This One's A Doozy

Hello and welcome back! In part two of the story of the murder of Betsy Faria, we dive a little deeper into a different suspect in the crime, we learn all about the depths that some people are willing to go in the name of personal gain. So what’s the deal with Pam Hupp, the last known person to have seen Betsy alive? Was she really the selfless, kind friend that she pretended to be? Listen in and...

Hello and welcome back! In this episode, Kevin enjoys s’mores in beer form, Hailey cozies up, and we bring you part one of the story of the murder of Betsy Faria. Betsy was known to everyone who knew her for her incredible personality, bright smile, and courage in the face of hardship. When Betsy is found murdered in her home in Troy, Missouri, investigators work to uncover the truth of what happe...

Hello and welcome back! In today’s episode, Kevin and Hailey make an announcement, share a drink, and get in the story about the disappearance and murder of 21-year-old spring breaker, Mark Kilroy. In 1989, Mark was snatched right out of a busy crowd by a mysterious and deadly cult with ritualistic leanings. Hang on tight for this one. This one’s a doozy.  For the month of January, Patreon subscri...

Hello and welcome back! We are coming at you with an extra episode this week and this one is wild. In the 90’s, the Lee family bought the home of their dreams deep in the Black Forest in northeastern Colorado Springs. But soon after moving in, the family would be plagued by bizarre sights, sounds, and smells. After capturing thousands of photos and videos and dozens of paranormal investigations on...

Hello and welcome back! In today’s episode, we learn about the tragic and mysterious story of the Sodder children. When a family of 12 watch their house burn to the ground on Christmas Eve, 1945, things are not what they seemed to be. When 5 of the children are completely unaccounted for, their family set out on a decades long mission to find them and to find the truth of what happened to them on...

Hello and welcome back! Join us for our second and final installment of the story of American psychopath Israel Keyes. Today, we pick up where we left off in part 1. When kidnapping suspect Israel Keyes was arrested and questioned regarding his involvement in the disappearance of 18-year-old Samantha Koenig, police had no clue how dark and twisted this man truly was. As Israel continued to proudly...

Hello and welcome back! Today, we’re bringing you the story of the kidnapping of 18-year-old Samantha Koenig. When Samantha went missing from her place of work in Anchorage, Alaska, detectives are left with no evidence as to where she could’ve gone. Over the course of the next month, clues remained minimal until a ransom note with a photo of Samantha was found in a local park. From there, the hunt...

Hello and welcome back! Happy New Year to our friends and listeners across the globe. We thought it would be fun to kick off the new year with a bonus episode! Today, we’re talking all about the Warminster Thing. On Christmas morning in 1964, a small English town was being visited by an unseen source that was terrifying residents with strange sounds. Soon, sights and sounds from out of this world...

Hello and welcome back! On this week’s story, we dive into the shocking and tragic story of the unexpected deaths of two men, deaths that aren’t what they seem to be. When detectives are hot on the heels of figuring out what REALLY happened, a sudden suicide note confesses to all of it. But things are never quite what they seem to be in this story. Buckle up, friends. This one’s a doozy!  SOURCES:...

Hello and welcome back! In this, our first EVER fictional episode, we present you with a long loved tradition coming at you from the Victorian Era: telling ghost stories on Christmas Eve. In honor of the practice, Kevin and Hailey each present one of their favorite old school ghost stories for your Christmas Eve enjoyment. Gather ‘round the fire and prepare yourselves. This one’s a doozy.  SOURCES...

Hello and welcome back! In this week’s episode, we learn all about the tragic murder of 19-year-old beauty queen Nona Dirksmeyer. Nona was a student who was known for her beauty, selflessness, kindness, and care for others and she was at the height of working towards her dreams in December of 2005. When Nona’s body was discovered in her apartment by her boyfriend and his friend and mom, all eyes w...

Hello and welcome back! In today’s episode, Hailey considers diversifying her portfolio, Kevin switches it up, and the two discuss the nightmare crime spree known as the Wichita Massacre. When two brothers descended upon the town of Wichita, they showed no mercy as they robbed, terrorized, and murdered without discretion. On their final night of terror, one bizarre twist of fate would lead to a sp...

Hello and welcome back! I’m this extra special episode, Hailey softens the blow of last week’s story AND this week’s upcoming story by sharing a classic North American cryptid tale: The Beast of Bray Road. When a series of strange sightings of a dog-like man put a small Wisconsin town in a chokehold, the hunt for answers began. What was this thing? What did it want? Let’s try and figure it out tog...

