Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny
When Sodom Met Gomorrah
Every Sunday, join two best friends (two blessed friends!), Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny, as they read the Holy Bible—book by book—and recap the goofiest, gaggiest ways of God.
Author
Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny
Category
Podcast website
Latest episode
Jun 7, 2026
Where to listen?
Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soonPodcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts
Episodes
EZEKIEL THE FREAK-IEL! PART 1 | Episode 27 with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 09.11.2025 39:20
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah, we learn that Ezekiel is not only a performance art loving prophet, but also a complete and unabashed size queen. That's right, we read multiple verses about whores lusting after well endowed men and we feel oh so seen. We haven't struggled to move on from a verse so much since Sarah's giggles had us laughing back in Genesis! Representation matt...
LAMENTATIONS OF A WIMPY KID | Episode 26 with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 26.10.2025 29:27
On this episode of When Sodom Met Gomorrah... We go through the grief of Jerusalem, but more importantly go through Buddy's Halloween costume: Chicken Michael Jackson. Benny calls her mom, meets Addison Rae, and acknowledges that her aunt used to live in Paris. Let's go!
JEREMIAH, THEREMIAH, EVERYWHEREMIAH! | Episode 25 with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 19.10.2025 42:59
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah, we read the book of Jeremiah, written by none other than Jeremiah, who, after cementing his legacy with this book of the Bible, went on to write hits such as Birthday Sex. He's such versatile and everlasting figure of greatness and power. This book is filled with God's usual shenanigans of hating and then killing his chosen people, but with some fun...
ISAIAH’D WHAT I SAID! PART 2 | Episode 24 with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 12.10.2025 34:39
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah, we re-dip our toes back into the book of Isaiah! And the water is… cold… and murky…. God, are you there? Help us. We love you. Please help. Lord, please. Find me where you made me. I'm where the trade made me. Help!
I SAY-UH, ISAIAH! PART 1 | Episode 23 with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 05.10.2025 33:16
Hewwo pwincess... This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah, we dip our toes into the book of Isaiah! And yes, we do mean dip... because for the first time in WSMG Pod history, we have split a book into two parts because this book was so god damned long it was only logical. So put your headphones on, sit back and listen to us SAYUH what we SAYID! OKAYYY PWINCESS LET'S GO!
THIS IS MY FIGHT SONG OF SOLOMON | Episode 22 with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 28.09.2025 30:25
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah, we dip into the refreshing waters of Solomon Lake! AKA... the sexy book! Or so we thought... turns out taking monogamy advice from a man with 700 wives and 300 concubines is low-key crazyyyy. We somehow get some Kamala Harris soundbites in here. And maybe sing quite a bit too. LET'S GO.
ECCLESIASTES WTF DO I NAME THIS EP | Episode 21 with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 21.09.2025 37:48
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah, we get into what is essentially Miss Benny's Book of Job equivalent. Yes, remember when Buddy almost cried reading the Book of Job and we gave you our most earnest episode to date? Well this time, it's Benny's turn! And amidst some real analysis of what Benny calls "the atheists book", we discuss XTina's decidedly not-a-hit single...
ARE YOU PROVERBS OR ANTI-VERBS? | Episode 20 With Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 14.09.2025 30:52
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we are back from our hiatus with new sounds, new guests, and a new episode talking about the book of Proverbs! If God is a woman, Solomon is a he/they in Bushwick cause his pen goes crazy but he can't do his dishes. Also Josie Totah is in this episode somehow. LET'S GO!
NOW THAT'S WHAT I CALL PSALMS: VOLUME 1 | Episode 19 With Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 27.07.2025 40:47
You guys... this is a very, VERY special episode... We're bustin' into Psalms, the book of songs and poems praising the one and only G O D!!! Now, we could have just read you this beautiful prose, but we thought you had enough earnest Bible reading after Job... So this week, we've gathered some of the biggest musical talents of our time to perform modern renditions of our favorite P...
PRAYER CIRCLE #3: "Is Digging In Your Butt A Sin?" 20.07.2025 20:29
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we took your prayer requests about digging in your butt, converting to another religion, and how to become a famous trans actress... Let's GO!
SLOB ON MY JOB | Episode 18 with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 13.07.2025 48:41
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we read the Book of Job otherwise known as The Book that Nearly Broke Buddy Keaton's Nascent Faith OR The Book Miss Benny Dreaded Reading the Most Due to Childhood Religious Trauma... Yes, it’s true: this is a heavy book, and we let ourselves get real earnest for you. Buddy almost cries! But don’t worry — amidst all the honesty, vulnerability, and dilige...
I'M WITH ESTHER! Episode 17, with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 06.07.2025 40:19
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we step into the only book of the bible that doesn't even mention God! And one of TWO that is titled after a woman (she/her/they) — listen as Benny recounts way too many unimportant details about her childhood and Buddy suffers to even care at all about his "best friend" or whatever. LET'S GO!
