The Selby Is Godcast: A Cleveland Guardians podcast

Zack and T.J. discuss an embarrassing weekending in Baltimore for the Indians (and Zack's inability to catch a foul ball), Bobby Bradley's arrival and Cleveland's decision to DFA Jake Bauers and MLB's impending battle against sticky substances and how it impacts spin rate. For more episodes, support the podcast at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast - you'll get one additional show per week.

T.J. and Zack discuss a peculiar finish to Sunday's doubleheader and how Cleveland managed to avoid a Blue Jays sweep. The guys then talk about  an offense that continues to struggle and where to find answers. T.J. asks Zack if he'd consider trading Eddie Rosario or Cesar Hernandez if a team asked about either right now, Zack shares a handful of players that are older than T.J. and the duo re...

Zack and T.J. recap Cleveland dropping 2-of-3 to the Twins and James Karinchak's rare extra-inning woes, discuss Owen Miller's arrival and what the injury to Franmil Reyes means for the rest of the offense, explain why some better production from Amed Rosario has been intriguing, examine Triston McKenzie's demotion and talk about the difficulty of trying to contend and develop at the same time. Fo...

The Indians are nearly a quarter into the season, so Zack and T.J. hand out grades, discuss their most disappointing and surprising players, talk about which player deserves the next opportunity in Cleveland and debate if they'd change their preseason win-loss predictions based on what we've seen so far. If you want additional episodes each week, join our growing community at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGo...

If the 1917 White Sox could get no-hit twice and then win the World Series, why can't the 2021 Cleveland Indians? Zack and T.J. talk about the contrast between another no-hit loss and a 9-run output in a win on Saturday. Then, the guys talk about the changes that need to be made on the roster, Owen Miller, and discuss what the near future should look like for Andres Gimenez. Also, what's in the tu...

T.J. and Zack talk about "Uncle Bryan and the boys" in the Indians bullpen, why James Karinchak has been so unhittable, what makes developing hitters so difficult and if there's any cause for concern with Eddie Rosario and Cesar Hernandez. For additional midweek episodes, find us at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast 

Are the Indians nearing a chance to make changes offensively? What about the way pitchers attack Jake Bauers neutralizes one of his biggest skills? Will we be seeing Daniel Johnson, Owen Miller or Bobby Bradley at any point soon? Is there any reason for concern about Triston McKenzie's velocity? Is Franmil Reyes the fastest man on the planet? What do we make of Sam Hentges? T.J. and Zack discuss a...

Zack and T.J. recap a wild week for the Indians -- including getting no-hit and having a triple play turned against them. The guys continue to evaluate an ever-evolving roster, talk about Triston McKenzie, Jordan Luplow and discuss the difficulties fans that cut the cord have faced when trying to watch Cleveland this season. Catch our midweek episodes for $1 per podcast at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodca...

Zack and T.J. talk about Cleveland's 5-3 start and focus on Franmil Reyes and Emmanuel Clase while looking ahead to an interesting stretch. Then, the guys speak with Indians relief prospect Nick Sandlin (27:07).  For even more Cleveland baseball discussion, find our midweek episodes over at Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast.

Zack and T.J. react (and overreact) to Cleveland's first weekend in Detroit. Who is hitting leadoff against righties and why is it Ben Gamel? Is Emmanuel Clase on his way to the closer spot? Which young player stood out on opening weekend? Velocity alarmism and more!

Zack and T.J. react to the Opening Day roster coming together, assess what it means for Amed Rosario and Ben Gamel, discuss why Jake Bauers got the first chance at first base and attempt to decipher how the Indians will divide their innings among their starters. Also, the guys announce that additional midweek episodes will now be available on Patreon.com/SelbyIsGodcast.

Oscar Mercado will not be Cleveland's Opening Day center fielder. So, who will it be? And how did the Indians arrive at this decision? Zack and T.J. talk about the remaining battle in center and address the rest of the team's roster puzzle. Also, big podcast news!

T.J. and Zack talk about the possible ways the Indians could assemble their starting rotation to begin the season (and if it matters) and assess Logan Allen's chances to make the squad. Then, the guys talk about center field and Amed Rosario's transition to the outfield.

Zack and T.J. discuss Billy Hamilton and Mike Freeman not making the Cleveland roster, detail how Andres Gimenez might be inching toward the opening day shortstop job, look for clear clues about the batting order and briefly talk about some Minor-League rule changes baseball will be toying with in 2021.

Zack and T.J. talk about Jose Ramirez and Franmil Reyes breaking Covid protocols, assess the spring shortstop competition between Andres Gimenez and Amed Rosario, discuss the battle between Jake Bauers and Bobby Bradley at first base and debate if RBIs (RBI?) can ever matter in MVP voting.

With additional details being reported about Mickey Callaway's time in Cleveland by The Athletic on Tuesday (https://theathletic.com/2420251/2021/03/02/indians-mickey-callaway-behavior/), Zack and T.J. discuss what that reveals about the organizational culture in Cleveland.

Zack and T.J. talk about a potential Shane Bieber extension, discuss how players might feel more comfortable this year compared to 2020, banter about which off-the-radar player each are intrigued by this spring and Zack reveals his preference for a new Cleveland team name.

Zack and T.J. debate whether it's better for star players to play in big markets. Then, the guys ask the listeners for their input about the future of the podcast, talk about Francisco Lindor's "tired" comment and discuss what the back end of the Cleveland bullpen might look like in 2021.

Zack and T.J. reflect on the career of a now-retired Cody Allen. Then, the guys answer a number of questions and make predictions about the 2021 season. What is more likely to happen: Jose Ramirez wins MVP or Indians win the division? Who will get the most plate appearances in center field? Who will be the breakout hitter and pitcher? Those questions and more are answered this week.

Zack and T.J. revisit the Mike Clevinger trade and ask what would make that deal a future success? Then, the guys talk about an often overlooked member of that deal and determine how important he is to the overall evaluation of that trade. After, Zack and T.J. get a little unhinged talking about the state of the game.

Zack and T.J. share their pleasant memories of legendary Cleveland sports talk host and writer Les Levine, discuss the return of Bryan Shaw to the Indians on a minor-league deal and attempt to fill out the Opening Day lineup.

Zack and T.J. are back for an emergency edition of the Selby Is Godcast, breaking down the Indians' reported agreement with outfielder Eddie Rosario.

Zack and T.J. talk about the Indians' reunion with César Hernández, discuss rumors of outside interest in Amed Rosario and talk about the dangers of always trusting in Top 100 prospect lists.

Zack and T.J. are back to discuss the biggest questions that need answered in 2021 and the opportunities needed to make it happen. Will the Indians just commit to playing some young players or will we see a few veterans brought into the organization before spring begins? And what is best for the longterm health of the franchise? 

Zack and T.J. discuss some of their lasting impressions of Francisco Lindor in Cleveland, share some behind the scenes stories and ponder where the "savings" created by the Lindor-Carlos Carrasco trade will go.