The Scotchy Bourbon Boys

Send us Fan Mail Derby week energizes Kentucky as bourbon enthusiasts and horse racing fans gather for the 151st Run for the Roses, with Woodford Reserve maintaining its tradition of commemorative bottles featuring special artwork. • Weather forecast predicts heavy rain for Derby Day, dramatically changing race conditions and creating opportunities for mudders • The bourbon industry shows strong r...

Send us Fan Mail We revisit bourbon history with a special tasting of a 1981 Old Taylor bourbon, which reveals the fascinating journey of this historic brand from Colonel EH Taylor through National Distillers to Jim Beam and eventually back to Buffalo Trace. • Old Taylor transitioned from its original distillery (now Castle & Key) to Jim Beam production in the 1970s • This 1981 bottle represen...

Send us Fan Mail Yellowstone Bourbon honors America's first national park while exploring the rich history behind this iconic brand that dates back to 1872. Stephen Beam, descending from two legendary distilling families, revived this historic label through Limestone Branch Distillery, continuing a tradition that survived Prohibition and multiple ownership changes. • One dollar from every bot...

Send us Fan Mail The Scotchy Bourbon Boys dive deep into Maker's Mark's Wood Finishing Series, comparing the 2024 Heart Release and 2025 Keepers Release while exploring the brand's evolution from its wheated bourbon origins to its innovative stave-finishing techniques. • Wood Finishing Series represents Maker's Mark's expanding approach to bourbon making through French oak...

Send us Fan Mail This batch of Booker's, named "Barry's Batch" in honor of former Beam CEO Barry Berish, delivers a remarkably smooth drinking experience despite its 125.7 proof, with rich caramel, peanut butter, and warm spice notes creating a perfect fireside sipper. • First Booker's release of 2025 (Batch 2501) honoring Barry Berish, former Beam chairman who passed away...

Send us Fan Mail The Kentucky Bourbon Festival has transformed from a small event with 9 distilleries to a premier bourbon celebration featuring 62 distilleries, with exclusive releases and direct access to master distillers. KBF President Randy Prasse shares how the festival has evolved to focus on authentic experiences connecting bourbon enthusiasts with the people who make their favorite spirit...

Send us Fan Mail The rich and storied tradition of challenge coins has made its way from military culture into bourbon communities, creating meaningful connections among enthusiasts and marking achievements in the whiskey world. • Challenge coins originated with WWI pilots but became popular during Vietnam War • Different types of bourbon challenge coins include Stave & Thief Bourbon Steward c...

Send us Fan Mail Tiny shares his experience with Gervasi Vineyard and Distillery, his local Canton, Ohio establishment that has evolved from a winery to include an award-winning distillery producing exceptional bourbons and spirits. • Founded in 2008, Gervasi began as a winery and restaurant before expanding to include villas, event venues, and recently a distillery • The Gervasi Stillhouse featur...

Send us Fan Mail The Jack Daniels Triple Mash offers a uniquely sweet whiskey experience by combining three different mash bills in a way that challenges expectations of the Jack Daniels brand. This innovative expression earned 14 out of 18 knocks in our barrel bottle breakdown, making it a standout bottle at the $40 price point. • Triple Mash combines 60% Tennessee Rye, 20% Tennessee Whiskey, and...

Send us Fan Mail Knob Creek 9 Year serves as both an incredible value at $35 and a meaningful journey marker for bourbon enthusiasts seeking authentic whiskey experiences without breaking the bank. • Knob Creek was established in 1992 as part of Jim Beam's small batch collection created by Booker Noe • The name pays homage to Abraham Lincoln's childhood home in Kentucky • After temporari...

Send us Fan Mail The Scotchy Bourbon Boys taste and compare Stagg Jr. and Stagg bourbons, tracing the evolution from the "Junior" designation to simply "Stagg" and examining whether quality changed with the name. • Stagg described as "the perfect man's bourbon" - barrel-proof with power but exceptionally balanced • Multiple batches of Stagg released in 2024 (A th...

Send us Fan Mail Tonight's episode dives deep into the world of double oak and toasted oak bourbon, exploring the science and flavor differences between various finishing techniques. We examine what sets apart barrel finishing methods and why they create such distinct flavor profiles in your favorite bourbons. • Woodford Double Oak stands as our benchmark for the category—butterscotch and car...

