Fan Mail In this chilling season premiere of our Pennsylvania Collection, Andi takes us back to her home state to explore the watery grave of Livermore, PA. Once a thriving canal and railroad town, Livermore was erased from the map by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in the 1950s—but many believe its destruction was foretold by a dark, centuries-old secret. We dive into the legend of the L...

Send us Fan Mail In this haunting season premiere, the You Two Scare Me Podcast heads west to the Lone Star State! Andi and Feliz kick off their Home State Collection by diving into the deep, dark history of Texas—from the six flags that have flown over it to the Indigenous peoples like the Caddo and Comanche who first called it home. We explore the chilling legend of La Llorona, the "Weeping...

Send us Fan Mail In this final episode of our Key West Collection, Andi and Feliz dive deep into the maritime mysteries and restless souls of "Bone Island." We start at the Key West Shipwreck Treasure Museum, a recreation of Asa Tift’s 19th-century warehouse, where the artifacts of the Isaac Allerton—the richest shipwreck in Key West history—are said to carry the spirits of drowned sailo...

Send us Fan Mail In this out-of-this-world episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, Andi and Feliz trade ghost stories for UFOs and USOs (Unidentified Submerged Objects). While Key West is famous for its haunted history, the skies and waters surrounding this tiny island have been a hotspot for unexplained aerial and aquatic phenomena for decades. We dive deep into the declassified files of Project...

Send us Fan Mail In this spine-chilling episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, Andi and Feliz take a "field trip" to the Key West Firehouse Museum and discover that some spirits are more than willing to talk back! Armed with dowsing rods, K2 meters, and a spirit box, the ladies capture incredible evidence of the afterlife, from a tragic 12-year-old boy named Jack Ray to the mysterious...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, Andi and Feliz explore the haunted history of Fort Zachary Taylor (or "Fort Zach" to the locals). Built in 1845, this National Historic Landmark sits on the southern tip of Key West and holds the largest collection of Civil War cannons in the United States. But beyond the impressive masonry and military history lies a dark...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we’re hitting up three of Key West’s most haunted locations. First, the Gato House, once home to a wealthy cigar baron, where guests have seen shadows and heard strange voices. Next, the Oldest House, a classic piece of Key West history—and a hotspot for ghostly figures and unexplained sounds. Finally, we check out the Marrero Guest Mansion, where a heartbroken wo...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, Andi and Feliz travel 70 miles west of Key West to the remote and mysterious Dry Tortugas National Park. At the center of these isolated islands sits Fort Jefferson, a massive, unfinished coastal fortress with a dark history of disease, isolation, and despair. We dive into the story of the fort’s most famous prisoner, Dr. Samuel Mud...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we’re doubling up on haunted hotspots in Key West—starting with the Old Monroe County Jail. With a grim history of violence, isolation, and death, it’s no surprise people report cold spots, whispers, and shadow figures in the empty cells. Then we head over to the Key West Firehouse Museum, where former firefighters say the spirits of their fallen comrades still li...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, we climb to the top of one of Key West’s most iconic landmarks—the Key West Lighthouse. But it’s not just the view that’ll give you chills. Visitors and staff have reported shadowy figures, disembodied footsteps, and a mysterious woman in white, believed to be the spirit of the first female lighthouse keeper. From unexplained lights to eerie sensations in the towe...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, Andi and Feliz take a stroll down Duval Street to investigate the dark and tragic history of the La Concha Hotel. Built in 1926, this grand hotel is the tallest building in Key West, but its height has come with a heavy price. We explore the chilling stories of the 13 rooftop suicides and the restless spirits that still linger at th...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, Andi and Feliz dive deep into the swamplands and mangroves to track Florida’s most infamous cryptid: The Skunk Ape. Often called the "Bigfoot of the South" or the "Sasquatch of the Southeast," this massive, hairy, and incredibly foul-smelling creature has been a part of Florida folklore for generations. We explor...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, Andi and Feliz explore one of the most famous and haunted locations in Key West: the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum. While thousands of tourists visit every year to see the lush gardens and the legendary six-toed cats, many leave with stories of a much more mysterious nature. We dive into the history of the grand Spanish Colonial...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, Andi and Feliz take you inside one of the most legendary and haunted bars in Key West: Captain Tony’s Saloon. Located at 428 Greene Street, this building has a history as colorful and dark as the island itself. From its days as the city’s ice house and morgue to its infamous reputation as the site of the Hanging Tree, we explore why...

Send us Fan Mail In this bone-chilling episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, Andi and Feliz explore one of the most bizarre and unsettling stories in Florida history. We dive into the morbid obsession of Carl Tanzler (better known as Count Carl von Cosel) and his "romance" with the beautiful Elena Hoyos. This isn't your typical love story. From the halls of the Marine Hospital in...

Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, Andi and Feliz dive deep into the chilling legend of Robert the Doll, the world’s most famous haunted doll. From his origins in a turn-of-the-century German toy factory to his current residence at the Fort East Martello Museum in Key West, we explore the dark history, the voodoo curse rumors, and the terrifying firsthand accounts th...