The Murder Police Podcast

Send us Fan Mail A mother's faith doesn't waver, even after a decade of searching for her missing son. Sandra Hasty and daughter Jennifer share the haunting story of Michael Gorley's disappearance from rural Kentucky—a case marked by strange encounters, spiritual guidance, and the frustrating knowledge that someone knows exactly what happened. The details paint a disturbing picture:...

Send us Fan Mail A mother's intuition and a sister's unexplainable spiritual experience drive the desperate search for Michael Keith Gorley after his Ford Explorer is discovered partially submerged in a pond on Wilderness Trail Road in Lincoln County, Kentucky. Sandra Hasty and Jennifer Gorley Coffey take us through the bewildering days following Michael's disappearance, revealing a...

Send us Fan Mail The unsolved disappearance of Michael Keith Gorley haunts the backroads of rural Kentucky like a ghost story without an ending. Ten birthdays, ten Christmas mornings, ten Mother's Days have passed while his family waits for answers that never come. Sandra Hasty remembers the last morning she saw her son - May 17, 2015. Michael had slept in her bed that night (she took his), a...

Send us Fan Mail Join Wendy and David for their 3 Things, this time, on Jeffrey Dahmer.   The case of Jeffrey Dahmer continues to haunt our collective consciousness decades after his crimes came to light. What makes this story so deeply disturbing isn't just the shocking nature of his murders, but the stark contrast between the monster and the man who appeared so ordinary to those around him....

Send us Fan Mail A split jury verdict that defied expectations. Three men dead. A defendant who confessed but later died by suicide in prison. The Lexington Triple Homicide conclusion reveals the devastating consequences when drug culture, family violence, and opportunity collide. The detective's theory makes disturbing sense – victims who crashed hard after a "420 party" would have...

Send us Fan Mail When detectives locate Ricky at a Louisville Red Roof Inn following a triple homicide in Lexington, they're stunned by his immediate confession: "I killed Aaron and Isaac and I'm proud I did it." But this chilling admission deliberately omits any mention of his stepfather Frank – the third victim discovered at a separate location. What follows is a masterclass...

Send us Fan Mail A routine death call transforms into a detective's worst nightmare when one body becomes three in a matter of hours. When Frank Reschke is found murdered in his recliner, detectives quickly realize they're missing two crucial elements - the victim's car and his stepson, Ricky Sherroan. What follows is a masterclass in homicide investigation as detectives balance gat...

Send us Fan Mail Two handsome, wealthy young men from Beverly Hills. Parents murdered by shotgun blasts in their own mansion. A whirlwind of spending on luxury cars and Rolex watches. Sexual abuse allegations that split public opinion. The Menendez brothers case remains one of America's most captivating true crime stories more than three decades after the 1989 murders shocked the nation. We p...

Send us Fan Mail "Justice delayed is justice denied" takes on profound meaning in the story of Mark Morris, whose grandparents Edwin and Bessie Morris were brutally murdered on Father's Day evening in 1985. What began as an act of kindness – letting a familiar face use their phone when he claimed to be out of gas – ended in a savage double homicide that has left a family waiting for...

Send us Fan Mail A horrifying betrayal lies at the heart of Edwin and Bessie Morris's murder. The elderly couple was brutally killed in their Kentucky home—not by strangers, but by the son of Edwin's best friend and his violent accomplices.  The nightmare for the Morris family began with a confusing phone call delivering unimaginable news, but it would be months before they discovered wh...

Send us Fan Mail The quiet town of Gray Hawk, Kentucky had one stoplight in the entire county. Nobody locked their doors. Everyone knew everyone. It was here that Edwin and Bessie Morris built their life, running the local grocery store, post office, and gas station. Their grandson Mark Morris remembers them as pillars of the community - hardworking people who helped neighbors who couldn't af...

Send us Fan Mail We LOVE the response to out latest concept "3 Things" and have plans to do many more, but we really want ideas from our listeners and watchers! What cases would you like to talk about?  Drop your suggestions on our YouTube Channel where this episode is under our Shorts playlist and subscribe to our YouTube channel while you are there! David's book, True Crime and Consequ...

Send us Fan Mail Murder Police Podcast – JonBenét Ramsey Case: 3 Things   In this gripping episode of The Murder Police Podcast , hosts Wendy and David explore the 2024 Netflix documentary Cold Case: JonBenét Ramsey and discuss three major aspects that stood out to them. The case, which remains one of America’s most infamous unsolved mysteries, continues to raise questions decades later.   Wendy a...