NEHEMIAH SET, HUT! Episode 16, with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 29.06.2025 38:28
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we dive deep into Nehemiah, waiting for something meaty... but not really finding it. However, we do have a lot of fun along the way. Join Benny and Buddy with special guests, The Dixie Chicks, Adele, Jason Derulo, and more! Who doesn't know what I'm talking about??? SET, HUT!
EZRA, EZRA, READ ALL ABOUT IT! Episode 15, with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 22.06.2025 30:42
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we step out of our tales of sleeping together and throwing up on our hookups and launch back into the Holy Book with the book of: EZRA. We talk about the mass divorce of the pagan wives, and Buddy nearly cries a few times. It's a huge day for believers like us. LET'S RIP SOME ASS!!!
SECOND CHRONICLES OF BENNY & BUDDY | Episode 14, with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 15.06.2025 46:18
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we are starting right where we left off and finishing counting down our TOP 10 favorite memories together as besties. We talk about our shared cosmetic procedures and how those can go awry, our shared couples massage and how that can go awry (for one of us), and our shared... well, just listen and find out what else we've shared. It's kind of insane...
FIRST CHRONICLES OF BUDDY & BENNY | Episode 13, with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 08.06.2025 41:04
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we forgo recapping every book of the bible so far (as First Chronicles would instruct us to do) and instead recap the top 10 moments of our friendship as two besties... we tell stories we've never told before and probably shouldn't in this two parter episode beginning with PART ONE. LET'S GO!
COMING BACK FOR SECONDS, KING? | Episode 12, with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 01.06.2025 46:21
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we are allergic to the drama, diva! (Bless you...) Children teasing a bald man, said bald man sicking bears on said children, a freaky prophet raising a child from the dead, a bloody coup that includes the annihilation of an entire family and the trampling of a gorgeous harlot, and so. much. idolatry. No wonder we're having such an intense reaction... LE...
FIRST KINGS, FIRST | Episode 11, with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 25.05.2025 39:38
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we dip into the cool refreshing waters of 1st Kings! These kings put the DOLL in Idolatry, and we put the TREE. We get some dead baby drama, a man with 700 wives and 300 concubines, and finally answer the question: Is Gravity by Sara Bareilles the best song ever written? LET'S GO.
PRAYER CIRCLE #2: TRAVEL AND SEX ABROAD 19.05.2025 29:28
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we are coming to you from closer to the source than ever before... Marrakech, Morocco baby gyal! Being two incredibly well traveled sex-enjoying-individuals, we thought this would be the ideal time to answer your questions on travel/sex. We cover topics like... How to travel with an enema or dildo? How do you handle a "roster"? Will Miss Benny and B...
GIMME A SECOND, SAMUEL | Episode 10, with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 11.05.2025 43:11
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we're getting into what is arguably the gaggiest and gayest book of the bible so far! Seriously it's story-rich as hell. We go over the highly debated same-sex attraction love of David & Jonathan, the rebound affair David has in his lover's wake, and through the story of David we finally answer the question: will bisexuals inherit the kingd...
FIRST SAMUEL, MORE LIKE THIRST SAMUEL! | Episode 9, with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 05.05.2025 49:51
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we're getting into some of the most sickening and iconic stories in The Bible. Israel's getting its first king, after all! But not only that, we're being introduced to some of the tallest and hottest characters yet. From Saul, to David, to Goliath himself, it seems God has a way of attracting XXL hunks from all over the Levant. Very Nice!
PRAYER CIRCLE #1: "Is Our Best Sex Behind Us?" 27.04.2025 23:10
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah... we take a fellowship detour into our debut episode of PRAYER CIRCLE! We take prayer requests from our devout followers of Christ (and our instagram @wsmgpod), and answer questions like... Should I remain celibate? Are open relationships okay? How do I stop lusting after gay guys and become more homophobic? Let us pray...
THE RUTH, THE WHOLE RUTH, AND NOTHING BUT... | Episode 8 with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 20.04.2025 41:30
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we're diving deep into one of the shortest books of The Bible and somehow making a full episode out of it. With only four chapters, you may be wondering: what topics could they possibly even cover in this? We talk about feet (quite a bit, actually), Oprah's gay love affair with Gayle King, Gayle King saying the F-slur, Benny doubting Buddy's lo...
I'LL BE THE JUDGES OF THAT! | Episode 7, with Buddy Keaton & Miss Benny 13.04.2025 44:20
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we… get earnest. Well after, like, fifty poop and fart jokes. We squirm our way through the book of JUDGES! We somehow plug Tate McRae’s leg move in Revolving door… we meet Kehlani, Demi Lovato, and Maluma occasionally. And then we earnestly discuss one of the most horrifying chunks of the Bible we’ve read so far, which after book after book of genocide is sa...
JOSHUA HAWK PUAH | Episode 6, with Buddy Keaton and Miss Benny 06.04.2025 42:26
This week on When Sodom Met Gomorrah , we've got [tech] issues girl, but you've got em too! We crack open the first book post Moses' death. That's right, from here on out, we've got a new author! And this new author has a thing for this woman, Rahab—the harlot—as well as circumcisions, sending spies into the promised land, God parting a body of water... It's kind of...
Similar podcasts
Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.