What Do You Think of This?!

Was it gritty? Romantic? Over-the-top? All of the above? This week, Jeff and Josue don their cloaks and revisit Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves (1991)—a movie filled with slow ballads, moody forests, and heroic mullets. From Alan Rickman’s legendary camp villainy to Kevin Costner’s non-existent accent, this film walks a tightrope between epic and absurd, and we’re here for every muddy, melodramatic...

A thief, a hero… or just two millennials playing ridiculous games? This week’s mini-sode is packed with music, mayhem, and a few well-aimed shots at nostalgia. Jeff and Josue put their wits to the test in three daring challenges, each tied to next week’s epic tale of adventure. Will they hit the mark, or will they fall into the traps of their own making? And because we can’t resist sneaking in som...

The quack is back! This week, Jeff and Josue revisit Disney’s  D2: The Mighty Ducks  to find out whether this beloved sequel still skates circles around our nostalgia—or if our memories have been icing the truth. Join us as we break down the over‑the‑top hockey hijinks, unforgettable (sometimes baffling) plot points, and all the knuckle pucks in between. Plus, don’t miss our brand‑new “Would You R...

It’s WDYT?! MINI'SODE time, and we’ve got a fun challenge that’s totally off the rails—guessing hockey penalty signals based on our outlandish descriptions! Join us as we put Josue to the test, then gear up for next week’s nostalgic rewatch of a Disney Hockey Classic. Of course, we couldn’t just announce it normally; we also share a Goofy-inspired “rulebook” reading you’ll have to hear to beli...

We had an extra week to prepare, and today we’re READY to dive into one of our most epic reviews yet! In this episode, Jeff and Josue revisit the 2002 movie adaptation of Alexandre Dumas’ classic historical fiction,  The Count of Monte Cristo . Join us as we explore a timeless tale of betrayal, revenge, and redemption—complete with unexpected twists and unforgettable characters. Before we get star...

We had a little video glitch this week (long story), but maybe it’s fate nudging us to try shorter “mini'sodes.” So here’s a bite-sized treat: a sandwich-themed quiz—can you guess which creations are real Monte Cristos?—plus a dramatic trailer reading for our upcoming full episode on  The Count of Monte Cristo.  Consider this a fun teaser for what’s to come! Would you rather see more short episode...

This  Test Kitchen  episode might just be our  most chaotic yet —because when  shrimp happens, things get weird!  🦐🍔 Inspired by  Forrest Gump, The Lion King, and more,  we take on  some of the wildest movie-inspired foods ever —including a  pancake burger loaded with bacon, shrimp, and hot sauce!  😱 🔥  What’s on the menu? 🍤  Bubba-Gump Shrimp Skewers  ( Forrest Gump ) 🐛  Grub-Like Gummy Wor...

Valentine’s Day is here, but don’t worry if you’re feeling cynical—we’ve got enough rom-com ridiculousness for everyone. First, we vent our  pet peeves  and quiz each other on  famous couples , then dive headfirst into the star-studded “America’s Sweethearts” to see if this early-2000s flick still deserves a spot in our hearts. Think you know love? This episode might make you think again. From sca...

Bust out the good headphones! We’re throwing it back to the ’90s with an album that shaped Jeff’s early drumming days and left a big mark on Christian rock. Join us as we dive into  bloOm  by Audio Adrenaline—exploring its standout tracks, production style, and nostalgic charm. Will Josue be on board with the band’s sound, or is this all about recapturing youth group memories? But first, we quiz J...

Rise and shine, podcasters, and don’t forget your booties—because we’re heading to Punxsutawney! In this episode, Jeff and Josue revisit  Groundhog Day  (the ultimate wintertime time-loop classic) to see if it still warms the heart or leaves us stuck in place. But first, our  iconic-animals quiz  brings a dash of wildlife fun, plus we explore the mystery of déjà vu—how does it really happen? Is  G...

This time, we’re journeying to Pride Rock to see if  The Lion King  still roars loud in our hearts—or if it’s just nostalgia purring away. First up, though, Josue flips the tables on Jeff with an  animal-sound quiz  inspired by the Pride Lands (spoiler: you’ve got a good shot at winning). Then, we explore voice acting vs. singing, debate Hans Zimmer  and  Elton John’s contributions, and debate how...

In this episode, we hop in a time machine bound for the 1960s and follow The O-needers (or is it The Wonders?) on their rise to stardom in  That Thing You Do . But first, get ready for an epic drum-intro quiz—see if you can guess these iconic beats faster than Josue! We also share the latest on neighborhood shenanigans, questionable Sonic-a-verse physics, and how well this movie holds up in modern...

