Justin Hibbard

Why Catholic?

Religion EN ↓ 201 episodes

Dive into the what and why behind Catholic beliefs with Justin Hibbard - former Evangelical Pastor, Apologist, and Catholic convert. whycatholic.substack.com

Be sure to visit the podcast's website and support the creator: whycatholic.substack.com

Author

Justin Hibbard

Category

Religion

Podcast website

whycatholic.substack.com

Latest episode

Nov 14, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 10M+ downloads · 4.7+ rating iOS soon

Episodes

#25 - Interview with Cory Dennis - Politician Converts to Catholicism 19.12.2022

In this episode, Justin Hibbard interviews Cory Dennis, press secretary for the Attorney General of Louisiana. Cory and Justin share a number of things together: they both graduated from Annapolis Area Christian School, Justin was Cory’s former teacher, and they both entered the Catholic Church at the Easter Vigil in 2022. Cory shares his faith journey from an Evangelical home, to entering the Nav...

#24 - Our Lady of Guadalupe 12.12.2022

In a time of hostile tension between the Spanish and the Aztecs, the miracle of Our Lady of Guadalupe changed the course of history. In this episode, Justin Hibbard recounts the story of Our Lady of Guadalupe, why it was so important in the evangelization of the New World, and some of the peculiar phenomena of the image of the Virgin Mary on the 500-year-old tilma. Be sure to subscribe to Why Cath...

#23 - Confirmation & the Baptism of the Holy Spirit 12.12.2022

The Sacrament of Confirmation is the rite in which the Holy Spirit is conferred upon the baptized Christian. In this episode, Justin Hibbard explains the biblical basis for confirmation, the different practices and opinions across the Catholic Church, and the importance of confirmation in the life of the Christian. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider. Become a W...

#22 - The Jewish Roots of Confirmation 05.12.2022

The Catholic Church believes that the Holy Spirit is completely conferred upon a baptized Christian upon the Sacrament of Confirmation. Where does this practice come from? Why do Catholics use oil for confirmation? In this episode, Justin Hibbard explores the Jewish roots of the Sacrament of Confirmation. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider. Become a Why Catholi...

#21 - Interview with Amy Thomas - the Catholic Pilgrim 28.11.2022

In this episode, Justin Hibbard interviews Amy Thomas (aka the Catholic Pilgrim). Amy shares how she grew up in an Evangelical home, turned her back on God in anger, married a Catholic, and eventually became Catholic herself. Amy gives advice to Catholics on sharing their faith and standing up for convictions, as well as gives her perspective on preventing sexual abuse. Follow the Catholic Pilgrim...

#20 - A Brief Defense of Catholic Baptism 21.11.2022

Why does the Catholic Church believe that baptism is the initiation into the Christian community? Why do we call it a sacrament? Why do we baptize infants? In this episode Justin Hibbard breaks down the Catholic sacrament of baptism and addresses some of the common arguments against the Catholic theology of baptism. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider. Become a...

#19 - The Solemnity of Christ the King 19.11.2022

Why do we have a solemnity commemorating Christ the King? Where did it come about and what is its purpose? In this episode, Justin Hibbard shares the background of this holy day as well as some some personal stories of his relationship to politics and how coming into the Catholic Church helped him reorient his perception to the reality that Jesus is King. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on y...

#18 - One Baptism for the Forgiveness of Sins 14.11.2022

The Nicene Creed includes the phrase “I believe in one baptism for the forgiveness of sins.” In this episode, Justin Hibbard looks through Scripture and history to explain how the historical Church has understood that Christian baptism is a one-time event and how it is a sacrament that washes away original sin. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider. Become a Why C...

#17 - The Jewish Roots of Baptism 07.11.2022

Why does initiation into the Christian community begin with a ceremony involving water? In this episode, Justin Hibbard explores Christian baptism and its roots in the Jewish practice of mikvah. Learn some of the specific details around a proper Jewish mikvah and how Christian baptism is similar and different. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider. Become a Why Ca...

#16 - The Eucharist Changes Everything 31.10.2022

In this episode, Justin Hibbard concludes the mini-series on the Sacrament of the Eucharist. How does the belief that the real presence of Jesus in the Eucharist affect the practice of the Mass as well as various beliefs throughout Catholicism? Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider. Become a Why Catholic? patron at whycatholic.substack.com/subscribe Submit questio...

#15 - The Mysterious Case of Eucharistic Miracles 24.10.2022

While Catholics believe that the Eucharist becomes the body, blood, soul, and divinity of Jesus, the form remains bread and wine. However, what if it didn’t? What if the bread turned into flesh and the wine into blood in an extraordinary miracle? In this episode Justin Hibbard explores a few cases of Eucharistic miracles over the centuries and the scientific evidence that claims a miracle is the o...

#14 - The Eucharist Throughout History 17.10.2022

How has the Christian Church historically and consistently understood the Eucharist? Join Justin Hibbard as he looks at Jesus’ Bread of Life Discourse in John 6 through the lens of followers of the Apostles and Church leaders throughout history. You may even be surprised to hear some prominent Protestants share the Catholic understanding of the Eucharist. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on y...

