Mike Witmer Jeff Quake and Brian Appleby

Underachievers Podcast

Comedy EN ↓ 313 episodes

Welcome to the Underachievers Podcast! A roundtable podcast hosted by three friends; Mike Witmer, Jeff Quake and Brian Appleby trying to figure this whole life thing out. On a normal basis you will hear us talk about anything from our own lives that week, to reviews and critiques, from tv and movies to even some music. We even pepper in a little sports talk here and there. You never know what random tangent the guys will go down each episode. So, what are you waiting for? Come along and listen as these guys try to figure out how a podcast is done!

Author

Mike Witmer Jeff Quake and Brian Appleby

Category

Comedy

Latest episode

Jul 6, 2026

Where to listen?

Podcasts in the app Replaio Radio Coming soon

Podcasts are coming to the app soon. Install now and be the first to see a whole new take on podcasts

Get it on Google Play Install for free Android 5M+ downloads · 4.8 rating iOS soon

Episodes

Stories On A Monday 22.09.2025

The guys are back with episode #183 of our Underachievers Podcast series! We're without Brian this week, but the show goes on. Today's episode is a story-heavy one. First, we go to Jeff when he shares how he accidentally shaved off his beard and celebrated his three-year wedding anniversary. Next, Witmer retells his weekend celebrating his brother's bachelor party in Atlantic City. Lastly, Jeff sh...

Best All-Time Moments: 14 15.09.2025

Unfortunately, the guys are off this week from our Underachievers Podcast series! However, we've got you covered with another best all-time moment. We have four highlights for this one. Starting it off, we go to the time Brian talks about how genuine happiness has changed. Next, we get to a question of the hour: What is our go-to comfort food? Later on, we have more questions when Brian has three...

Best All-Time Moments: 13 01.09.2025

Unfortunately, the guys are off this week from our Underachievers Podcast series. However, we've got you covered with another best all-time moments! These four highlights come from early 2023. First, we go to the time Witmer asks Jeff if he would drink a 20-day-old beer. Next, we go to the time Brian shares how he accidentally spent $300 on shots and had to leave his car to get home. Later on, we...

The Highest Part of Your Week 18.08.2025

The guys are back with episode #182 of our Underachievers Podcast series! We're without Brian, but the show goes on. Starting it off, the guys talk about how they recently got together with Brian over the weekend. From Jeff's housewarming party to having a chill guys day at Witmer's pool. Later on, the guys have a question of the hour segment on whether it is harder to win 20 games in a row in the...

A Nice Summer Break 11.08.2025

The guys are back with episode #181 of our Underachievers Podcast series! We're without Brian, but the show goes on. Starting it off, Witmer shares how his recent staycation was, from visiting Hersheypark to hanging poolside. Later on, Jeff shares how getting the guys back together went at Tommy and Megan's Lake house. Jeff also talks about his recent trip to Ocean City, Maryland, with his wife. C...

Best All-Time Moments: 12 28.07.2025

Unfortunately, the guys are off this week from our Underachievers Podcast series. However, we've got you covered with another best all-time moments. All four of these highlights come from mid-to-late 2022. First, we go to the time Witmer has a few questions from our question of the hour segment, the main one being, would the guys give up their seats on an airplane for 10k? Next, we go to a random...

Same Faces, New Spaces 14.07.2025

The guys are back with episode #180 of our Underachievers Podcast series! We're without Brian, but the show goes on. In this one, we're mainly catching up on where we've been the past few weeks. Starting it off, Witmer shares how he recently went back out to Pittsburgh to hit Maggie's Farm again, his new office space, and more. Later on, Jeff shares his pretty uneventful past couple of weeks and a...

Best All-Time Moments: 11 07.07.2025

Unfortunately, the guys are off this week from our Underachievers Podcast series. However, we've got you covered with another best all-time moments. These highlights coming from 2022. Starting it off, we go to the time the guys had a random tangent on ice. This discussion on whether ice really does that much when dealing with an injury. Next, we go to the time Witmer shares how he managed to lose...

The Heat is Brutal 24.06.2025

The guys are back with episode #179 of our Underachievers Podcast series! We're without Brian, but the show goes on. Starting it off, Witmer shares how his podcasting location is going to change, going out to Pittsburgh again and more. Next, Jeff recaps his time at a recent Philadelphia Phillies game with an old friend, which gets the guys down a tangent on guys and friendships. Lastly, the guys h...

Best All-Time Moments: 10 16.06.2025

Unfortunately, the guys are off this week from our Underachievers Podcast series. However, we've got you covered with another best all-time moments. These three highlights coming from the end of 2021. Starting it off, we go to the time, the guys had a random tangent on haunted houses and other similar haunts during the Halloween season. Next, we go to another tangent, Witmer and Brian had on kid's...

We Haven't Skipped A Beat 09.06.2025

The guys are back with episode #178 of our Underachievers Podcast series! We're without Brian, but the show goes on. Starting it off, Witmer and Jeff have a mini hockey discussion, and the shirseys Jeff still owes Witmer. Next, Witmer shares what he's been up to lately. From going out to Pittsburgh to celebrate his niece's birthday, to seeing his brother's newly bought home. Later on, Jeff shares...

Best All-Time Moments: 9 26.05.2025

Unfortunately, the guys are off this week for Memorial Day. However, we've got you covered with another best all-time moments. For this one, we are looking at highlights from mid-2021. Starting it off, the guys have a random tangent on karaoke, and the likelihood they would actually go up and sing. Next, Witmer shares how he is still recovering from a recent weekend hanging with the guys. This get...