In this Season 2 kickoff, we’re revisiting one of Josue’s all-time favorites: Forrest Gump.  Before diving into cross-country runs and a box of chocolates, we chat about gluttonous backyard squirrels—yes, really—and quiz each other on Gump-inspired metaphors. It’s a lighthearted start to a jam-packed discussion of what makes this iconic film so memorable. Does Forrest Gump still hold up, or is it...

It’s a new year—and we’re on the cusp of Season Two of “What Do You Think [of This]?!” (dropping January 9th). Before we dive into a fresh batch of nostalgia, we’re re-releasing this special treasure from Season One: a hilarious video review of the 1985 classic  Alice in Wonderland . This bonus episode is extra special with our first in-studio guest, Jeff’s brother Jimmy (a.k.a. ‘Second Desk’), wh...

Christmas has come and gone, but we hope you’re still feeling merry! As we work hard in our podcast workshop getting ready for Season Two (dropping January 9th), we’re treating you to something extra special—a BONUS re‑release of one of our favorite Season One episodes, now with never‑before‑seen video footage and a few AI‑inspired twists. Whether you’re a die‑hard fan of  The Godfather  or just l...

We might be on a break (a Rachel break, not a Ross break!), but as we gear up for Season Two (dropping January 9th), we’ve got something extra special for you. For the next three weeks, we’re re‑releasing some of our favorite episodes with never‑before‑seen video footage! In this BONUS episode, we revisit our 12th installment where Jeff introduced Josue to the timeless music of Frank Sinatra, expl...

It’s our Season 1 finale of “What Do You Think [of This]?!” and the stakes have never been higher. We’re pitting nostalgia against nostalgia in a bracket as ridiculous as it is epic. We’re looking back through everything we’ve consumed since Episode 1 and making the final decision: Who truly comes out on top, and what pure nostalgia gets left on the cutting room floor? After you listen, scroll to...

We’re diving headfirst into holiday mode! After a week spent soaking up Bing Crosby’s timeless tunes, we’re celebrating with a nostalgia-infused holiday classic— White Christmas . There’s singing, dancing, and plenty of festive cheer—but is there really any snow? We all agree there should be, right? Before you settle in, test your holiday knowledge with our Christmas quiz—can you beat Josue’s scor...

Happy Turkey Day! The gates to the holiday season are open, and we’ve got a cornucopia full of nostalgic suggestions that may or may not hit the mark. In this episode, we start with a quick look at the animated Peanuts classic  A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving.  Then, Jeff introduces Josue (and you) to the first Christmas vinyl you should spin—courtesy of Bing Crosby’s timeless classics—along with som...

Extra, Extra! 🗞️ We hope you finished that giant turkey leg from last week because today’s headline announces our first nostalgic musical review:  Newsies ! In this episode, Jeff and Josue dive into the world of musicals as they revisit a show that comes straight from Josue’s past—and he’s convinced we’re all going to love it. But before we get into the musical magic, Jeff leads us through our ina...

It’s time for another  Test Kitchen , and this one is a  nostalgic feast fit for a Don!  We’re recreating the most legendary movie-inspired dishes—some fancy, some bizarre, and some that might just get you “made” in the mafia. 🕵️‍♂️ 🔥  On the menu: 🍰  Looking Glass Land Cake  ( Alice Through the Looking Glass ) 🍬  Candy Showdown: Reese’s Pieces vs. M&Ms  ( E.T. & Beyond! ) 🍗  Giant Tur...

Today we look to the stars—but not before we clean the lasagna out of the litter box! We’re serving up two nostalgic throwbacks in one episode: a short animated special featuring Garfield’s very first trick‑or‑treat adventure (with a side of candy, candy, candy 🍬🍭) and a revisit of the Steven Spielberg and John Williams classic,  E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial  👽. Which is the iconic classic and wh...

Hidey-ho! It’s Halloween, and things are getting a little spooky around here. Jeff’s experience with creepy movies is pretty limited, so Josue thought it was the perfect time to take a plunge into nostalgic horror with the iconic 80’s film  Child’s Play —starring the one and only Chucky, “your friend 'til the end.” We kick things off with a fun quiz where Jeff flexes his newfound knowledge abo...

We’re nearing the end of October, and that means the podcast is getting a little creepier… and a whole lot kookier. In this episode, we dive into 1993’s  Addams Family Values —where dark humor meets unexpected romance, and even a bit of sensuality sneaks in. Before we get into it, we kick things off with a fun quiz on TV show tunes. Play along and see if you can guess the answers before Josue does...

This week we welcome a very special guest in the studio—Jeff’s brother Jimmy (aka “Second Desk”), our resident Wonderland expert. In this episode, we take a wild ride down the rabbit hole as we dive into Part 2 of our nostalgic journey through  Alice in Wonderland  (1985). Don’t worry if you missed Part 1…so did we, initially! But now the story gets curiouser and curiouser, and we uncover layers o...