What's Our Verdict Reviews

JJ, Mattson and Alec delve into the cultural and cinematic impact of 'The Matrix', released on March 31, 1999, which coincidentally marks the 18th birthday of JJ. The hosts engage in a vibrant discussion, reflecting on their first experiences with the film and how it shaped their understanding of cinema. They explore themes of reality versus illusion, drawing parallels to contemporary discussions...

Alec, Mattson and JJ dive into a detailed discussion of Quentin Tarantino's film "Inglourious Basterds," exploring its unique blend of historical fiction and dark humor. The hosts debate the film's pacing, particularly its middle section, which some feel could benefit from tighter editing. They highlight the standout performances of Christoph Waltz and Brad Pitt, emphasizing how their characters d...

Mattson, Alec and JJ dive deep into the film "Get Out," exploring its unique blend of horror and social commentary. They engage in a lively debate about the film's effectiveness, with one expressing a strong appreciation for its suspenseful storytelling and unexpected twists. In contrast, another host critiques the pacing and execution, arguing that it fails to maintain suspense and ultimately lea...

The Lighthouse is the focus of today's discussion, with hosts J.J., Mattson, and Alec diving deep into its unsettling themes and unique storytelling. They explore the dynamics between the two lighthouse keepers, played by Robert Pattinson and Willem Dafoe, as they grapple with isolation and insanity on a remote island in the 1890s. The conversation highlights how the film's ambiguous ending leaves...

Mattson, Alec and JJ dive into the heartwarming and whimsical animated film "Klaus," which explores the transformative power of kindness and community spirit. The hosts discuss how this unique take on the Santa Claus origin story resonates beyond the holiday season, emphasizing the idea that simple acts of kindness can spark a chain reaction of goodwill. They share personal anecdotes about their e...

The podcast dives into a critical review of the animated film "The Polar Express," highlighting the disjointed storytelling and questionable animation choices that left the hosts underwhelmed. JJ expresses his skepticism about the film's ability to convey the essence of Christmas, suggesting it feels more like a commercialized product than a heartfelt story. Mattson and Alec add their insights, wi...

JJ, Mattson and Alec dive into a critical discussion of the 1996 holiday film "Jingle All the Way," highlighting its shortcomings and the reasons why it has garnered a negative reception. The hosts express their disdain for the movie, with one even giving it a score of 0.5, citing its over-the-top performances and lack of a compelling message about Christmas. They reflect on the absurdity of the p...

Alec, JJ and Mattson dive into a spirited discussion about the classic holiday film, "A Christmas Story," which has long been a staple of Christmas viewing for many families. While Matson shares fond memories of watching the film every Christmas Eve, JJ and Alec express their disdain for it. The conversation explores the reasons behind their strong feelings, including JJ's criticism of the film's...

JJ and Alec dive into a lively discussion about the classic holiday film, National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation, highlighting the comedic elements that make it a beloved staple for many during the holiday season. They reflect on the character of Clark Griswold, played by Chevy Chase, emphasizing his relentless pursuit of a perfect family Christmas amidst a series of absurd mishaps. One host shares...

A lively debate unfolds as J.J., Matson, and Alec dissect the beloved classic comedy, Happy Gilmore. The trio delves into the film's cultural impact, exploring how it resonated with audiences since its release in 1996. J.J. passionately recounts his personal connection to the movie, narrating how it sparked his interest in golf and became a staple in his comedic repertoire. As they navigate throug...

Join us as we dive into a lively discussion about the comedy classic "Dodgeball: A True Underdog Story." The conversation highlights the film's unique blend of outrageous humor and memorable characters, with hosts sharing their personal experiences and opinions on its impact since its release in 2004. Despite mixed feelings about Ben Stiller's performance, the hosts can't help but appreciate the c...

Exploration of cinematic nostalgia takes center stage as J.J., Mattson, and Alec dive into the world of comedy with a focus on the cult classic Tropic Thunder. The hosts reflect on their experiences with movies in a pre-streaming era, where trips to Blockbuster meant coming home with a selection of films that would guide their entertainment choices. The conversation leads to a deeper examination o...

The podcast takes a deep dive into the timeless comedy 'Tommy Boy', exploring its cultural significance and the unforgettable performances of Chris Farley and David Spade. The hosts passionately discuss the film's evolution from a box office underperformer to a cult classic, largely due to Farley’s magnetic screen presence and his unique brand of humor. They dissect the film’s most iconic scenes a...

