Two Girls One Ghost

Tucked away in a tiny Indiana town, the Rhodes Hotel has lived many lives since 1893. What began as a glamorous Victorian inn during the gas boom era transformed into a brothel and speakeasy when times got tough. These days, it’s known for something much darker. Guests report footsteps in empty halls, full conversations with no one there, shadow figures lingering just out of sight, and the unmista...

Connection doesn’t end with death, and some relationships begin before you even meet… We’re sharing listener stories of loved ones reaching through the vale and across time and space, through signs, dream visits, and unexplainable moments. Sometimes in beautiful ways and sometimes in ways that are a little more eerie than comforting. A listener spent years adventuring in vivid dreams with a myster...

What if a ghost could text back… but only through Polaroids? This is the unforgettable case of the “Polaroid Ghost.” We follow two artists living in a quiet Los Angeles neighborhood who suddenly find themselves documenting a presence that doesn’t just show up on camera, but answers questions, spells out its name, and hints at secrets hidden on the property. We get into the psychics, the skeptics,...

Grab your peanuts & cracker jacks because we’re reading listener stories all about sports superstitions and paranormal encounters. We might not know that much about sports, but we do know a thing or two about spirits. When you combine high stakes games, roaring crowds, and deeply rooted rituals, it’s no surprise a few spirits make an appearance. Stories include: Baseball players from a child’s wal...

Meet Madame Vesta La Viesta, a trailblazing mystic and self-proclaimed astral traveler who fascinated early 20th-century New York City with her cosmic adventures and spiritual teachings. As a star instructor at Harlem’s Occult School of Science, she claimed her spirit could leave her body and explore distant planets. Her otherworldly encounters included extraterrestrial beings, soul-mated couples,...

We’re packing our bags for a spooky girls’ trip episode where the only itinerary is haunted vibes, chaotic energy, and paranormal encounters that seem to happen whenever the girls get together. In this episode we read listener stories about bachelorette parties, road trips, and weekend getaways that took a turn into the supernatural. Ghost photobombs, objects moving on their own, possible UFO sigh...

**Content Warning: This episode contains discussions of homicides, suicide and torture** This week we’re back in spooky Appalachia to explore a haunted attraction that might be a little too real. Sitting on 20 acres of a former Tennessee plantation is Frightmare Manor. The haunt’s story centers on Jeremiah Lexer, the former plantation owner who was secretly a serial killer, the shocking 1902 axe m...

Across countries and childhood bedrooms, a tall shadow in a top hat appears to watch, threaten, protect, or possibly feed. This is one of the most infamous figures in paranormal lore: the Hat Man. Throughout the listener encounters we share, patterns emerge. He thrives in sleep paralysis. He appears during trauma. He lingers near children…Sleep tight. Listener Stories Include: A listener in Brazil...

This week we take you to South Pass City, Wyoming, a gold rush boomtown turned ghost town where trailblazing women and lingering spirits share the same dusty streets. In honor of Women’s History Month, we dive into the wild story of how a rough and rowdy mining town helped spark women’s suffrage, introduced the first female justice of the peace, was home to Wyoming’s first female serial killer, an...

We’re wandering through the cemetery gates, and the spirits absolutely showed up. In this Encounters episode, we’re getting into listener stories all about cemetery experiences: historic graveyards, extra bodies, water logged brains, phantom smells and a smorgasbord of spirits and apparitions. And what’s a graveyard episode without a little late night Ouija action? Stories include: A listener unco...

This week, we’re creeping around the corners of Reddit to unpack some of the most chilling and convincing paranormal evidence the internet has to offer. After scouring countless threads, we’re playing some of the most astounding EVPs and videos we’ve ever discovered. From an infamous Gettysburg ghost soldiers video, and a possibly demonic EVP to terrifying recordings from the Sallie House… This ep...

No matter how hard we try, we can’t get enough of your haunted stories from Appalachia. We’re diving back into that familiar Appalachian unease… voices in the woods, figures that don’t feel quite human, and uncanny moments in the mountains where mimics, trickster fae and a smattering of local cryptids seem to know your name, your voice, and exactly how to lure you off the trail. Stories include: A...

