The Super Legit Podcast

James Heaney and Cole Stratton swing by the nonexistent Super Legit studio to answer the question, “When do you lie?” We can’t even pretend we recorded this one recently, but with talks about more strikes, it’s deeply prescient! We get into social lies, parenting lies, inconsequential lies, and resume lies. We revisit a cop who’s always got his pants down, a mother who will go to any length to kee...

Douglas Sarine and Paul Vaillancourt return to answer the question, “If you could go back and sliding door/new choice one moment in your teens, what would it be?” We desperately try to remember the name of the film Mr. Destiny, impersonate Michael Caine flawlessly, explore what Josh would have been like as a bass player, give up smoking clove cigarettes, and dive into scenes about bad guardian ang...

In a more intimate episode, the cast answers the classic Joey question, “How YOU doin’?” Between bad impressions of Joey, detailed analysis of Michael Heiman’s wedding roles (who couldn’t even show up for this episode!), and a breakdown of the insanity of the modern jury system, the team finds time for scenes about deeply uncooperative drivers and surprisingly well-trained cops, an age-old argumen...

Steven Good joins the Super Legit Crew along with returning friend Will Reyes to answer the question, “What’s an experience that bonded you with someone?” We listen to stories about Jeopardy tryouts, police visits to hotel rooms, fast food binges, scenic road trips, and more. And our improvised scenes visit Hotel California, Cactus Lake, more speed dating, and a very bad surgical theater.  Cast: S...

Christian Hefley and Josh Tariff help the Super Legit crew answer, “If you could go back in time and talk to 17 year old you, what advice would you give yourself?” We learn the dangers of collecting Beanie Babies, what Sports Almanacs are really for, take a walk through video game judgment, find out what dating is like in the Mortal Kombat universe, discuss the lasting impact of Limp Bizkit, and s...

Lish Bliss and Rebecca Stevens join us to answer the question, “What's an embarrassing situation that happened to you that you’re happy to talk about?” We get some co-hosting surprises, technological wizardry, leaked nudes, leaky pants, leaky eyes, leaky lips, and other topics we couldn’t come up with leak-based descriptions of!  Cast: Sean Michael Boozer, Jen Burton, Stephen C. James, Jarrett Len...

Shulie Cowen and Norm Thoeming of Opening Night: The Improvised Musical return to the Super Legit studio (we totally have one of those) to answer the question, “What's the weirdest thing you've ever had to do as part of a job?” We hear stories of armed advertising photo shoots, Pizza Express mascots, overly anal restaurants managers, overly anal camp students, and lube wrestling! And have we menti...

Three spectacular guests answer the question, “What was a moment in your life where you proudly felt like you were totally killin' it?” Listen to Bill Chott, BJ Lange, Michael Tauzin, and the rest of our crew walk through parenthood, teaching moments, high school campaigns, and impressing girls. And did we mention how quickly the team took the question ironically? And whether you love OR hate Paw...

Thomas Greene and Douglas Sarine return and take over the show?! Listen to them interview the cast before making one BIG mistake. Then we all answer the question, “What’s something you quit that you still feel great about?” We talk about sentimentality toward possessions, negative thinking, the military, and visit a very unconventional wedding. Also, more things!  Cast: Sean Michael Boozer, Chris...

Kathrynn Cobbs and Alex Rose swing by the podcast to answer the question, "What's your Kryptonite?" We dig deep into Girl Scout Cookies, collectables, Mexican Coke, wet socks, and so very much more!  Cast: Sean Michael Boozer, Jen Burton, Chris Compton, Michael Heiman, Stephen C. James, Jarrett Lennon Kaufman, Josh Spence, Chris Sanders  Special guests: Kathrynn Cobbs and Alex Rose  Ads: Leech Emp...

The classic crew returns to answer, "What's great about being an adult that wasn't even on your radar as a kid?" We talk through the literal changes to the world since childhood, participation trophies that we deserve, nerd culture becoming... culture, and explore a book/movie called Medium Women. All that and much, much, MUCH more!  Cast: Jen Burton, Chris Compton, Michael Heiman, Stephen C. Jame...

It's a home brew episode! The Super Legit crew answers the question, "What's a superstition that you hold onto, whether or not you believe in it?" We get into what you say after someone sneezes, theatrical curses, the lottery, and for some reason... Gallagher.  Cast: Jen Burton, Chris Compton, Michael Heiman, Stephen C. James, Jarrett Lennon Kaufman, Josh Spence, Chris Sanders  Ads: Rope (improvis...