Hello and welcome back! In this episode, Kevin shares his dream, Hailey delights about a squirrel bridge, and we learn about the Von Maur shooting. When 19-year-old Robert Hawkins walked into the Von Maur at Westroads Mall in Omaha, Nebraska and began to open fire on holiday shoppers and store employees, countless lives were changed forever. But in the wake of such terrible tragedy, hope and heali...

Hello and welcome back! In this extra special episode, Hailey shared all about some of her favorite fixtures in global folklore that make their pretense known during the holidays. We’ve got naughty goblins, oafish trolls with a penchant for mischief, Christmas witches, and horned monsters set on punishing the naughty boys and girls for their wrongdoings. AND maybe an extra special fixture of Haile...

Hello and welcome back! This week, Kevin wants to go fast, Hailey has a theory regarding light bulbs, and the pair put their heads together in an attempt to solve the mystery of the Hinterkaifeck murders. We’ve got a real whirlwind of a story involving a mass murder, mysterious footprints, incest, betrayal, and a 100 year old mystery. Can you figure out the truth of what really happened at Hinterk...

Hello and welcome back! Surprise again! We wanted to throw another extra episode your way this week to accompany you on your holiday journeys! In today’s story, Hailey tells Kevin all about the monstrous loser that is American serial killer Ed Kemper. What else can we really say about this episode? From beginning to end, this is a sick and twisted story of a man who could’ve been much more than he...

Hello and welcome back! On today’s episode, Hailey confesses her addiction to seasonal beverages, Kevin relishes his frugality, and Hailey shares about the bizarre vampire mania that swept through New England at the height of the tuberculosis outbreak. This steaming pot of unusual soup features vampires, weird death practices, barking dog demons, and the baffling and tragic tale of New England’s f...

Hello and welcome back! In this episode, Kevin fights an extreme thirst, Hailey reminisces about a meme-factory event, and the pair put their thinking caps on to try and figure out what happened to Kenny Veach. In November of 2014, 47-year-old outdoor enthusiast and YouTuber Kenny Veach embarked into the Mojave Desert in hopes of locating a mysterious cave near Area 51. When Kenny didn’t return ho...

Hello and welcome back! Surprise! We’re throwing an extra episode your way this week for the fun of it. Join us as we explore the village of Pluckley and the Dering Woods, two of Britain’s most haunted spots. We’ve got frights, we’ve got spooks, we’ve got screaming woods, we’ve got cute ghost dogs, ghostly love triangles, multitudes of ghosts, and so much more! Hop on in and enjoy the ride because...

Hello and welcome back! In this week’s episode, Kevin enjoys a drink with a terrible name, Hailey grants listeners two new vocabulary words, and Hailey tells the story of Bobby Dunbar. Bobby was just 4 years old when he vanished from his family’s campsite. Despite an expansive search, it took 8 months, and plenty of blood sweat and tears to bring him home. But soon after his arrival, a woman came...

Hello and welcome back! In today’s episode, Hailey shares the story of Blair Adams, a young man from Canada who went from an every day guy to a frantic man on the run. What caused Blair’s sudden change of personality and fear for his life? Was he just paranoid? Or was there something more sinister at play? When his body was discovered several thousands of miles from home, investigators and loved o...

Hello and welcome back! In this, our first EVER listener edition of the podcast, we have five, count ‘em, FIVE stories sent to us by listeners! We are joined by a special guest who reads her own story as well! Brace yourselves for stories featuring a creepy doll, an inhabited ex, a meant-to be encounter and orbs that bring comfort and peace, a Houdini ghost-man-thing, and a phantom/spirits in the...

Hello and welcome back! In today’s episode, Hailey shares all about the disappearance and murder of Chelsea Bruck. When Chelsea attended a much anticipated Halloween party in 2014 in rural Michigan, she never returned home. When her body was discovered in a wooded area, the hunt was on for answers to several questions. Who did this to her? And why? Find out on today’s episode. Hang on tight. This...

Hello and welcome back! In today’s bonus episode, we are taking a trip around the globe to 2 very spooky, potentially VERY haunted spots. Be on the look out for mystery fog, the ghosts of plague victims or maniacal doctors, a red lady, and one of the most well-described and gruesomely depicted ghosts we’ve ever covered: The Elemental. If spooky spots are your thing, than buckle up. This one’s a do...