Total Conundrum

Episode Description: In the quiet town of Medford, New York, 21-year-old Sarah Goode was a devoted young mother, full of laughter, promise, and love. When she disappeared after a night out in June of 2014, her friends and family knew something was wrong. What followed was a desperate search, a devastating discovery, and a heartbreaking trial that would expose a predator hiding in plain sight. In t...

Episode Description: Deep in the ancient canals of Xochimilco, Mexico, lies a place unlike any other. Trees filled with hundreds—if not thousands—of decaying, glassy-eyed dolls sway in the breeze. Their cracked faces stare into nothing… or maybe right into your soul. This isn’t the set of a horror film. It’s real. And the story behind it is even more disturbing. In this episode of Total Conundrum,...

Episode Description: You’ve heard of Spider-Man—but this isn’t a story about a hero. This is the disturbing true tale of Theodore Edward Coneys, a man who became known as “The Denver Spiderman” after committing a grisly murder and secretly living in his victim’s attic for months without detection. Why did he do it? How did no one know he was there? And how did this urban legend come to life in 194...

Episode Description: Step inside the decaying halls of Waverly Hills Sanatorium, one of the most infamous haunted locations in America. From its origins as a state-of-the-art tuberculosis hospital to the dark urban legends that grew after its closure, Waverly Hills has a history steeped in suffering, death, and mystery. What really went on inside those walls? Are the spirits of former patients sti...

Harold Shipman: The Doctor of Death Episode Description: He took an oath to heal—but instead, he became one of the most prolific serial killers in history. In this chilling episode, we explore the life and crimes of Dr. Harold Shipman, a trusted family physician who used his position to silently murder over 200 patients. How did he get away with it for so long? What drove him to commit such calcul...

The Haunting of Trevena Castle Episode Description: A castle on the edge of the sea… a family desperate for peace… and a darkness that refused to stay buried. In this chilling episode, we unravel the true haunting of Trevena Castle, where explorer Thomas Graves hoped to restore a gothic ruin—but instead unleashed a storm of demonic possession, ghostly apparitions, and supernatural chaos. What secr...

Episode Description: Step into the chilling mind of one of America’s most notorious serial killers—Jeffrey Dahmer. A man whose gruesome crimes shocked the world, Dahmer lured victims into his apartment, where he carried out unspeakable horrors. How did he evade capture for so long? What drove his insatiable need to kill? And what really went on inside Apartment 213? In this episode, we unravel the...

Step into one of the most mysterious and haunted locations in America—the Winchester Mystery House. A mansion built under the guidance of spirits, with doors leading to nowhere, staircases twisting into oblivion, and a history drenched in paranormal encounters. Was Sarah Winchester truly haunted by the ghosts of those killed by her family’s rifles, or was this the obsession of a grief-stricken wom...

Episode Description: Step into one of the most horrifying true crime stories in history as we uncover the twisted life and crimes of Ed Gein—the grave robber and murderer who turned his farmhouse into a real-life house of horrors. From his isolated childhood under the rule of his fanatical mother to his disturbing obsession with human remains, we’re taking you deep into the mind of the man who ins...

New Episode Alert: The Haunting of Bobby Mackey’s Music World! Welcome to the most haunted honky-tonk in America—where the music plays, the whiskey flows, and the spirits? Well… they do more than just linger. This week on Total Conundrum, we’re taking you inside Bobby Mackey’s Music World, a country bar with a terrifying past. From a blood-soaked slaughterhouse to satanic rituals and a ghost with...

New Episode Alert! This week on Total Conundrum, we’re diving into the chilling, twisted mind of Ted Bundy—one of America’s most notorious serial killers. From his charming facade to the horrifying crimes that shocked the nation, we’re peeling back the layers of his story like a true crime thriller you won’t believe. What We Cover: ⚠️ Bundy’s eerie double life—charmer by day, monster by night How...

Total Conundrum Podcast – Show Notes Episode Title: The Haunted History of Tonopah Episode Description: Welcome to Total Conundrum, where we explore the weird, the eerie, and the downright bizarre! In this episode, we’re diving into Tonopah, Nevada—a town built on silver but haunted by its tragic past. From mine disasters to mystery plagues, haunted hotels, and, of course, the infamous Clown Motel...

Welcome to Total Conundrum, where we delve deep into the darkest corners of true crime history. In today’s episode, we’re exploring the horrifying legacy of John Wayne Gacy, also known as the Killer Clown. Strap in; this journey through the mind of one of America’s most notorious serial killers is not for the faint of heart. Segment 1: The Descent into Darkness ● Gacy’s Early Life: We’ll discuss J...