Send us Fan Mail Martin and Pat transformed a friendship at Burns Pub in Columbus into Bua, an exceptional Irish whiskey brand that competes with giants while maintaining local Ohio roots. Their Black Label expression, finished in Irish stout barrels at 94 proof, offers a unique sipping experience that showcases how Irish whiskey creates perfect harmony with barrel finishes compared to bourbon&apo...

Send us Fan Mail Amanda Humphrey takes us behind the scenes at Star Hill Farm, home of Maker's Mark, where tradition meets innovation across 1,100 acres of working farmland. We explore how this iconic bourbon brand is pioneering sustainable practices while maintaining their founder's vision through innovative wood-finishing techniques and an uncompromising commitment to flavor. • Amanda&...

Send us Fan Mail The legacy of Elmer T. Lee lives on through his namesake single barrel bourbon, where we compare the newest 2025 release with a 2019 bottle to explore how this iconic whiskey maintains its high standards over time. • Elmer T. Lee was Buffalo Trace's fourth master distiller who revolutionized bourbon by launching Blanton's in 1984 as the first modern single barrel bourbon...

Send us Fan Mail This episode dives into everything March means for bourbon lovers, exploring the unique dynamics between whiskey releases and the excitement of basketball season, dubbed "March Madness." We also touch on the anticipation within the Ohio whiskey community around recent drops and the impact of Irish whiskey during the festive season.   • Discussing why March is such a pivo...

Send us Fan Mail The episode dives into the captivating journey of Irish whiskey, featuring the unique storytelling of Waterford distillery. We explore the blend of terroir and innovation, along with tasting evaluations of various expressions.  • Introduction of Rosewood Bourbon and its revival  • Tasting notes and insight into Waterford whiskey  • Exploration of whiskey aging and its impact  • De...

Send us Fan Mail The episode explores the fascinating journey of American Highway Reserve, a bourbon that travels the U.S. in a Rolling Rick House and gains distinct flavors from diverse climates. Tiny break down tasting notes, discuss their barrel banging rating system, and share personal insights into the bourbon experience, emphasizing the connection of good spirits to friendship and culture. ...

Send us Fan Mail Whiskey Thief Distilling is on the brink of an exhilarating transformation with new distribution plans and unique experiences for whiskey enthusiasts. The hosts discuss the distillery's upcoming special releases, the importance of consumer engagement, and the anticipated Whiskey Thief Guild, fostering a deeper connection with their fan base. • Launching limited self-distribut...

Send us Fan Mail This episode connects the art of distilling with the rich narratives woven into craft spirits. We explore the revival of rye whiskey, innovative techniques, and the sense of community that drives the craft distilling movement forward.  • Legacy of Pennsylvania rye whiskey and its revival • Artistic techniques in distillation explored  • The role of heritage in recipe development ...

Send us Fan Mail The episode dives into the bourbon resurgence, focusing on accessible brands and the unique story ofSweetens Cove 22 We explore what's currently available on the shelves, emphasizing exciting finds like Sweetens Cove 22 and a new barrel rating system to assist listeners in their bourbon journeys.  • Significant price drops and current accessible shelf options  • Observation o...

Send us Fan Mail This episode dives into the world of Traveler Whiskey, a collaborative project between Chris Stapleton and Buffalo Trace’s master distiller Harlen Wheatley. We explore the history behind this whiskey, its unique blend, market dynamics, and what this means for both casual drinkers and whiskey connoisseurs alike. • Introduction to Rosewood Bourbons and Rye  • Personal updates and po...

Send us Fan Mail We explore the fascinating journey of Middle West Spirits and its commitment to crafting exceptional whiskey using local grains. The episode delves into the distillation process, history, and unique flavor profiles of their various whiskey expressions while celebrating their innovative spirit and community roots. • Introduction to Middle West Spirits' philosophy  • Background...

Send us Fan Mail Craft distilling in Ohio is thriving, with Midwest Spirits paving the way for unique whiskey flavors. The episode dives deep into the process of aging, blending, and the importance of local agriculture while highlighting upcoming innovations and products.  • The evolution of Midwest Spirits through COVID   • The significance of understanding international palates   • Aging and con...

Send us Fan Mail This episode explores the vibrant journey of Penelope Whiskey, highlighting its innovative approaches and unique finishes within today’s competitive bourbon landscape. The hosts engage in a detailed tasting of various expressions, and their lively banter adds a rich layer of experience for listeners. • Introduction to Penelope Whiskey and its significance  • Insights on the acquis...