Send us Fan Mail How do you cope when someone close to you disappears without a trace? On this episode of the Murder Police Podcast, we unravel the story of Little Timmy Sterner, whose sudden disappearance has left a family in Nicholasville in turmoil and desperate for answers. Briana Johnson, Timmy's cousin and our guest, shares her heartfelt memories of growing up with Timmy, painting a pic...

Send us Fan Mail Searching for Little Timmy: A Journey of Hope, Despair, and Community Strength What would you do if a loved one disappeared without a trace? This episode takes you into the emotional abyss experienced by Randall Smith as he shares the harrowing search for his missing friend, Little Timmy. Alongside Timmy's mother and sister, Randall recounts the psychological torment and haun...

Send us Fan Mail Unraveling Friendship: The Disappearance of Little Timmy Sterner What if the friends you cherished from childhood suddenly disappeared into thin air? This episode, we sit with Randall Smith, a close friend of Little Timmy Sterner, to unravel the layers of friendship that withstand years of change and adversity. Randall shares colorful tales of laughter and adventure, from the quir...

Send us Fan Mail The Search for Justice in Timmy's Case Picture the heart-wrenching story of Timmy Sterner, a vibrant young man from Nicholasville, Kentucky, whose sudden disappearance has left a community in suspense. We begin with Cheyenne Brock, who shares her heartfelt recollections of growing up with Timmy, painting a vivid picture of their sibling-like bond. Their joyful reunion, filled...

Send us Fan Mail What happens when a family is caught in the crossfire of misinformation and speculation? Join us as we unravel the emotional journey of Timothy Sterner's disappearance, guided by his uncle Terrance and grandmother Sandy. They share their personal battles against the tide of falsehoods and rumors, highlighting how these distractions have made an already painful situation nearl...

Send us Fan Mail A young man's mysterious disappearance has left a community in turmoil and a family in search of answers. Timothy Sterner's story is one of heartache, resilience, and the relentless pursuit of truth. We are joined by his uncle Terrance and grandmother Sandy, who share not only personal stories and cherished memories of Timmy but also the immense void his absence has left...

Send us Fan Mail In this emotionally charged episode of The Murder Police Podcast, we continue to unravel the tragic story of Little Timmy Sterner. We are joined by his sister, Sabra VanWinkle, and his mother, Tammy Sterner, who share poignant memories and shed light on the events leading up to Timmy's mysterious disappearance. Sabra and Tammy paint a vivid picture of Timmy's life, from...

Send us Fan Mail What happens when hope turns into heartbreak, and the search for answers stretches into years? Join us as we bring you the harrowing story of Little Timmy Sterner through the intimate and heart-wrenching accounts of his father, Tim, and his father's girlfriend, Ashley Wethington. From the depths of grief to the highs of cherished memories, this episode peels back the layers o...

Send us Fan Mail Season Ten Premiere! Welcome back to The Murder Police Podcast! As we bid farewell to Season Nine, we are thrilled to dive into Season Ten with renewed vigor and a fresh studio setup.  In this episode, Wendy and David reflect on the journey so far and provide a sneak peek into the gripping cases that will be explored this season. Our hosts take a moment to reminisce about the impa...

Send us Fan Mail What happens when a community's hope clashes with the haunting void left by an unresolved tragedy? Experience the chilling narrative of "Who Killed Letha?" as we welcome Clifford Taylor to share his heartfelt memories and personal connection to the Taylor family. Clifford presents an intimate portrayal of Letha's life, from her childhood nurtured by parents wit...

Send us Fan Mail What if the key to solving a decades-old murder mystery was hidden in plain sight? Join us as we unravel the haunting and intricate story of Letha, a young girl whose sudden disappearance and tragic death have left a community in shock and despair. This episode recounts the frantic search efforts by her family and friends, the chilling discovery of her body under a pile of tin and...

Send us Fan Mail In the latest episode of the Murder Police Podcast, we delve into the heart-wrenching story of Letha, a young woman whose life was cut tragically short. This episode stands out not only for its compelling narrative but also for the emotional depth provided by our special guests, Miss Beverly and Patches, who were Letha’s aunt and cousin, respectively. From the outset, listeners ar...