We’re heading into the remote wilderness of Portlock, Alaska—an abandoned village with a truly terrifying reputation. In this episode, we dig into the legend of the Nantinaq, a towering, violent Bigfoot said to stalk the mountains, terrorize residents, and possibly drive an entire community to flee. Echoing screams in the night, unexplained disappearances, and grisly historical accounts haunt this...

This week’s Encounters episode is a full-on paranormal kitchen sink episode. Anything goes as we dive into listener stories of glitchy realities, accidental séances, demonic laughter, doppelgängers, and near-death visions. Oh, and our podcast may have helped save one listener’s life during an ER visit. Stories include: An old house where an entity throws objects, fills rooms with laughter, and app...

We’re diving into the incredible story of Madam C.J. Walker, a woman who overcame unimaginable adversity to become America’s first self-made female millionaire and build a legacy that is still alive today. From her groundbreaking impact on Black entrepreneurship to the creation of the iconic Walker Theatre in Indianapolis, we explore how her vision, resilience, and determination helped create oppo...

Have you ever been mistaken for someone else? Or seen your roommate at home when they were actually at work? We’re digging into stories of doppelgängers, mimics, and familiar faces doing deeply unsettling things. Small moments of confusion escalate into full-on paranormal experiences, and just when you think it can’t get weirder, we wrap things up by examining photos listeners sent in of Corinne’s...

Lake Lanier looks like the perfect summer escape—but beneath the surface, something is very, very wrong. In this episode, we revisit one of the most haunted and deadly lakes in America, where swimmers report invisible hands pulling them under, boats flip without warning, and an entire town sits frozen beneath the water.  We first covered Lake Lanier nearly five years ago, focusing on the paranorma...

Love takes a paranormal turn this episode as we share listener stories filled with soul ties, eerie signs, and connections that cross realms. We’re talking twin flames, invisible strings, ghostly visits, and moments that feel way too perfectly timed to be coincidence. Stories include: A hauntingly beautiful twin flame connection with an antique shop owner whose presence continues well after death...

This is a very special Anti-Valentine’s Day episode. Sabrina, joined by Meredith from the Rattled & Shook podcast, spent the night inside the infamous Room 311 at the Read House Hotel in Chattanooga, Tennessee. Built on land marked by tragedy and violence, the Read House is known for its glamorous historic guests—and its long, unsettling history of paranormal activity. We dive into the hotel’s pas...

We love paranormal games almost as much as we fear them, and our listeners have plenty of examples as to why. We’re sharing stories of homemade Ouija boards, late night rituals that tempt the spirits, and “harmless” sleepover games that spiral wildly out of control, because some games don’t end when you think they do.  Stories include: A Queen of Spades ritual that results in a terrifying mirror a...

We’re unpacking one of the most infamous paranormal conspiracies in U.S. history: the Philadelphia Experiment. During World War II, the Navy allegedly attempted to make a warship invisible—and instead triggered something terrifying. After a flash of green light, possible time travel and teleportation, the sailors who survived returned mentally shattered and physically disfigured. Serving as a chil...

This week, we’re traveling across Asia and diving into some of the most unsettling paranormal experiences we’ve ever heard. Our listeners share spine-chilling stories rooted in cultural folklore and lived terror—tales of spirits who predict the future, impersonate loved ones, and inflict physical harm. Between the laughter, the disbelief, and the full-body chills, this episode reminded us why some...

What’s stranger than Stranger Things? The story that inspired the show — an alleged government program called the Montauk Project. This week, we’re putting on our tinfoil hats and diving into the conspiracy that claims a quiet Long Island military base was the site of secret experiments involving psychics, mind control, time travel, and something that may have torn a hole in reality itself. Betwee...

You wake up, but you can’t move. Your chest feels heavy, your voice won’t work, and there’s a sense that you’re not alone. Sleep paralysis, for many of our listeners, is where their most unsettling experiences begin. Stories include: A listener who repeatedly wakes during paralysis contorted into impossible positions, as if something has physically moved them A couple whose sleep experiences begin...

We’re heading deep into the Appalachian Mountains to uncover the Cherokee legend of the Nvnehi, immortal beings not bound by time or space, who live inside the mountains, under rivers, and just outside our perception.  Rumors of phantom music in the woods, hidden underground towns, invisible warriors, and people who slip in and out of our world have long haunted the region. These aren’t ghosts or...