The hosts dive into a humorous and critical discussion about the horror sequel "Children of the Corn II: The Final Sacrifice," highlighting its lack of genuine scares and overall poor execution. They reflect on their childhood memories of the film, contrasting how their perceptions of horror have changed over time. The conversation touches on the film's absurd moments, such as unrealistic death sc...

Exploring nostalgia and childhood memories, the podcast dives into the classic film 'The Monster Squad,' a beloved 1987 movie that blends humor and horror through the lens of childhood adventure. The hosts reflect on their personal connections to the film, sharing anecdotes about their own experiences with tree houses, sleepovers, and the influence that this cult classic had on their formative yea...

Join us as we dive into the nostalgic world of "Ernest Scared Stupid," a beloved Halloween classic that blends humor and mild horror. The hosts reflect on their childhood memories associated with the film, discussing how it shaped their perceptions of scary movies and the unique charm of Jim Varney's performance as Ernest. While JJ revels in the film's comedic elements and heartfelt nostalgia, Mat...

The podcast dives into the world of British humor through the lens of the cult classic film, Shaun of the Dead. The hosts, JJ Crowder, Mattson Heiner, and Alec Burgess, engage in a lively discussion surrounding the film's impact, its unique blend of comedy and horror, and its place within the beloved Cornetto Trilogy. They explore the film's storyline, which follows the aimless lives of Shaun and...

A retired master car thief must come back to the industry and steal fifty cars with his crew in one night to save his brother's life. JJ finds himself feeling old again. Mattson admits this could have been his pick. Alec just has a good time. Support us: https://www.patreon.com/whatsourverdict Email us: hosts@whatsourverdict.com Follow us: Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/whatsourverdict Twitter...

Movie star Nick Cage is channeling his iconic characters as he's caught between a superfan and a CIA agent. Mattson thinks Cage should stick to this kind of film. Alec is let down by expectations. JJ gushes and quotes. Support us: https://www.patreon.com/whatsourverdict Email us: hosts@whatsourverdict.com Follow us: Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/whatsourverdict Twitter: @whatsourverdict Insta...

After a personal visit by God himself, the eccentric construction worker Gary Faulkner takes the decision to embark on an adventure in the badlands of Pakistan to bring Al-Qaeda's leader Osama Bin Laden to justice. Mattson declares his displeasure. Alec admits to his randomness. JJ is disappointed in his pleasure. Support us: https://www.patreon.com/whatsourverdict Email us: hosts@whatsourverdict....

Newly-paroled ex-con and former U.S. Ranger Cameron Poe finds himself trapped in a prisoner-transport plane when the passengers seize control. JJ is on the ropes with this one. Mattson doubles down on the torture. Alec, well Alec is just Alec on this one. Support us: https://www.patreon.com/whatsourverdict Email us: hosts@whatsourverdict.com Follow us: Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/whatsourve...

When a childless couple--an ex-con and an ex-cop--decide to help themselves to one of another family's quintuplets, their lives become more complicated than they anticipated. Mattson questions JJ's taste...again. Alec feels personally attacked. JJ gushes over some scenes. Support us: https://www.patreon.com/whatsourverdict Email us: hosts@whatsourverdict.com Follow us: Facebook: https://www.facebo...

Mel Brooks brings his one-of-a-kind comic touch to the history of mankind covering events from the Old Testament to the French Revolution in a series of episodic comedy vignettes. Mattson makes a shocking confession. Alec works through the surprise to bring the funny. Support us: https://www.patreon.com/whatsourverdict Email us: hosts@whatsourverdict.com Follow us: Facebook: https://www.facebook.c...

A psychiatrist with intense acrophobia (fear of heights) goes to work for a mental institution run by doctors who appear to be crazier than their patients, and have secrets that they are willing to commit murder to keep. Mattson can't do it with this one. Alec imitates JJ. Support us: https://www.patreon.com/whatsourverdict Email us: hosts@whatsourverdict.com Follow us: Facebook: https://www.faceb...

A star-pilot for hire and his trusty sidekick must come to the rescue of a princess and save Planet Druidia from the clutches of the evil Spaceballs. Mattson wonders what true Star Wars fan would think of Spaceballs. Alec can't help but love the funny no matter how stupid it is. Support us: https://www.patreon.com/whatsourverdict Email us: hosts@whatsourverdict.com Follow us: Facebook: https://www...