Welcome to Total Conundrum, where we peel back the layers of the most chilling true crime stories. Today, we’re diving deep into the twisted world of Charles Manson and his infamous family. Strap in; it’s going to be a wild ride. Segment 1: Who Was Charles Manson? ● Early Life of Charles Manson: Discussion on Manson’s early life in Cincinnati, his troubled childhood, and the formation of his manip...

Dive into the heart of darkness with Total Conundrum! ️‍♂️ Join Jeremy and Traci as they unravel the spine-tingling tale of The Watcher House at 657 Boulevard. From chilling letters to unseen forces, this episode explores the sinister secrets lurking within its walls. Don’t miss out on the thrills and chills! Listen now on your favorite podcast platform. Hit that play button on YouTube, and make s...

Prepare for a hair-raising collaboration! Join us and our fellow podcasters as we unveil the chilling tale of the ghostly horrors of Willowbrook Manor. Let’s roll out the red carpet for the stars of this audio extravaganza: 3 Siblings Walk into a Bar, Sounds Interesting, Couple of Couples, Studio Sinister, ScaryTales and Serials, Murder and Mimosas, The Suspended Sentence, Hauntscast, Weird Mythic...

Join us for a spine-tingling episode as we explore the ghosts of the White House with special guest April from Door Key Podcast! ️ Discover the eerie tales lurking within America’s most famous residence. Don’t forget to rate and review us on Apple and Spotify, and like and subscribe on YouTube! Plus, catch trailers from our podcast pals, A Call to Madness and A Suspended Sentence. #GhostsOfTheWhit...

Join us in our latest episode as we delve into the shadows with Megan and Issac from Hidden in the Shadows Podcast! We explore spine-tingling tales of the supernatural, mysterious encounters, and talk about their amazing abilities. Don’t miss this exciting conversation as we shine a light on the mysteries lurking in the darkness. Tune in now! #HiddenInTheShadows #Supernatural #PodcastCollab #Myste...

️✨ In our latest episode of Total Conundrum, Jeremy and Traci sit down with Sarah from Voiceless Behind Bars to delve into the pressing issues surrounding wrongful convictions and the plight of innocent individuals behind bars. Sarah shares her firsthand experiences and insights, shedding light on the injustices faced by those who have been wrongfully incarcerated. Tune in as we explore the compl...

️ Join Jeremy, Traci, and special guest John from Dairy Land Frights as they wrangle up the chilling tale of Seth Bullock and the haunted Bullock Hotel! Get ready for a rootin’ tootin’ ride through history and hauntings in this wild-western adventure! Don’t forget to like, subscribe, and leave a review on Apple and Spotify! Stay tuned for more spine-tingling tales and collabs with The Young Dads p...

Unlock the mysteries of cryptids! In this episode, Traci and Jeremy sit down with Nash Hoover from Chasing Legends, a seasoned cryptid hunter. Join the adventure as they delve into the world of elusive creatures and share spine-chilling stories. ️ Hit that play button on YouTube, and make sure to like and subscribe for your weekly dose of mystery and mayhem! If you’re tuning in on Apple or Spotify...

✨ Dive into the eerie world of cursed movies with Traci! In this episode, she unveils the chilling tales behind films shrouded in mystery and superstition. Get ready for a cinematic journey with unexpected twists and cursed reels! ️ Hit that play button on YouTube, and make sure to like and subscribe for your weekly dose of mystery and mayhem! If you’re tuning in on Apple or Spotify, drop a five-...

Get ready for ghostly tales! Traci dives into the haunted history of the Palmer House in Sauk Centre, MN. Join Traci and Jeremy with special guest Jenny from TCPS and MN TAPS, who was also a former Palmer House employee, for firsthand accounts and eerie encounters. ️‍♀️✨ Hit that play button on YouTube, and make sure to like and subscribe for your weekly dose of mystery and mayhem! If you’re tuni...

Get ready for a wild ride as Jeremy delves into the Flat Earth theory! But wait, he’s not stopping there — he’s brewing up his own quirky Flat Earth spin! Hold on to your globes, it’s gonna be a hilarious, mind-bending episode! ✨ Hit that play button on YouTube, and make sure to like and subscribe for your weekly dose of mystery and mayhem! If you’re tuning in on Apple or Spotify, drop a five-sta...

Jeremy and Traci are joined by the extraordinary Kevin from “Where the Weird Ones Are” podcast for an epic crossover episode! ✨ Get ready for a cosmic journey into the bizarre and unexplained. From mushroom people to cryptids to flat earth, this episode has it all! Don’t miss out on the laughter, the weirdness, and the fantastic stories that Kevin brings to the Conundrum Crew. Tune in now and emb...