What's Your Favorite Scary Story?

We are finally back to what this podcast is all about & covering your suggestions again! This week we're talking about America's scariest motel, the Clown Motel. And no, they're not the fun kind of clowns... This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everythi...

Welcome to our very first Halloween episode! To be festive we are covering the origin of black cat superstitions. Greatly inspired by our boy Binx. Yesterday was also Marlene's birthday so go wish her a HAPPY BIRTHDAY! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover e...

Welcome back to Marlene's second week in charge! This episode is all over the place. We talk about conspiracies, cults, and concerts! See you all next week for our very first Halloween episode. This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the pa...

This week is a little different...we are on our honeymoon so here is a pre-recorded little story of how we first met, enjoy! P.S. There's a little surprise at the end ;) This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban...

Marlene and Alyssa are finally headed to Topanga Canyon, California TO GET MARRIED!!! So naturally Alyssa found some spooky stories that took place in, you guessed it, Topanga Canyon! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal,...

We've got another ghost town for you, except this one is underwater...and that's kind of how it became a ghost town! This week we talk about all of the tragedies that happened before and after Lake Lanier was built. This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover ever...

What's the weirdest true crime you've ever heard? After listening to this episode, it's probably one of these. Check out these quirky criminals with Alyssa and Marlene! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, ali...

Heads up this week's story is super sad, but super interesting. What happened to Lady the horse and who did it? Listen to this week's episode to hear all about her crazy story. This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal,...

Better think twice before you get that cup of coffee on your way to work...this week Alyssa talks about a few haunted coffee shops and Marlene delivers another super not so fun fun fact! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the paranorma...

We could tell you guys liked the last episode we did on them, so we figured we'd do it again! This week hear all about some more Mexican urban legends, then let us know your favorite in the poll! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky......

This week we're talking about one of California's biggest tragedies...the St. Francis Dam Disaster. Which means, of course, we're talking about ghosts as well. This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urba...

This week Marlene and Alyssa go shopping for some spooky stories about some of the most haunted malls in the world! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, etc. So don't be shy and send m...

This week we take a short trip into the Hermitage Estate in Tennessee! Some not so great things happened here, which as always, resulted in quite a few ghosts. Also, Marlene treats us to some unexpected singing and asmr! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover...

This week was a fun one...Marlene and Alyssa talk all about the Jersey Devil, while maybe laughing a little too hard at who knows what. Tune in to hear about this crazy cryptid and to hear their crazy laughs! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything...

This week we have our very first 100% true crime story! We are covering the very sad story of Lauren Giddings and how she became the victim of such a terrible crime. This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban lege...

This week we hear 3 different stories from 3 different little spooky books! We'll hear about pirates, the gold rush, and of course an old asylum! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, e...

This week got a little true crimey! Check out our episode on the Greenbrier Ghost to see how the true crime and paranormal worlds collide in this sad and crazy story. This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban leg...

This week we cover every piece of fascinating history and lore of the Superstition Mountains! From disappearances to hidden treasure to aliens, this story has it all! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban leg...

This week we talk all about the terrifying legend of Slenderman, with a little surprise at the end! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, etc. So don't be shy and send me your ideas!

This week Marlene and Alyssa are back to telling the stories you suggest and this one's a good one! The Surrency family was a pretty happy, successful family...until they got straight up attacked by the most destructive poltergeist ever. Give it a listen and then if you have an idea for a story send it in so you can maybe hear it on the next episode! This podcast is all about the stories you w...

Over 300 years ago utter chaos took place in Salem, MA, where 19 people were wrongfully accused and murdered. Take a listen to this week's episode where Marlene and Alyssa go over the horrible story of the Salem Witch Trials. Alyssa also talks about her spooky experiences in Savannah, GA! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you w...

Did she do it? No one knows...and that's what makes the case of Lizzie Borden so tragically fascinating. This week Marlene and Alyssa dive into one of America's most infamous unsolved murders and talk all about the Lizzie Borden House. They will also share their own experiences they had in the house, as well as the night they shared in the Conjuring house! This podcast is all about the sto...

This week Alyssa and Marlene talk about one of the most haunted places in the world...The Conjuring House. This place has a rich, yet slightly terrifying, history that goes back thousands of years. Tune in to hear all about it! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want t...

This week Marlene takes over the podcast! Give it a listen to hear about a spooky dark sea folklore...and hear about a few cool updates! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want me to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. I want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, etc. So don&#3...

A curse, a zoo, and a Peter Griffin skinwalker..yes, all of these things are in this week's episode of What's Your Favorite Scary Story? This week Alyssa and Marlene talk about the abandoned Griffith Park Zoo in Los Angeles, California. There's also a few fun extras that you won't want to miss! This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestion...