Wheel of Crime Podcast

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Jenn and Em break down the case of Ethan Crumbley, and how the tragedy led to an unprecedented trial of his parents for their role leading up to the shooting. They explore the warning signs, the investigation, and the legal fallout that reshaped conversations around responsibility and prevention. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Jenn and Em ring in the New Year on the Wheel of Crime Podcast with a deep dive into the terrifying creature known as the Manananggal, a legendary shapeshifting vampire from Philippine folklore. The ladies unpack the origins of the myth, the gruesome details of its nighttime hunts, and why this creature continues to haunt imaginations. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Jenn and Em celebrate the 2025 Wheel of Crime Christmas Special with a festive collection of listener submitted stories blending paranormal encounters and true crime. These unsettling real life events turn holiday nostalgia on its head and make you wonder what’s hiding just out of sight this Christmas. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Jenn and Em dig into the disturbing crimes of Thomas J. Grasso, including the case that led to his execution and the bizarre last meal request that made him internet infamous, and how he became the killer who can't get SpaghettiOs.  Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Em and Jenn explore the legend of the Boggy Creek Monster from Fouke, Arkansas. The ladies examine the sightings, folklore, and unsettling stories surrounding this infamous Southern cryptid. A creature that still slips through decades of retellings, leaving behind more questions than answers every time it’s seen. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail On today's episode of the Wheel of Crime, the ladies dive into one of the wildest music industry conspiracy theories. Jenn and Em unpack the bizarre claims surrounding country music icon Garth Brooks. From internet rabbit holes to fan fueled theories that refuse to die, this episode explores how a beloved superstar became the center of a viral conspiracy storm. Support the sh...

Send us Fan Mail Em and Jenn dive into the chilling Japanese urban legend of Teke-Teke. A vengeful spirit said to drag itself through train stations after being horrifically split in two. A fast moving ghost story that has haunted schoolyard whispers and internet forums for decades, proving some legends are impossible to outrun. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Jenn and Em dive into spooky true crime and paranormal stories shared on Reddit, where internet confessions and creepy encounters collide. One standout case explores the bizarre World of Warcraft murder case, where gaming obsession and real life violence collide in the most unsettling way. A collection of stories that prove the internet is a horrifying place to be.  Support the sh...

Send us Fan Mail Ahoy ye mateys! Em and Jenn set sail into one of the most famous maritime legends, the ghost ship known as the Flying Dutchman. The ladies dig into the cursed voyage lore and centuries of sailor stories that claim this doomed vessel still drifts the seas, never able to make port. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail From viral footage to shocking allegations and the extreme experiences inside, this episode uncovers the truth behind McKamey Manor and the man behind the curtain, Russ McKamey. Jenn and Em dive into why this haunting experience has become one of the most controversial activities in America. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Emily and Jenn dive into magical and powerful forest crone known in Slavic folklore as Baba Yaga. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Subject of the first Conjuring film, Jenn and Em crack into the case of the Perron Family haunting and the real Bathsheba witch.  Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Em and Jenn discuss a string of animal killings in North Carolina. The killings are thought to be done by the infamous cryptid, the Beast of Bladenboro. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast Jenn and Emily discuss Tony Todt, who follows in his father's footsteps with a family murder plot. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Em and Jenn discuss the mythical creature from Wisconsin folklore, the hodag. Is it a hoax or is it really out there?  Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Jenn and Em dive into wild listener submitted stories on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, featuring a mix of true crime experiences and paranormal encounters. From unsettling real life crimes to unexplained supernatural moments, these stories will leave you questioning what’s real long after the episode ends. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Jenn and Em discuss the folklore of the Kóoshdaa Káa. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast Jenn and Em discuss the three men who escaped the infamous Alcatraz prison in 1962.  Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Jenn and Em discuss one of Ed and Lorraine Warren's famous case, the Smurl family haunting. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Em and Jenn discuss the legend of the white ladies from various countries across the globe. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast, Jenn and Em discuss the Great Plymouth Mail Robbery, which still remains a mystery to this day. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast Em and Jenn discuss the mysterious lore of Huntingdon College's Red Lady. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast Jenn and Em discuss one of America's greatest mysteries, the plane heist of D.B. Cooper. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast Em and Jenn discuss a lesser known cryptid  known as the Flatwood Monster. Support the show

Send us Fan Mail Today on the Wheel of Crime Podcast Em and Jenn discuss the lore of the Jersey Devil. Support the show