Best All-Time Moments: 8 12.05.2025

Unfortunately, the guys are off this week. However, we've got you covered with another best all-time moments! We've got four highlights for this one, all date to mid-2021. First, we go to the time the guys filled out a meme post about how much of a dad we were. Next, we go to the time the guys got together at Brian's for one of the first times after the Covid shutdown. Later on, the guys reminisce...

Best All-Time Moments: 7 05.05.2025

Unfortunately, the guys are off this week from our Underachievers Podcast series. However, we've got you covered with another best-all time moments! These three moments coming from early 2021. Starting it off, we go to the time Jeff and Brian share, meeting up with the guys down in Virginia. One of the first times, they all got together after the covid shutdown. Next, we go to the time the guys di...

The Weekend of Jeff 28.04.2025

The guys are back with episode #177 of our Underachievers Podcast series! We're without Brian, but the show goes on. Starting it off, Jeff shares how he celebrated Easter with his and his wife's family. Next, Jeff talks about his birthday, how his family celebrated, what he did with his wife and more. Later on, we discuss how Jeff's wife managed to surprise him with all the guys getting together a...

We're Not Tanking This One 14.04.2025

The guys are back with episode #176 of our Underachievers Podcast series! We're without Brian, but the show goes on. Starting it off, Witmer talks about getting breakfast with his dad. Next, Jeff shares how he managed to get sick over the weekend. The remainder of the episode is the guys having a long tangent on tanking in sports. Come along and hear how the guys are doing this week! Want more fro...

We Haven't Gone Anywhere 08.04.2025

After a month and a half, the guys are back with episode #175 of our Underachievers Podcast series! We're without Brian, but the show goes on. Starting it off, Jeff shares how he and his wife recently bought a home. He also talks about how he managed to get a concussion. Next, Witmer shares how he accidentally sliced open his fingers while trying to open a can, celebrating his dad's birthday and m...

Best All-Time Moments: 6 31.03.2025

Unfortunately, the guys are off this week from our Underachievers Podcast series. However, we've got you covered with another best all-time moments. For this one, we're looking at the end of 2020. First, we go to the time the guys debated candy corn and why people would like the waxy candy. Next, go to the time Brian shared how he got towed while at a Super Bowl parade. Later on, we have another s...

Best All-Time Moments: 5 24.03.2025

Unfortunately, the guys are off this week from their Underachievers Podcast series. However, we've got you covered with another installment of our best all-time moments. These moments go back to mid-2020. Starting it off, we go back to the time Brian shares how his rough weekend in Wildwood, NJ was during Labor Day. Next, Brian and Jeff share the time they got together with Matt, Tommy and Tommy's...

Best All-Time Moments: 4 10.03.2025

Unfortunately, the guys are off this week from our Underachievers Podcast series. However, we've got you covered, with another best all-time moments. We have three highlights, from 2020. Starting with the time, we first welcomed Matt Bevenour to the podcast. When the guys recap their game of mini golf and the rough use of their Mulligan. Next, we go to our first timeless debates segment. When Witm...

Best All-Time Moments: 3 03.03.2025

Unfortunately, the guys are off this week from our Underachievers Podcast series. However, we've got you covered with  the third installment of our best all-time moments. Starting it off, we go to the time Brian has some bone picking with Jeff over a snap, Jeff didn't send to Brian. Next, we go to the time Brian watched a flat earth documentary and got triggered hard, and the guys' thoughts on the...

Best All-Time Moments: 2 24.02.2025

Unfortunately, the guys are off this week from our Underachievers Podcast series. However, we've got you covered with our second highlight series of our best-all time moments. For this one, in particular, we're throwing it back to mid-2020, with three moments. First, Brian shares a story of how he accidentally tried cooking eggs with the power out, which gets the guys talking about other embarrass...

A Podcast Worth Celebrating 17.02.2025

The guys are back with episode #174 of our Underachievers Podcast series! We're without Brian this week, but the show goes on. Starting it off, Witmer and Jeff celebrate the Philadelphia Eagles winning the Super Bowl. Next, Jeff shares what he's been up to, from celebrating his wife's birthday to wear he ended up watching the Super Bowl from. Next, Witmer discusses his troubles with getting pretze...

Let's Talk About the Super Bowl 03.02.2025

The guys are back with episode #173 of our Underachievers Podcast series! We're without Brian this week, but the show goes on. The Super Bowl is a heavy focus on this episode. Starting it off, Jeff shares his weekend outing celebrating a co-worker's birthday, which ended up being kinda awkward. Next, Witmer shares how he recently got breakfast with his dad. Later on, the guys talk Super Bowl. Firs...

Snow Days and Sports 27.01.2025

The guys are back with episode #172 of our Underachievers Podcast series. We're without Brian this week, but the show goes on. Starting it off, Jeff shares how he recently met up with, frequent guest host Tommy Fitzgerald, the other weekend. Next, Witmer and Jeff have a tangent on snow days and reminiscing days of their childhoods and getting the day off school. Lastly, the two share if sports all...

Listen to the Underachievers Podcast podcast in Replaio

Radio and podcasts in one app - free, with no sign-up. Install today and do not miss the launch

Get it on Google Play

Replaio is not a podcast publisher; show names, artwork and audio belong to their authors and are distributed through public RSS feeds.