Thomas Greene joins the crew, along with the return of Opening Night's Shulie Cowen and our co-editor and friend, Christian Hefley! Find out what childhood TV show defined everyone, with trips through Rocket Power, Animaniacs, Batman, Kids in the Hall, and some VERY stinky scenes!  Cast: Sean Michael Boozer, Jen Burton, Michael Heiman, Stephen C. James, Jarrett Lennon Kaufman, Josh Spence, Chris S...

Lydia Nelsen returns to answer the question, "When did someone you didn't like surprise you in a really positive way?" We get a variety of teachers, find a magically inspirational sandwich artist, get sidetracked by the Real Housewives of some place or another, and get a visit from Major Dad.  Cast: Jen Burton, Stephen C. James, Jarrett Lennon Kaufman, Josh Spence, Chris Sanders  Special Guest: Ly...

"For precisely one year you can switch lives with someone else. Body, skills, knowledge, property, etc. Who and why?" Lydia Nelsen answers this question the best way she can, while Rebecca Stevens answers... from another dimension! We dig into the intricacies of taking over other people's bodies throughout time, seeing the other side of a relationship, high school reunions redone, and how to avoid...

"What's a time in your life you bit off more than you could chew?" We find out exactly how guests Tierney Conley and Chris Thompson got in over their heads, along with the rest of the Super Legit Crew. Hear about job interviews gone very wrong, underaged driving, how not to order a pizza, and so very much more!  Cast: Sean Michael Boozer, Jen Burton, Chris Compton, Michael Heiman, Stephen C. James...

Douglas Sarine swings by the virtual studio to answer the question, "What's your first memory growing up of true freedom?" From Douglas' snappy outfits, to what freedom really looks like in today's world, we visit worlds of Nintendo, use food as metaphor for relationships, and find out the consequences of pretending you're somebody you're not.  Cast: Sean Michael Boozer, Jen Burton, Chris Compton,...

Rolland Lopez and Rich Baker swing by the virtual studio to answer the question, "What's your favorite slang word or phrase, and where did you get it?" We explore all sorts of Southern slang, talk about The Matrix dance musical, explore bad school assignments, and bring back some forgotten classic Internet cartoons!  Cast: Chris Compton, Michael Heiman, Stephen C. James, Jarrett Lennon Kaufman, Jo...

Lauren Pritchard and Kelly Vrooman join the Super Legit crew as they answer the question, "What's the longest lie you ever managed to keep straight?" We hear lies about crying, ages, punches, nationalities, familial relationships, maturity, and more!  Cast: Sean Michael Boozer, Jen Burton, Chris Compton, Jarrett Lennon Kaufman, Josh Spence, Chris Sanders  Special guests: Lauren Pritchard and Kelly...

The Cast of Super Legit is joined by their most talkative guest yet to answer the question, "What's your favorite activity to zone out to?" We find out how jigsaw puzzles pair with movies, power washing pairs with video games, hiking pairs with quiet, and serial killers pair with cabins in the woods. All this and so very much more!  Cast: Sean Michael Boozer, Jen Burton, Chris Compton, Michael Hei...

The Super Legit Crew brings back some of their best characters to read The Raven by Edgar Allan Poe in this Halloween 2022 special bonus episode.  Cast: Sean Michael Boozer, Jen Burton, Chris Compton, Christian Hefley, Stephen C. James, Jarrett Lennon Kaufman, Chris Sanders, Josh Spence  Original release date: 10/28/22 

Our co-editor Christian Hefley joins us this week to answer the question, "What's the worst piece of advice you've ever been given?" After a brief co-hosting turf war, we explore bad advice on how to get the attention of girls, the pitfalls of dating when you're Frankenstein's Monster, how not to save a drowning victim, and peer pressure!  Cast: Sean Michael Boozer, Jen Burton, Chris Compton, Mich...

Guest star Cozi Orlen joins Will Reyes as he returns to answer the question: "What's a strong opinion you had that you reversed later in life?" We learn whether bits are good for conversation, we plan the funeral for conjoined twin comedy writers, question God, pick apart the origins of villain voices, find out why Mr. Rogers changed his clothes every day, and explore the gig economy in the Land o...

Because there are always more stories to tell, the team revisits an old question: "What's a time you got dragged into something you'd have given anything to be kept out of?" We learn about mosh pit brawls, Christian rock shows (complete with Christian Side Hugs), being a personal relationship counselor, and theme parks rights that aren't as secure as they should be. And let's not get started on sp...

The crew recenters themselves to answer one simple question: "What's the worst job you've ever had?" We learn what it's like to be a dessert sherpa, check in with a gingerbread witch on candy mountain, commute long distances for closed improv theaters, get special visits from the Bible and Marvel extended universes, and find out way too much about insurance.  Cast: Sean Michael Boozer, Jen Burton,...