#13 - Interview with Devin Halford - From Atheist to Catholic Missionary 10.10.2022

In this episode, Justin Hibbard interviews Devin Halford, a former atheist who converted to Catholicism and is now a missionary to the homeless with Christ in the City in Denver, CO. Devin’s missionary profile page Christ in the City website Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider. Become a Why Catholic? patron at whycatholic.substack.com/subscribe Submit questions...

#12 - Q&A - Fall 2022 03.10.2022

In this Q&A episode, Justin answers the following questions: * “I would like to know what you gave up and had to sacrifice in becoming Catholic.” * “Us Catholics are aware that Protestants know the Bible far better than we do. How has becoming Catholic changed the way you read the Bible?” * “I’m a fairly new Christian. Why should I convert to Catholicism? I like the reverence and beauty, but I jus...

#11 - From Baptist Pastor to Faithful Catholic 26.09.2022

This is a recording of Justin Hibbard’s presentation about how he went from a lifelong Protestant and a Baptist Pastor to the Catholic Church. This was recorded on September 15th at St. Mary’s Catholic Church in Park City, UT at their September Summit. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider. Become a Why Catholic? patron at whycatholic.substack.com/subscribe Submit...

#10 - The Center of Existence 19.09.2022

Flannery O’Connor the great fiction author once took great offense when someone suggested to her that the Eucharist was just a nice symbol. “If it’s just a symbol, then to hell with it,” she said. In this episode, Justin Hibbard continues an explanation on the sacrament of the Eucharist and the theology behind it. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider. Become a Wh...

#9 - The Jewish Roots of the Eucharist 12.09.2022

Why do Christians commemorate Jesus’ death with a piece of bread and wine? In this episode, Justin Hibbard (co-founder of the ministry Christianity is Jewish), explores the origin of the Eucharist (aka communion or Lord’s Supper) by explaining its context in the Passover Seder. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider. Become a Why Catholic? patron at whycatholic.sub...

#8 - St. Peter Claver: Slave to the Negroes Forever 09.09.2022

As a special monthly episode, Justin Hibbard explains the significance of a particular feast day in the liturgical calendar. In this September 9th episode, Justin explores the life of Saint Peter Claver aka Pedro Claver - an extraordinary 17th century Jesuit missionary from Spain who poured out his life to provide physical and spiritual aid to Africans who were unjustly taken from their homes and...

#7 - The Collective Memory of Christianity 06.09.2022

What value is there in considering what the earliest Christians believed? Why do certain sects of Christianity dismiss the early Church? Should we read the Bible with our own limited scope, or should we read Scripture, considering what the disciples of the Biblical writers believed and practiced? In this episode, Justin shares what led him to reconsider everything he ever thought about Christian h...

#6 - With God, in Community 29.08.2022

Why does the Catholic Church (and Orthodox Church for that matter) teach that the sacraments are only available inside the Church? In this episode, Justin Hibbard discusses the nature of God as a communal being and how He works to bring us into community (and unity) with other Believers. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider. Become a Why Catholic? patron at whyca...

#5 - Invitation to Narnia 22.08.2022

Is Christianity a boring and stale religion full of stifling rules? Or is it a wild faith full of myth, fantasy, and the supernatural? In this episode, Justin Hibbard continues highlighting the Sacramental Worldview of Catholicism by focusing on the supernatural undercurrent of Christianity - where Heaven kisses earth, where myth becomes fact. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite...

#4 - The Ark of the Covenant 15.08.2022

What can the Ark of the Covenant teach us about a sacramental worldview and the portal between heaven and earth? In this episode, Justin Hibbard explains some of those mysterious and haunting biblical accounts of the Ark of the Covenant, and why comprehending these stories is essential for understanding the Catholic worldview. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider...

#3 - A Sacramental Worldview 08.08.2022

What is the worldview of Catholicism? In this episode, Justin Hibbard dives into the why of Catholicism by explaining a sacramental worldview. What are the sacraments? What do the sacraments accomplish? How do we partner with God in the sacraments? And how does a restaurant compare to the sacraments? Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider. Become a Why Catholic? pa...

#2 - The Language of Catholicism 01.08.2022

Why do Protestants and Catholics struggle to find common ground on theological ideas? Is it that they embrace very divergent Christian worldviews, or is it more of a language barrier where concepts, words, and emphasis gets lost in translation? Join Justin Hibbard, a Catholic convert, who has a background in linguistics and spent 39 years in various Protestant circles, explain how Catholicism is a...

#1 - Get to the Why 25.07.2022

In this episode, Justin explains his theory of the three levels of articulating worldviews and how getting to the why helps us be better apologists of our own beliefs as well as more charitable in talking about someone else’s perspectives. Be sure to subscribe to Why Catholic? on your favorite podcast provider. Become a Why Catholic? patron at whycatholic.substack.com/subscribe Submit questions fo...

Listen to the Why Catholic? podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.